What's your best role in each category?

[katagma]

My best town role is Jailor with 43 wins. This might suggest that I'm a good jailor.
My best mafia role is Godfather with 20. This suggests that I am a good mafia leader. This was also the first role I ever played as.
My best neutral role is Vampire with 12 This is because vampire is a role where you can be converted from a town role into a neutral killing role.

[Descender]

My best town role is Jailor with 43 wins. This might suggest that I'm a good jailor.
My best mafia role is Godfather with 20
My best neutral role is Vampire with 12

town? It's either mayor or transporter (I reveal d1 as mayor, always transporting with trans)
mafia? it's a tie between framer and disg lul
neutral? arsonist followed by vampire

arso and vampire are my top wins

[katagma]

My best town role is Jailor with 43 wins. This might suggest that I'm a good jailor.
My best mafia role is Godfather with 20
My best neutral role is Vampire with 12

town? It's either mayor or transporter (I reveal d1 as mayor, always transporting with trans)
mafia? it's a tie between framer and disg lul
neutral? arsonist followed by vampire

arso and vampire are my top wins

That's actually really funny because mayor is the town role that I have the least amount of wins with (suggesting that I either suck at it or I haven't been mayor as often.) Other than vampire hunter, it is the only town role that I've won with less than ten times.

I've also always found disguiser hard to win as, mostly because it requires a consigliere to be useful and you have to die as well.

Do you play a lot of all any, because arsonist is significantly easier to win in all any.

[DragonClaw66]

Most Town Wins: Sheriff - 46

Least Town Wins (Excluding Vampire Hunter): Transporter - 11

Most Mafia Wins: Godfather - 46

Least Mafia Wins: Blackmailer - 5

Most Neutral Killing Wins: Werewolf - 8

Least Neutral Killing Wins: Serial Killer - 5

Most Neutral Evil Wins: Executioner - 11

Least Neutral Evil Wins: Witch - 9

[kyuss420]

Town- Doc - 329 wins
Mafia - mafioso - 53 wins
Coven - Coven leader - 200 wins
Nuetral Benign- Guardian Angel - 413 wins
Neutral Chaos - Pirate - 202 wins
NK - WW and Pestilence - both at 63 wins

[GillsterCQ]

Most Town Wins - Lookout - 71
Least Town Wins - Transporter - 25

Most Mafia Wins - Mafioso - 45
Least Mafia Wins - Forger - 5

Most Neutral Killing Wins - Serial Killer - 5
Least Neutral Killing Wins - Werewolf - 2

Most Neutral Evil Wins - Jester - 14
Least Neutral Evil Wins - Witch - 8

[BlastingOff]

Town: Jailor and Veteran (For Jailor, I always reveal D1 and start Jailor Meta and just win, for Veteran, I always get at least one evil dead every game. In one All/Any game, I was able to kill every evil in one night because I baited them all, and thus won).

Mafia: Perhaps Consigliere, in most cases I fool the Town for some time.

Neutral: Probably Jester, I generally can see what would annoy the Town I am playing with into lynching me.

[Manona24]

Town: Jailor is my best role (81 wins)
Mafia: Godfather (51 wins)
Neutral: Jester (21 wins)

[Descender]

My best town role is Jailor with 43 wins. This might suggest that I'm a good jailor.
My best mafia role is Godfather with 20
My best neutral role is Vampire with 12

town? It's either mayor or transporter (I reveal d1 as mayor, always transporting with trans)
mafia? it's a tie between framer and disg lul
neutral? arsonist followed by vampire

arso and vampire are my top wins

That's actually really funny because mayor is the town role that I have the least amount of wins with (suggesting that I either suck at it or I haven't been mayor as often.) Other than vampire hunter, it is the only town role that I've won with less than ten times.

I've also always found disguiser hard to win as, mostly because it requires a consigliere to be useful and you have to die as well.

Do you play a lot of all any, because arsonist is significantly easier to win in all any.

Im an AA lad once I finally get my trusted back I might liven up the strategic discussion

[BlastingOff]

Town: Jailor and probs Vet, I remember as Vet I once killed all evils (which were around 4) in one night in AA
Mafia: Consigliere, I generally "confirm" myself quite easily
Neutral: Jester, I know how to annoy people

[BreezyPonie]

Town: Jailor @ 50
Mafia: Mafioso @ 51
Neutral: Surprise surprise, Vampire @ 66. I'm fairly certain that this is true for about 80% of players, at least. (Survivor is second highest @ 36.)

