Kirize wrote:I didnt know you could contradict yourself in one sentencekookeekwisp wrote:Dont single out Arso cause it kills slower!
kookeekwisp wrote:It just hit me... This role is crap!
(before i get hate, Crap means UP, not bad) Compare it to every other TI. We got a surefire pinpointer, an accurate role viewer, an all-hearing informant, a murder witness, And an extremely vague speculator.
This is why you need multiple categories, and heavy Town in lower ones.
and out of the sum ups of the roles you said above, what I would like as an end result is this role to not find evils but find people to trustHAVE MORE CATEGORIES!!!
randomguyhavingfun wrote:Ok I got an idea. Have 2 versions, one with the current idea and one with an alignment inspector. Now here is how I thought it would work:
1Your target has an observative altitude investigatives amd deceptive
2Your target has a supportive altitude supports
3Your target has a determined altitude protectives and killings
4 your target has a mysterious altitude evils benigns and chaoses
You will get who is more trusted like normal
If both of your targets have the same altitude their altitude will be revealed to you
Massive buff idea. Keeps it claimable but makes it a more usefull. Just thought of it as an alternate version and not a replacement
BS4125 wrote:randomguyhavingfun wrote:Ok I got an idea. Have 2 versions, one with the current idea and one with an alignment inspector. Now here is how I thought it would work:
1Your target has an observative altitude investigatives amd deceptive
2Your target has a supportive altitude supports
3Your target has a determined altitude protectives and killings
4 your target has a mysterious altitude evils benigns and chaoses
You will get who is more trusted like normal
If both of your targets have the same altitude their altitude will be revealed to you
Massive buff idea. Keeps it claimable but makes it a more usefull. Just thought of it as an alternate version and not a replacement
I feel this role could work as an entirely separate one than this one as these attributes you gave are very different to them currently but I really like this idea for a role. Because you came up with the idea yourself and without anyone I think you should publish this role as your own and I'll support you with it because I think it's very clever and balenced atm but I think I'll stay with this idea for now and experiment with more categories for Trusted roles
randomguyhavingfun wrote:BS4125 wrote:randomguyhavingfun wrote:Ok I got an idea. Have 2 versions, one with the current idea and one with an alignment inspector. Now here is how I thought it would work:
1Your target has an observative altitude investigatives amd deceptive
2Your target has a supportive altitude supports
3Your target has a determined altitude protectives and killings
4 your target has a mysterious altitude evils benigns and chaoses
You will get who is more trusted like normal
If both of your targets have the same altitude their altitude will be revealed to you
Massive buff idea. Keeps it claimable but makes it a more usefull. Just thought of it as an alternate version and not a replacement
I feel this role could work as an entirely separate one than this one as these attributes you gave are very different to them currently but I really like this idea for a role. Because you came up with the idea yourself and without anyone I think you should publish this role as your own and I'll support you with it because I think it's very clever and balenced atm but I think I'll stay with this idea for now and experiment with more categories for Trusted roles
Cool, I understand. Gotta tweak with it before it's an actuall role because right now it's in a grey are between your role and a new one. Can't wait to see the changes you make though
BS4125 wrote:randomguyhavingfun wrote:BS4125 wrote:randomguyhavingfun wrote:Ok I got an idea. Have 2 versions, one with the current idea and one with an alignment inspector. Now here is how I thought it would work:
1Your target has an observative altitude investigatives amd deceptive
2Your target has a supportive altitude supports
3Your target has a determined altitude protectives and killings
4 your target has a mysterious altitude evils benigns and chaoses
You will get who is more trusted like normal
If both of your targets have the same altitude their altitude will be revealed to you
Massive buff idea. Keeps it claimable but makes it a more usefull. Just thought of it as an alternate version and not a replacement
I feel this role could work as an entirely separate one than this one as these attributes you gave are very different to them currently but I really like this idea for a role. Because you came up with the idea yourself and without anyone I think you should publish this role as your own and I'll support you with it because I think it's very clever and balenced atm but I think I'll stay with this idea for now and experiment with more categories for Trusted roles
Cool, I understand. Gotta tweak with it before it's an actuall role because right now it's in a grey are between your role and a new one. Can't wait to see the changes you make though
Still working on it, I just need to shuffle some roles around so each group has claimspace available
randomguyhavingfun wrote:BS4125 wrote:randomguyhavingfun wrote:BS4125 wrote:randomguyhavingfun wrote:Ok I got an idea. Have 2 versions, one with the current idea and one with an alignment inspector. Now here is how I thought it would work:
1Your target has an observative altitude investigatives amd deceptive
2Your target has a supportive altitude supports
3Your target has a determined altitude protectives and killings
4 your target has a mysterious altitude evils benigns and chaoses
You will get who is more trusted like normal
If both of your targets have the same altitude their altitude will be revealed to you
Massive buff idea. Keeps it claimable but makes it a more usefull. Just thought of it as an alternate version and not a replacement
I feel this role could work as an entirely separate one than this one as these attributes you gave are very different to them currently but I really like this idea for a role. Because you came up with the idea yourself and without anyone I think you should publish this role as your own and I'll support you with it because I think it's very clever and balenced atm but I think I'll stay with this idea for now and experiment with more categories for Trusted roles
Cool, I understand. Gotta tweak with it before it's an actuall role because right now it's in a grey are between your role and a new one. Can't wait to see the changes you make though
Still working on it, I just need to shuffle some roles around so each group has claimspace available
Just not too much because we are meant to give this guy a buff. Try considering invests results and splitting some roles from there apart.
Kirize wrote:I didnt know you could contradict yourself in one sentencekookeekwisp wrote:Dont single out Arso cause it kills slower!
kookeekwisp wrote:I already told you my feedback. Literally all you did was put more categories, and they're WAY TOO BALANCED!
Investigator knows which role group their target's in, and it's meant to be completely balanced.
This role doesn't know what category either role's in. Combined with a balanced list, this role is one of the most UP ideas in all of history. (and why does the least trusted category have more Town than the third list?)
Make the list less even, or this role is horribly UP.
randomguyhavingfun wrote:I think you should swap disguiser and sk and move janitor down 2-3 categories. Otherwise they are pretty good
randomguyhavingfun wrote:Would like a vh and sk change but it's up to you. These are looking pretty solid
BS4125 wrote:randomguyhavingfun wrote:Would like a vh and sk change but it's up to you. These are looking pretty solid
We'll see for now, if SK and VH were to swap though then third will have more scum than the forth but I am thinking about moving VH into the lowest result as Vampires with Vampire Hunters should go together as it is a good claim for Vamps
randomguyhavingfun wrote:BS4125 wrote:randomguyhavingfun wrote:Would like a vh and sk change but it's up to you. These are looking pretty solid
We'll see for now, if SK and VH were to swap though then third will have more scum than the forth but I am thinking about moving VH into the lowest result as Vampires with Vampire Hunters should go together as it is a good claim for Vamps
I think this s counteracted by the fact that 3 has 3 good claims in it and 4 has mafioso. If you are worried but want to implement this you can always try getting the consort in 4
BlazinIce wrote:Move Bodyguard to the 2nd level. Otherwise, good.
ArrivedRocket wrote:I think that the trust level for werewolf should be fairly high, but when it is a full moon they change to untrustworthy, similar how the results change for the sheriff
Other than that I think this could be a great addition!
/support
BS4125 wrote:The thing is the majority of the time when you visit a Werewolf you die anyway unless a Doctor heals you but even then it just makes it really complicated for just a small buff. Thanks for the feedback though
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 10 guests