Jerme wrote:This suggestiosn seems interesting, I like it. I have a few questions:
- Does a survivor lose also their vests or is this the only role which does not lose their charges?
- Does a Mayor regain their votes when the Auditor dies?
- What do you think about this Consigliere result: "Your target removes items when visiting. They must be an Auditor"?
lucas8411 wrote:This role is really good, the only negative thing about this if there are no limited roles (and Mayor). The ability is useless but besides that you did a good job
oliy wrote:It doesn't do anything to VH :\
Oh no, not the Disguiser!
TBH this role has too few downsides for it's upsides.
Also, at least Witch can somewhat protect itself from killers, this cannot.
Finally, you just need to roleblock specific roles, so you're useless near the end of the game.
It's eh.
matthew8367 wrote:(Potentially: Roleblock on audit, Demotes VH to Vigi with a bullet)
Mroz4k wrote:Actually not a bad role.
Its a Neutral Evil role, thats for sure. I mean, it screws everyone but the Neutrals (well, it does screw over Survivor too, which is not such a bad idea). And it has the Witch´s win conditions, so it encourages to work against the Town. Can put a hurt on Mafia, same as Witch.
Sure, the abilities are limited and the role has the role dependency on the rolelist, but it can still win, just played like a Goon. And its existence is putting some balance to the game, actually making the Neutral Killing a little bit more likely to win as well... I am all up for this role.
Just the name is weird. I mean, the description has nothing to do with auditors, makes me wonder if you even know what Auditors are and what they do. Anyways thats kind of besides the point.
Also should most definitedly be a Unique role.
One thing where it doesnt make much sense in general is Mayor. I dont see the point to take away that powers. I mean, in this way, the role is kind of a hard-counter to Mayor abilities, and those abilities are not even such a problem for the game... its more of a confirmability thats the problem.
I´d say that there should be no effect on the Mayor, or if, it should make Mayor unable to reveal. Maybe tie them down in a way that Mayor cannot reveal for as long as the Auditor is still alive, or something like that. Would be better way to go about that.
Survivors SHOULD lose all the Vests. Puts something to worry into the mind of a Survivor, makes them think twice before revealing. That makes winning as Survivor more challenging, and gives more space to evil roles as whole.
matthew8367 wrote:oliy wrote:It doesn't do anything to VH :\
Oh no, not the Disguiser!
TBH this role has too few downsides for it's upsides.
Also, at least Witch can somewhat protect itself from killers, this cannot.
Finally, you just need to roleblock specific roles, so you're useless near the end of the game.
It's eh.matthew8367 wrote:(Potentially: Roleblock on audit, Demotes VH to Vigi with a bullet)
Now what do you think?
oliy wrote:It doesn't do anything to VH :\
Oh no, not the Disguiser!
TBH this role has too few downsides for it's upsides.
Also, at least Witch can somewhat protect itself from killers, this cannot.
Finally, you just need to roleblock specific roles, so you're useless near the end of the game.
It's eh.
matthew8367 wrote:@oliy Can you explain please?
@BPsycho That is in no way balanced. Witch can also deal damage to Mafia, more than Auditor can.
BPsycho2 wrote:matthew8367 wrote:@oliy Can you explain please?
@BPsycho That is in no way balanced. Witch can also deal damage to Mafia, more than Auditor can.
Wouldn't it make sense in that The Auditor works with money?
BPsycho2 wrote:I know that, but
(I'm not gonna win this, am I?)
Truecore wrote:Since you guys were talking about survivors being audited...
___________________________________
Role Name: Scumbag
Role Alignment: Neutral Chaos
Attributes: None
Abilities: None
Goal: Survive to see the Town lose the game
Wins with: Everyone that isn't Town
Special Attributes: None
Investigative Results: ??
Additional Information (comments): Cannot be randomed. Can only appear as a result of a neutral role being audited. (In sc2 mafia, if a neutral role gets audited, it becomes a scumbag. Usually, being a scumbag is REALLY REALLY BAD.)
BPsycho2 wrote:I personally think the Audit should only affect town roles because auditing is a financial evaluation, and the Mafia have the money to prevent being Audited.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 14 guests