orangeandblack5 wrote:Amnesiac should be in its own category, so it can be forced to join town if investigated.
orangeandblack5 wrote:As Godfather, it should be somewhat hard to fake a role if investigated.
TrueGent wrote:Since no one else is elaborating, I might as well give my two cents.
TrueGent wrote:Amnesiac:orangeandblack5 wrote:Amnesiac should be in its own category, so it can be forced to join town if investigated.
This one is a tough choice, however I went for this option as your current Amne result, "Amne, Trans, Surv", already puts the investigated Amne under a lot of pressure if they pick Mafia and Trans is a difficult role to fake so Amnes' that pick Mafia after being invested will probably be lynched anyway.
TrueGent wrote:Godfather:orangeandblack5 wrote:As Godfather, it should be somewhat hard to fake a role if investigated.
I feel your list has already got this down, Sheriff is an easy role to fake so it will be put under a lot of scrutiny if he claims it anyway, especially since the Investigator is already claiming a TI spot.
EDIT:
Ok so I went through the list and made a few changes so Amne could have its own spot. Tell me what you think.
Escort, Consort - Your target is a manipulative beauty. They must be an Escort or Consort.
Investigator, Consigliere - Your target gathers information. They must be an Investigator or Consigliere.
Vigilante, Veteran, Mafioso - Your target owns a gun. They must be a Vigilante, Veteran, or Mafioso.
Framer, Forger - Your target tampers with documents. They must be a Framer, or Forger.
Mayor, Jailor, Spy - Your target puts the Town above all else. They must be the Mayor, Jailor, or a Spy.
TrueGent wrote:Doctor, Serial Killer, Witch - Your target practices their art every night. They must be a Doctor, Serial Killer, or Witch.
Swapped Witch and Vampire as it made more sense for Vampire to be paired with Vampire Hunter.
Vampire Hunter, Vampire, Survivor - Your target holds a grudge. They must be a Vampire Hunter, Vampire or Survivor.
I'm a bit iffy with this one as it depends solely on how good a claim VH is.
TrueGent wrote:Arsonist, Lookout, Blackmailer - You target frequents others' houses. They must be an Arsonist, Lookout, or Blackmailer.
Disguiser, Bodyguard, Werewolf, Transporter - Your target may not be what they seem. They must be a Disguiser, Bodyguard, Werewolf or Transporter.
Put Trans here as its almost insta confirm and neither WW nor Disguiser is going to claim it.
TrueGent wrote:Janitor, Medium, Retributionist, Jester - You target talks to themselves. They must be a Janitor, Medium, Retributionist, or Jester.
Added Ret to this as no evil will ever claim it, and Jester can possibly claim it in order to get lynched.
TrueGent wrote:Sheriff, Godfather, Executioner - Your target wants to gain others' trust. They must be a Sheriff, Godfather, or Executioner.
TrueGent wrote:Amnesiac - Your target does not know what they are. They must be an Amnesiac!
TrueGent wrote:This list has two 4 slots, but at least one of those 4 are no-claims so I think it should be ok.
Kirize wrote:I didnt know you could contradict yourself in one sentencekookeekwisp wrote:Dont single out Arso cause it kills slower!
Gobln wrote:orange i hope you dont let a lot of these scrubs change your original ideas.
Gobln wrote:orange i hope you dont let a lot of these scrubs change your original ideas.
PandACT wrote:Ok, the spy, jailor, mayor thing doesn't work. That would go awry fast. Keep sherrif/ret/exe the same, and leave bg/jailor/whatever alone.
PandACT wrote:Ok, the spy, jailor, mayor thing doesn't work. That would go awry fast. Keep sherrif/ret/exe the same, and leave bg/jailor/whatever alone.
Kiyosen wrote:Gobln wrote:orange i hope you dont let a lot of these scrubs change your original ideas.
I kinda have to agree with this statement. If you can give a good reasoning for your position, then you can make a more valid influence. Though I suggest refuting as much as you can with your current position before changing it.
Though I voted that the Amnesiac shouldn't be in its own category because of how they tend to side with Town and won't be pressured by the Mafia/NK to join them instead. I also voted that it should be a bit hard for the Godfather since they obviously shouldn't get a death sentence.
PandACT wrote:Ok, the spy, jailor, mayor thing doesn't work. That would go awry fast. Keep sherrif/ret/exe the same, and leave bg/jailor/whatever alone.
orangeandblack5 wrote:Amnesiac,Transporter, Survivor - Your target avoids others. They must be an Amnesiac, Transporter, or Survivor.
JammySplodge wrote:orangeandblack5 wrote:Amnesiac,Transporter, Survivor - Your target avoids others. They must be an Amnesiac, Transporter, or Survivor.
I don't see how a transporter avoids others, they visit people
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 20 guests