It's true that it doesn't really do anything when there's no neutrals left, and I did think about the fact that it can't really do anything other than coordinate with neutrals and such, which is really situational, so I'd like to give it an ability to use the nights it doesn't talk to anyone, but I can't really think of anything it could do that other mafia roles can't already do, I'd like some suggestions for things it could do on non-negotiating nights, since I can't think of a unique ability that won't just make it a better version of another mafia role
SkyW wrote:Here's the problem.
Reveal townie's role to town: "Thanks mafia! Now we have a confirmed town member that we can all whisper claim too and win the fucking game! TP/LO stay on them!"
Reveal neutral's role to town: "Thanks mafia! Now we have a confirmed evil we can hang, then focus more on taking down the mafia!"
The only way this role is beneficial (since it doesn't even role block) is if you talk to someone and they reveal that they are NE/NB to you, but you won't actually know if they're lying or not unless you reveal them to the town... and then your potential ally is either hanged or rallied around.
/nosupport.
Well, here's the thing, you're supposed to be careful when revealing roles, so you don't accidentally reveal a townie, the role obviously works best with a consig to tell you who's who, but even without one you could be able to deduce who is what, and try to coordinate with them, the risk of revealing a townie is very much intentional, and as for revealing neutrals, it's like deathnotes revealing who is immune, you don't always want to reveal that kind of information right away, but more toward mid-game, when mafia can kill enough people to not need NK anymore, or to give a mafia member in trouble one more day to avoid being hung
But yeah, I think it might be too weak atm, since it can't do anything except that, so any suggestions for changes to the ability/adding a night ability for when you don't negotiate would be nice, thanks for the feedback!