Amythyr wrote:/support
Also add a arso achievement to ignite jailed target
Meh, why not? Edited.
Amythyr wrote:/support
Also add a arso achievement to ignite jailed target
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
NettoTakashi wrote:For the most part, I /support this. However, some of your suggested achievements would be hell to code, some would still be hell to achieve, and one or two... still encourage bad play?
This is gonna be a long one... so I'll stick it in a Spoiler.
Spoiler:
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
DragoWhooves wrote:how about an arso achievement for killing 10+ players in one night?
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
qwertyuiopl wrote:I have an idea... How about "secret achievements"? I.e., ones where you don't know what they are until you get them. Be in a game with all default names could be one, as could the "invincible object VS unstoppable force" juggernaut/pestilence thing. Idk about others, I'll try to think of some.
Also, should the "default names" achievement be changed to "15 default names" or no? Otherwise, it'd be pretty easy for people to get in rapid mode.
Thanks
UzayAltay wrote:First , /support
Second , I have something to added to achievements , and will write to here .
Spoiler:
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Purple998 wrote:/Bump
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Joacgroso wrote:So... I have a few suggestions about achievements and I wanted to post them here. If you have another suggestion about adding/removing/reworking achievements, please post it here
First of all, every role should have an achievement for getting all its achievements. If a player gets that achievement, he should be rewarded with a lobby icon of the role (not the face of the skin. I mean the picture that appears at the left of the achievements). There should also be an achievement for having ALL achievements for ALL roles, which should be rewarded with something REALLY good. Of course, there should also be "Get all achievements of X faction".-Role-Master/b]
Secondly, I would like to suggest the "[b]loop" achievements. Players would be able to get this achievements infinite times, so they can be rewarded for their good plays. Also, once you get the achievement for winning 25 times with a role, the achievement for winning 5 times should become a loop achievement.
And finally, achievements should be displayed AFTER a game ends, so they can't spoil you the roles of certain players.
Now that I suggested it, I would like to show how the achievement list would be (I will only write the achievements that should be added/removed/modified. I won't write the "win x times" or "get all achievements" achievements):
Spoiler:
And that's it. To sum up, what I suggest is:
- Add loop achievemnts.
- Remove gamethrowing/silly achievements.
- Give achievements for having all achievements.
- Add achievements based on skill and helping your team.
- Display achievements after the game ends, so they can't spoil you the roles of other players
- Also, as qwertyuiopl suggested, you should only get your achievement if you are connected during the end of the game. This would discourage players to leave the game.
What do you think about this? What achievements would you add/remove/rework? Please give me feedback in the replies. Thanks you
edit1: If you have all the achievements of a role, you should get a 50% discount for its scrolls.
edit2: Added new achievement for SK.
edit3: Added the elo achievement that Purple998 suggested.
edit4: Added "be in a game where everyone has a default name", and "win a duel against a serial killer".
edit5: Added achievements for juggernaut.
edit6: Added "kill 2 mafia members in one night" and replaced "kill 2 coven members in one night" with "kill a coven member who was being healed by the PM", for juggernaut.
edit7: Replaced "have a solo win without kingmakers" with "have a solo win without a kingmaking scenario and without killing witches or survivors (doesn't apply if you won against another NK)" for neutral killing roles.
edit8: Added "ignite a jailed player" for arsonist.
edit9: Replaced "Visist sk while being guarded" with "visit sk while being healed" for escorts. Removed "jail an attacked player 3 times in a game" for jailor. Replaced "attack 5 evildoers in one game" with "attack 3 evildoers in 1 game", for crusader. Removed "save the mafioso from dying" for gf, since it encourages gamethrowing. Replaced "kill 3 town power in the first 3 nights" with "kill 2 town power roles in the first 3 nights" for gf. Removed "clean a juggernaut" for janitor. Removed "make the jailor think he was roleblocked and jail his target again" for hypnotist. Removed "kill a sheriff who was going to visit a mafia member" and "kill 3 TIs that were going to visit mafia members in a game" for ambusher, because he can't visit mafia members (but he should). Added "survive until the end with someone with your role" for SK and arsonists. Replaced "Bite 3 players in 1 game (loop)" with "start a game as a solo vampire and end it with at least 4 vampires in your team (loop)" for vampires. Replaced "win a game where you killed 2 players each full moon night (loop)" with "win a game having a KPN of 1 (loop)" for werewolves. Removed "win a duel against a SK" for pirates because it encourages a bad play. Replaced "save 5 coven members in a game (loop)" with "save 2 coven members in a game (loop)" for potion masters. Removed "reanimate a jester" for necromancers, because it's impossible.