[peterparker]

My best town role is Jailor with 43 wins. This might suggest that I'm a good jailor.
My best mafia role is Godfather with 20. This suggests that I am a good mafia leader. This was also the first role I ever played as.
My best neutral role is Vampire with 12 This is because vampire is a role where you can be converted from a town role into a neutral killing role.

Statistically...
Town: IDK, probably Jailor. Id say i have above average judgement with that role.

Mafia: Framer, Not sure why.

Neutral: Serial Killer. Easy role, easy win.

[Duckferno]

My most wins with Town role is Transporter with 67 wins.

My most wins with a Mafia role is Consigliere with 91 wins.

My most wins with a Neutral role is Arsonist with 112 wins. (First Role Played, and Won With)

I'm Still waiting on Coven Expansion Statistics. I'm pretty sure I have 50 wins with Necromancer.

[Amythyr]

My best are:

TI: Tracker and Lookout(tracker is slightly ahead)
TP: Crusader
TK: Vig and Jailor
TS: Transporter

Mafia
Disguiser, Blackmailer

NK
Arso

Coven
Coven Leader
Hex in VIP and Necro in All Any

Neutral Benign
Survivor

Neutral Evil
Jester

[Duckferno]

Town- Doc - 329 wins
Mafia - mafioso - 53 wins
Coven - Coven leader - 200 wins
Nuetral Benign- Guardian Angel - 413 wins
Neutral Chaos - Pirate - 202 wins
NK - WW and Pestilence - both at 63 wins

How do you know your coven statistics? Whenever I try to look it says it's coming soon.

[Yummysht]

Jailor , GF and Jester

[dancinghippos]

Most wins with Town role is Jailor (61)

Most wins with a Mafia role is Godfather with 56 wins.

My most wins with a Neutral role is Jester with 31 wins.

[wozearly]

My best town role is Jailor with 43 wins. This might suggest that I'm a good jailor.
My best mafia role is Godfather with 20. This suggests that I am a good mafia leader. This was also the first role I ever played as.
My best neutral role is Vampire with 12 This is because vampire is a role where you can be converted from a town role into a neutral killing role.

How useful number of wins is in judging if you're good at a role honestly depends a heck of a lot on what gamemodes you play.

If you're a Ranked player, you'll find that you'll roll Jailor more frequently than a lot of other roles. Godfather and Mafioso will be roughly half the volume of Jailor rolls. NE and NK will be roughly 1/3rd of the Jailor rolls. So objectively you should have more Jailor, Godfather and Mafioso wins than most other roles.

Similarly, to a Ranked player, having 43 Jailor wins is only marginally better than 20 Godfather wins if you were comparing yourself between the two roles. And given Town's ludicrously high winrate, 20 Godfather wins would suggest you're more likely to be one of those rare people who is a far better Mafia than Town player.


Speaking personally, I'm objectively pretty good as Spy, Investigator and Transporter. I'm a terrible Mayor and, it appears, not that hot as Lookout.

Oddly, despite being good as Invest, I apparently suck as a Consig. But I'm a devious sod as Consort and fairly solid as Mafioso/GF.

Amongst the Neutral Evils, I'm a far better Exe than Jester. Despite loving Witch to death, I'm actually not so good at converting it into wins (although I've been doing better since Witch has the auto-bubble defence).

And in the NKs, I can be a right royal bastard if given a Serial Killer. But far less so if given an Arsonist.

[BabyGobln]

Doc
Consort
Serial K1llah

[EddyNorlickTH]

Not sure if ToS's statistic board is accurate. (because I haven't seen it updated for a while)

But, My best town were Jailor and Mayor. Best mafia was Mafioso (I got it like 4/5 of games). Best neutral was Survivor (But I really hate it)

[SparkingJay]

Jailor - 180 wins
Godfather - 91 wins
Jester - 48 wins

[Anika48024]

According to number of wins, I'm best as a Jailor, Mafioso and Jester, but I think this may be skewed due to the use of scrolls and playing a lot of Ranked and Ranked Practice. In reality I'd say my best town role is Sheriff or maybe Lookout, best mafia role is Blackmailer and best neutral role is Executioner.