FoxGames05 wrote:If they did remove the ability it would make the spy SO Much less useful to the Town. I mean yeah it kinda sucks, but it doesn't really give away who mafia is, or the role.
Depending how late in the game it is, it gives exactly who the mafia are, by giving who the mafia aren't. It basically negates almost all RM roles.
Consig - The useful thing of consig is that it lets you know who is or isn't priority to kill. however anyone who's confirmed town is a high priority to kill. The act of checking him, makes the medium or any other normally non threatening role, quite dangerous.
Framer - Yup he does the oposite of what he's supposed to do. If there's a sheriff there's like a 10% chance he'll happen to check the framed person and think he's mafia, if there's a spy there's a 100% chance he will know that the framed person is not mafia.
Disguiser - his ability is barely worth using to begin with, Definently not worth the cost of confirming the person you are disguised asas non-maf.
Forger - well I'll admit it's already a 1 in a thousand chance of actually having what you need to actually pull off a successful forge, But if you happen to do it, the spy see's 2 visits to the killed, and thus knows the will is forged.
Consort - the town immidiately knows there is a consort (after 2 people who were visited by mafia claim RBed), and you certainly can't claim escort after that