Bodyguard Counter Claims

[Fluxling]

Classic mode.
Player 1 is asked a role and claims BG.
Player 2 then CC's that without anyone having paid attention to him before then.
There are two dead jesters in the graveyard, so being a jester is not an option.
Naturally, RT is still unknown.
Who is most likely to be the Godfather?

[BlastingOff]

In most scenarios, player 1 is the GF. However, there are cases where Mafia will purposelly CC town claims to get them mislynched and get kills faster.

[YecatsMailbox]

This happened to me yesterday.
I was the Bodyguard (RT.)
Both jesters were already dead.
Framer was also dead - and his will said "Fear is GF, Blahblah is mafioso."
Investigator asked me the next day, what are you? I said I'm BG.
Fear said "I CC BG!"
Guess who the town hung?
Guess who was really BG?

[itaicool]

I will say 1 is the GF, since most evils aren't playing very smart in my opinion. They mostly stay quiet unless asked something.

[XxCottonCandyxX]

I'd say player 1 was gf unless maf would gain majority the next day if someone was lynched that day. Then I say it's 50-50.

[Amythyr]

I have actually cc'd TP claims and lynched the last TP as Mafia. It is Risk vs Reward scenario.