Guardian Angel change: Your target is always a town member.
New role: Devil’s advocate: Exactly the same as guardian angel but it’s target is always maf, coven, NE or NK
PikamanUltra wrote:The idea is that the guardian angel's target is always town, to make way for the devil's advocate for the evil and neutral roles. GA is guarenteed to be town, not so that it saves them time checking their role, but so that DA has his evil roles.
The GA isnt told whether their target is town or not, if a GA gets a target, they are confirmed town. With my change it is impossible for GA to get any other faction to protect but town.
Brilliand wrote:PikamanUltra wrote:The idea is that the guardian angel's target is always town, to make way for the devil's advocate for the evil and neutral roles. GA is guarenteed to be town, not so that it saves them time checking their role, but so that DA has his evil roles.
The GA isnt told whether their target is town or not, if a GA gets a target, they are confirmed town. With my change it is impossible for GA to get any other faction to protect but town.
This is identical to what I described, except that you show the GA a different role name if he has a non-Town target, which makes no practical difference (except to notify him that he has a non-Town target, and to tell the Town that fact if he happens to die).
The DA is just a GA with different labeling, so you aren't really proposing something new here, just a different label for one of the roles some of the time.
PikamanUltra wrote:Guardian Angel change: Your target is always a town member.
New role: Devil’s advocate: Exactly the same as guardian angel but it’s target is always maf, coven, NE or NK
EvilPudding wrote:Interesting idea and it is balanced like the WW
/support
mikimomo wrote:I think Ga should have Town and NB as a target for sure if this change ever got implemented. I also think GA should have Invincible Defence, as its AN ANGEL. How do you kill a celestial being?
Brilliand wrote:mikimomo wrote:I think Ga should have Town and NB as a target for sure if this change ever got implemented. I also think GA should have Invincible Defence, as its AN ANGEL. How do you kill a celestial being?
Game balance though.
Also, thematically a celestial being shouldn't even be one of the 15 people in the town; it should be in the sky somewhere where no one can visit it or vote it up.
EvilPudding wrote:Interesting idea and it is balanced like the WW
/support
Blackwolfe99 wrote:Again, game balance. Theme is second to mechanics.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 32 guests