edit10: Replaced "be in a game where everyone has a default name" with "be in a game where 15 players have a default name". Added "ressurrect the mayor" and "ressurrect a transporter" and removed "ressurrect a sheriff" for retributionists. Added "control the jailor into not executing a serial killer" and "control a bodyguard into dying to kill a vigilante while protecting an evildoer" for witch/coven leader. Added "heal a bodyguard who was going to die protecting his target" for doctors.
UzayAltay wrote:Joacgroso wrote: Spoiler:
Names on bold .
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
qwertyuiopl wrote:"Everyone hates me"- Have every living player vote guilty on you as jester - I don't like the part of "every living player". This could be pretty easy if you reach a kingmaking scenario vs only 2 players
"I'm your boss now"- successfully remember godfather, bumping a Mafioso down to second-in-command. Are you sure this is possible?
"Live to die another day"- get attacked but don't die as jester. Applies to all direct forms of protection, including jailings, but not transportation and witches. Sounds good.
"Déjà vu"- Execute two godfathers in one game. I'm not really sure if this one is needed. Jailor already has flawless executioner
"Go hang yourself"- lynch someone as mayor in a 1v1 situation Please no! This is like winning without revealing. It would make mayors don't reveal in order to get this. Doing this is awesome, but it shouldn't be encouraged.
"Tricked you!" Be acquitted as an evildoer (not jester though, lol) with at least 7 innocent votes. Great idea! But I would change it to "be acquitted with at least 5 innocent votes from townies. Otherwise it would be too easy.
"The sole survivor"- be the last player standing as survivor. I already added this.
"Too controlling"- be the last player standing as Witch. Not sure. Witches are supposed to help evils. I don't think encouraging them to hurt evils is a good idea. This could lead to gamethrowing, which would lead to evils always wanting to kill witches.
"AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!"- Have the graveyard be completely full with you having been lynched as jester. Although this seems fine, how would you manage to do this after being lynched?
[Need a name]- be the last player alive as Executioner (note that in order to still be exe with everyone dead, your target must already have been lynched). Exe's can't kill, so this could only happen for reasons out of their control.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
JGaming08 wrote:My only real issue with it is this -Joacgroso wrote:- Remove "win with another SK"
-Survive until the end with another SK still alive. - Knife team
It just makes it unnecessarily harder.
Apart from that - /Support
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
DragonClaw66 wrote:Amnesiac
Diseased Mind: Remember that you were Pestilence. Amnes already have "remember NK". Although Pest is NC, I consider it a NK.
Magic Remembrance: Remember that you were a member of the Coven. Sounds good
Arsonist
Fiery Friend: Ignite more players than you doused. Sounds good
Coven Leader
Playing With Fire: Control an Arsonist into dousing themselves and let another Arsonist incinerate them (this doesn't need to happen on the same night). Seems too complicated. The arso would just clean the gas off of himself.
Disguiser
Quite a Trickster: Have a Retributionist attempt to revive you. I love this
Jester
The Haunting: Get yourself lynched on Day 2. I can't believe I forgot to add this.
Plaguebearer/Pestilence
A Speedy Start: Infect a Transporter as your first victim. Seems too luck based in my opinion.
Veteran
Vigilant, Not Vigilante: Shoot a Witch that tried to control you. Good idea, but should also apply to coven leader.
Werewolf
The Alpha: Maul the Mayor, Coven Leader, and Godfather in one game. Why would the coven leader control the mayor in a mafia game? And in a ww game? Seems too complicated to me.
Witch
It's Not Your Decision: Control the Jailor into executing a Town member. I'm pretty sure I've already suggested this.
Light of the Full Moon: Control a Townie into the rampage of a Werewolf. Sounds good
The Horseman's Rage: Control a Townie into the rampage of Pestilence. Sounds good. It should also apply if you make him vistit Pestilence.
DistractDEAD: Control an Escort into roleblocking the Serial Killer. Sounds good, I guess.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests