Moderators: Varanus, FM Game Moderators
Chemist1422 wrote:I have no idea why they didn't lynch the person carrying KP in LyLo
That's like the first rule of not being terrible
Eragon1329 wrote:I’m not saying I played amazing and that I should have won
but lynching me was not the correct town play there
HarperReed wrote:Eragon won in what is the epitome of a "stars aligned" scenario. Not to take credit from Eragon as Harper has said they completely destroyed the social game.
Town didn't play well this is true, but they didn't play wrong. That much Harper would attest to. The plan they used was efficient and in every other scenario than what transpired would have worked
Rickdaily12 wrote:Eragon1329 wrote:I’m not saying I played amazing and that I should have won
but lynching me was not the correct town play there
I disagree with both of you. Turn the 8v3v2 into just a straight forward 8v4 going into the night.
Witch and Escort can fuck with the night kill (note: the former did exactly this even after Eragon lived), and in this offshoot reality, Lookout gets another night to prove themselves with more night results.
I'm not going to reward the decision. Risking the mislynch over taking the confirmed kill almost always results in a blowback for the Town. I've seen it happen plenty of times. I understand why the choice was made, but the end result becomes this more often because it's generally more tactically unsound for the Town. It does usually fuck over the Mafia more, but that's often how it goes.
Really, if 5 Town die in a row, and the worst you look at is "well, we might wake up tomorrow at 7v4 with a few PRs", that's a straight forward issue with the setup. I can virtually just rest my case there.
Rickdaily12 wrote:HarperReed wrote:Eragon won in what is the epitome of a "stars aligned" scenario. Not to take credit from Eragon as Harper has said they completely destroyed the social game.
Town didn't play well this is true, but they didn't play wrong. That much Harper would attest to. The plan they used was efficient and in every other scenario than what transpired would have worked
Shall I refer to you every plan that has gone horribly wrong where a Town member has said exactly this? There are over a dozen buried in the huge stack of games here, bare minimum.
I'm just trying to emphasize that the pattern I've seen: if Town is in dire enough straits that they gamble on lynching anyone but the outted NK, this has resulted in a large number of the NK wins on this site.
HarperReed wrote:Eragon won in what is the epitome of a "stars aligned" scenario. Not to take credit from Eragon as Harper has said they completely destroyed the social game.
Town didn't play well this is true, but they didn't play wrong. That much Harper would attest to. The plan they used was efficient and in every other scenario than what transpired would have worked
EvanManManMan wrote:Every day we descend further into madness
You guys literally let an outed third party win the game
How bad can you be for that to happen
0verki11 wrote:EvanManManMan wrote:Every day we descend further into madness
You guys literally let an outed third party win the game
How bad can you be for that to happen
Eragon1329 wrote:Like honestly
I was confident that jalandh was town
otherwise this might have turned out differently
I was trying to confirm a win between us arso/town
but it wasn't in the cards
Rickdaily12 wrote:I'm just trying to emphasize that the pattern I've seen: if Town is in dire enough straits that they gamble on lynching anyone but the outted NK, this has resulted in a large number of the NK wins on this site.
Crimson97 wrote:If any mafia member voted for the standard, i hope my massive fuckup shows why vanilla was clearly better.
watchme1 wrote:This game was honestly a blast to play. I have a massive post to make later so stay tuned for that
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 152 guests