MafiaMenace wrote:Neutral Trans.
Why.
Mystoc wrote:MafiaMenace wrote:Neutral Trans.
Why.
so trans cant be confirmed anymore
and also to cause chaos since its goal is to cause deaths, it will be messing up what boths sides are trying to do so it has no allies its not town sided or evil sided its perfect
mafia won't like this cause it messes with who they try to kill and town wont like this role because it tries to get them killed and messes up invest results, it also makes transporters not trustworthy anymore
its fills it role perfectly has being a chaotic role that has no allies, the real question is why not? cause i'm seeing a ton of reasons why
MafiaMenace wrote:Mystoc wrote:MafiaMenace wrote:Neutral Trans.
Why.
so trans cant be confirmed anymore
and also to cause chaos since its goal is to cause deaths, it will be messing up what boths sides are trying to do so it has no allies its not town sided or evil sided its perfect
mafia won't like this cause it messes with who they try to kill and town wont like this role because it tries to get them killed and messes up invest results, it also makes transporters not trustworthy anymore
its fills it role perfectly has being a chaotic role that has no allies, the real question is why not? cause i'm seeing a ton of reasons why
I know that much.
I still don't like the fact of a neutral trans.
Mystoc wrote:MafiaMenace wrote:Mystoc wrote:MafiaMenace wrote:Neutral Trans.
Why.
so trans cant be confirmed anymore
and also to cause chaos since its goal is to cause deaths, it will be messing up what boths sides are trying to do so it has no allies its not town sided or evil sided its perfect
mafia won't like this cause it messes with who they try to kill and town wont like this role because it tries to get them killed and messes up invest results, it also makes transporters not trustworthy anymore
its fills it role perfectly has being a chaotic role that has no allies, the real question is why not? cause i'm seeing a ton of reasons why
I know that much.
I still don't like the fact of a neutral trans.
being unable to tell me why you don't like it is not helpful feedback. why do you feel its a bad idea to add to the game what part of it don't you like?
I don't like the fact of how it is a copy of a town role, just adding a role for the sake of taking away conformation is not good.
An example of a good copy is Consort, it actually helps mafia and takes away conformation
Mystoc wrote:I don't like the fact of how it is a copy of a town role, just adding a role for the sake of taking away conformation is not good.
An example of a good copy is Consort, it actually helps mafia and takes away conformation
-it's not a carbon copy though it cant move itself and its win condition is unique and it leaves after it wins, it's a good enough copy to be able fake being transporter but it isn't a copy and paste of it I never said an exact copy, but still basically the same.
-it does other things too though besides that it isn't their just to make transporter unconfirmable,
-its goal is to basically cause people to die who wouldn't of otherwise done so, while transporters goal is to help town win by moving town who will be attacked and making evil people attack themselves/ their allies
-its there to cause and make people do things they didn't want to do it equally helps and hurts both sides that why its perfect
-you are basing consort on being a good role based on the fact it as allies to help win with its ability? Well yes, I'd say something that is faction aligned is a good role if it helps it's allies. so just cause my role has no allies it's not a good role? That is not what I said at all. Can you point out specific abilities/attributes about the role that is different from Trans other than the fact that it can't move itself? I just don't have a liking for neutral copies of town, it just doesn't fit.
-its abilities to move others is cleary tied to its goal, its ability helps it win, like consorts ability helps mafia win, what difference does having allies have? Nothing. I never said there was a difference.
That is not what I said at all. Can you point out specific abilities/attributes about the role that is different from Trans other than the fact that it can't move itself?
Mystoc wrote:That is not what I said at all. Can you point out specific abilities/attributes about the role that is different from Trans other than the fact that it can't move itself?
well after it wins it leaves the game that's in the attributes :p
but i get what your trying to say, yes the ability and attributes are very close to being the exact same as transporter , but its the goal the makes this role completely different from transporter
it's different from trans because its goal is different, it will use this ability to move people in a much different way then a trans would, this will alter the game in way a transporter wouldn't because wants my role wants to cause deaths to happen instead of saving a another townie from dying, this a good goal because it isn't town or evil sided its disrupts them both equally and it can equally cause them to die when they wouldnt of normally
=====================================
edit
you say my role is bad because its abilities and attributes are close to being the exact same as transport but the ONLY difference between consort and escort is their goals while my role does have small differences then that of transporter. but then say my role is bad because its close to being the same role has transporter but consort IS an exact copy
-It seems to me based on your logic consort would be a bad role too, but you say it isn't just because its has teammates,
-so by your logic if i made this role a mafia role with mafias goals it would be a good role then? (i wouldn't do this because it would be OP it's just an hypothetical question to get you to see my point)
My alarm was set for PM not AM, goodbye sleep because I am fully awake now, at least you get to see my reply early now.
I guess I see your point, but I just have a problem I can't exactly explain with neutral copies of town/mafia/coven, it just doesn't fit right, it doesn't belong to me.
Mystoc wrote:My alarm was set for PM not AM, goodbye sleep because I am fully awake now, at least you get to see my reply early now.
I guess I see your point, but I just have a problem I can't exactly explain with neutral copies of town/mafia/coven, it just doesn't fit right, it doesn't belong to me.
i think the part you don't like is it isn't a fully original idea, since it copies part of an existing role and i totally get that, the thing is this role does add new aspects to the game besides just removing transporter''s confirmability
so i can respect that opinion so lets agree to disagree on this? have a good night's sleep.
DragonClaw66 wrote:I've never actually been opposed to a Neutral Transporter but this doesn't really reduce confirmability that much.
(1) It cannot transport itself. This means that if a Transporter transports two other players in one night, they can confirm themselves.
(2) This role is Neutral Chaos. This means it cannot appear in Ranked, so all Transporters in Ranked games are still confirmed.
Mystoc wrote:DragonClaw66 wrote:I've never actually been opposed to a Neutral Transporter but this doesn't really reduce confirmability that much.
(1) It cannot transport itself. This means that if a Transporter transports two other players in one night, they can confirm themselves.
(2) This role is Neutral Chaos. This means it cannot appear in Ranked, so all Transporters in Ranked games are still confirmed.
this role can still transport two people though in one night though, it not being able to move itself doesnt mean it cant move two people in one night
well i wanted it to be NE but it hurts evils too so it cant be NE,
i'm just gonna assume the ranked rolelist is gonna be reworked at some point before this role is added so NE and NC can interchangeably be allowed to roll, but for now theres no good solution to this role not appearing a lot in current ranked
KingArmaan wrote:If there would be trans and then a neutral trans, the game would be too chaotic. Also like stated by MafiaMenace, this is not like Consort, which is to balance the game and help a faction, and is just a role on its own that is a rehash of another role. If this and trans were to be in one game, there will be so many transportations that people wouldn't be able to visit the target they want or the chances will be reduced a lot.
Yes this an Neutral version of the town transporter and is a very simple role but also gets rid of transporter being able to confirm itself, I also believe I have taken the right approach to this role it is NOT part of any faction and its goal is unique and it adds different aspects to the game that a transporter normally wouldn't! so read the full role before commenting!
Helicooler wrote:I heard neutral transporter?
Don't. The first time someone suggested it it became such a joke that the thread was just people asking for things like jester survivor. It adds more chaos and trollyness to a role that has the ability to vet bait and then kill a randomer.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 12 guests