Chemist1422 wrote:Okay I reread EoD to see what happened (despite my better judgement)
I don't think tfios is mafia, as they had nothing to gain from not just committing to a Crimson lynch.
I'm not convinced on Proto being town at all, I'm going to cross-meta him between 17F+SFM57 once I finish typing this/after I post it depending on when day starts. I don't like his flipping of reads and the way he popped in with his second post felt like he was waiting for a chance to enter the thread in a non-awkward way, plus being self-aware about stuff.
I think Rick's answer to my question of there being a deepwolf is really interesting and very potentially spewy depending on his alignment, and since tfios/Crimson/Zucker/Goomba are all unlikely mafia/flipped town I think he could be wolf with another deepwolf here, most probably Flake or ejji.
My metaread on Eragon still stands.
I think Uzay's PbPA of Crimson was villagery, even with Crimson flipping town. I need to check if he responded to Crimson's counterpoints.
If there are any other specific reads I come up with I'll post them separately from this, because this was pre-typed during the night.
Flake wrote:oh wait it could be non-mafia or non-sk slip
/vote Flake
Easiest scumslip You are probably Maf/NK that forget no kill credits for A moment
yeah no
at first i was focused on chemist having been more likely to come up with a post like that in mafia chat, which is why at first i said non-mafia specifically
Flake wrote:if you're town and knew you made a slip you don't include the bit about eragon, especially if you truly thought you'd get perceived as scum for doing so
Chemist1422 wrote:I think cupcake's posts are bad and I want to see them respond to pressure
Chemist1422 wrote:By gamestate I'd go crimson over cupcake just because most of the lownull people are going after cupcake over crimson
Cupcake wagon seems more wolf-driven
Also the soft part of my headphones fell off so I'm gonna spend the next 20 minutes trying to fix that bye
This is a hard 180. Before that first post Chemist hardly acknowledged cupcake, then afterwards he proceeded to be against a cupcake lynch.
You said this to me as well, that I had barely acknowledged cupcake, but I don't understand how that's telling you anything. Cupcake had said nothing of value. Though depending on the vc at that point, I can very well see cupcake/chemist. I'll come back to this later. Honestly after reading EOD1 I could see chemist being scum, though I like their D2 posts. They're in my poe pool.
Flake wrote:if you're town and knew you made a slip you don't include the bit about eragon, especially if you truly thought you'd get perceived as scum for doing so
scum get
Logic :
if you're just gonna shade and not progress the game then fuck off
your lack of explanation on literally anything you say is tilting
i was trying to push what i thought could eventually lead to chem being outed; my logic here is perfectly fine considering at the time I thought chemist was saying he knew it'd be a slip on Eragon specifically at the time of writing, and not just potentially a slip on someone
Flake wrote:oh wait it could be non-mafia or non-sk slip
/vote Flake
Easiest scumslip You are probably Maf/NK that forget no kill credits for A moment
yeah no
at first i was focused on chemist having been more likely to come up with a post like that in mafia chat, which is why at first i said non-mafia specifically
Flake wrote:i could easily see mafia!chemist making that tryhard post at night and sending it to his mafia buddies like "do u think this is good )))"
minus the winky face
Okay , I just want to make A test for seeing If You would remember How Did You started The Logic . /unvote TBH I was expecting This explanation with A More emotional answer , but This is enough.
Flake wrote:oh wait it could be non-mafia or non-sk slip
/vote Flake
Easiest scumslip You are probably Maf/NK that forget no kill credits for A moment
What? How did he slip
Him immediatly assuming Eragon was Maf-kill . But he Actually was thinking Chemist may post it at Maf-chat before , so it is not A slip , but rather Than read .
Flake wrote:
UzayAltay wrote:
Flake wrote:if you're town and knew you made a slip you don't include the bit about eragon, especially if you truly thought you'd get perceived as scum for doing so
scum get
Logic :
if you're just gonna shade and not progress the game then fuck off
your lack of explanation on literally anything you say is tilting
i was trying to push what i thought could eventually lead to chem being outed; my logic here is perfectly fine considering at the time I thought chemist was saying he knew it'd be a slip on Eragon specifically at the time of writing, and not just potentially a slip on someone
I really couldnt set The Logic here . And it is not shade , I am not accusing You for bad Logic . I am just saying I cant set up your Logic at there . You are saying as town he would delete The part with Eragon , The thing is , Is not Deleting it make it scum ? I cant see that.
To people who think mine and chemist's interaction is orchestrated
In what world does Mafia come up with
"hey chem, you make a fake slip by including someone who dies you out on it, i'll deepwolf and call you outed scum because i'll say i think you make the slip on someone specifically rather than you knowing the possibility that it could be a slip but not being bothered to remove the slip after the flip of the someone who dies, but then i'll realise it's actually you just knowing the possibility it could be a slip pre-flip and do a completee 180 on you"
Flake wrote:chemist is probably town for not crumbling there
i think he would have if he genuinely faked the slip
Or The scum Which didnt kill Eragon From your Logic .
But I Dont think Chem's slip was AI I know , You was thinking "Chem wouldnt give that reactions as scum "
But , If he planned The slip , He can plan How can he defend after slip, too So I Dont think Chem's posts at there are even AI Chem can be everything with that slip IMO
Rickdaily12 wrote:I need to quickly pop in and let everyone know that I'm going to be unavailable for a few hours. Lost a distant family relative and I'm going to be occupied with family for a bit.
I'm okay, others are not. Will be back soon.
oof hope everything is alright man
+1 ( directly quoting sb else's post due my Englsih )
honestly…. yeah xd I thought that might be the case back when hosting the first purgatory… The 2’nd one kinda confirmed it... There’s a chance our play styles might tend to clash normally and I THINK I might have a tendency to SR you regardless of alignment, but I have no idea how to read you otherwise... If you're town, sorry for that :/ idk if I can do anything about that and tbh I'm not entirely convinced that I should... You’ll prob just have to deal with it at least till I actually figure out if I should be pushing you or not
I think this is coming from mafia!ejji and mafia!rick
"haha yeah sorry i slightly scum read you (only slightly though xx), literally not going to explain why, you can just deal with my scum read on you for no reason"
yeah no
this seems incredibly orchestrated and not real at all
rick literally just doesn't care about being scum read and doesn't push for a reason of any sort which shows his absolute lack of town incentive
Interesting read . I Will Wait for their explanation , First . But I Like The read .
I was actually worried that someone would say I faked it and call me scum for it
so you knew you made a slip
and posted it thinking you'd get called scum faking a slip
in what world does town do that
NGL. This could be a MvM but I guess we will see.
Seems unlikely. They could be able to Do that But What Will be their benefit ? Only benefit is W!Flake now being able to TR Chem freely But they could Do that at some other Ways So it seems hard
Dash2 wrote:Chemist it's not the slip that makes me think you're scum but your logic behind letting the slip happen
I didn't let it happen
I posted it after I had typed the post and forgotten about the slip
Besides, didn't you think I was scum already? It feels like you're trying to justify it with the slip now.
This bad post! Flake said this not Dash. Dash just trying to make sure you legit mafia. You Shade Dash but not Flake. The slip made Dash more Sus You just outted Flake as your scum buddy! ^_^