Page 19 of 22

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 3:20 pm
by watchme1
Well if i somehow make it through, maybe i can be of use. But i can literally shoot anyone without consequences so ya.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 3:22 pm
by Hawkwing425
Right. Let me clarify.
I am comparing PKR’s role with BRVR’s role because both claim Goblin, but have similar roles, except PKR’s is more useful and reliable. I am not using ToS to prove my point in any way because it has nothing to do with my point. My point is that it seems suspicious that there’d be 2 similar roles with unbalanced power in the same faction.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 3:30 pm
by PokemonKidRyan
Sheriff.
Parity Cop.

They're both town but do similar things yet you can argue they have more powerful roles.

Vote Timur. They're a checked non-goblin and if you go back to what Seth said, with the list we don't have Mafia.
Therefore Timur tried to throw shade by saying I'm consigliere instead of considering me like a sheriff.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 3:45 pm
by Hawkwing425
PokemonKidRyan wrote:Sheriff.
Parity Cop.

They're both town but do similar things yet you can argue they have more powerful roles.

Vote Timur. They're a checked non-goblin and if you go back to what Seth said, with the list we don't have Mafia.
Therefore Timur tried to throw shade by saying I'm consigliere instead of considering me like a sheriff.

...You continue to not get my point. Why are they both supposedly in the same faction?

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 4:10 pm
by WindBlqde
If there are 6 roles, why would 2 of them be that similar, yet have an imbalance in power? Your roles have more in common than you're realizing. Both have the same basic power, they are just carried out differently.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 4:20 pm
by Hawkwing425
WindBlqde wrote:If there are 6 roles, why would 2 of them be that similar, yet have an imbalance in power? Your roles have more in common than you're realizing. Both have the same basic power, they are just carried out differently.

THIS. See, Wind gets it.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 4:36 pm
by BRVR
Hawking can you claim what your role does? We can compare the goblin roles to the shade roles and see what the differences are.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 4:42 pm
by Hawkwing425
BRVR wrote:Hawking can you claim what your role does? We can compare the goblin roles to the shade roles and see what the differences are.

Sure thing.
Seththeking wrote:Goblin Shaman

During the night you can Generate Energy.
Generating Energy Roleblocks all players visiting you except for players attacking you.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 4:56 pm
by WindBlqde
Hawkwing425 wrote:
BRVR wrote:Hawking can you claim what your role does? We can compare the goblin roles to the shade roles and see what the differences are.

Sure thing.
Seththeking wrote:Goblin Shaman

During the night you can Generate Energy.
Generating Energy Roleblocks all players visiting you except for players attacking you.

Tbh that sounds much weaker than both BRVR and PKR's roles.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 4:58 pm
by Hawkwing425
WindBlqde wrote:
Hawkwing425 wrote:
BRVR wrote:Hawking can you claim what your role does? We can compare the goblin roles to the shade roles and see what the differences are.

Sure thing.
Seththeking wrote:Goblin Shaman

During the night you can Generate Energy.
Generating Energy Roleblocks all players visiting you except for players attacking you.

Tbh that sounds much weaker than both BRVR and PKR's roles.

True, but it's the ability I have. Also, it's different from both BRVR and PKR's roles, unlike their roles from each other, which is why I'm suspicious.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 5:03 pm
by WindBlqde
Spoiler:
Hawkwing425 wrote:
WindBlqde wrote:
Hawkwing425 wrote:
BRVR wrote:Hawking can you claim what your role does? We can compare the goblin roles to the shade roles and see what the differences are.

Sure thing.
Seththeking wrote:Goblin Shaman

During the night you can Generate Energy.
Generating Energy Roleblocks all players visiting you except for players attacking you.

Tbh that sounds much weaker than both BRVR and PKR's roles.

True, but it's the ability I have. Also, it's different from both BRVR and PKR's roles, unlike their roles from each other, which is why I'm suspicious.


Exactly what I was going to say. Your role is much weaker than theirs and sounds like a normal majority role. PKR & BRVR's roles are quite similar, and while BRVR's may be just on the more powerful side, i dunno about PKR.

/vote PKR

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 5:05 pm
by Hawkwing425
Okay, so I did some calculations, and I determined... it's not possible for me, BRVR, and PKR to all be Goblin. Chemist died to a Goblin killing role. I can't kill anyone. BRVR and PKR don't claim to be able to kill anyone... so there's someone who isn't speaking up. There's 3 Goblins remaining.

So, a list of claims:
Goblin 1: me (Goblin Shaman)
Goblin 2: BRVR
Goblin 3: PKR
Shade 1: watchme1 (confirmed via Soulshooter, but actual role ability is unknown)
Naga 1: ?
Naga 2: ?
Naga 3: ?
Jackel 1: ?
Jackel 2: ?
Human 1: ?

anyways
/vote PKR

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 5:30 pm
by WindBlqde
If PKR flips Goblin, we should get timur.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 5:37 pm
by Seththeking
Hawkwing425 wrote:Okay, so I did some calculations, and I determined... it's not possible for me, BRVR, and PKR to all be Goblin. Chemist died to a Goblin killing role. I can't kill anyone. BRVR and PKR don't claim to be able to kill anyone... so there's someone who isn't speaking up. There's 3 Goblins remaining.

So, a list of claims:
Goblin 1: me (Goblin Shaman)
Goblin 2: BRVR
Goblin 3: PKR
Shade 1: watchme1 (confirmed via Soulshooter, but actual role ability is unknown)
Naga 1: ?
Naga 2: ?
Naga 3: ?
Jackel 1: ?
Jackel 2: ?
Human 1: ?

anyways
/vote PKR


Please remember Debil was a Goblin! ^_^

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 5:47 pm
by WindBlqde
Seththeking wrote:
Hawkwing425 wrote:Okay, so I did some calculations, and I determined... it's not possible for me, BRVR, and PKR to all be Goblin. Chemist died to a Goblin killing role. I can't kill anyone. BRVR and PKR don't claim to be able to kill anyone... so there's someone who isn't speaking up. There's 3 Goblins remaining.

So, a list of claims:
Goblin 1: me (Goblin Shaman)
Goblin 2: BRVR
Goblin 3: PKR
Shade 1: watchme1 (confirmed via Soulshooter, but actual role ability is unknown)
Naga 1: ?
Naga 2: ?
Naga 3: ?
Jackel 1: ?
Jackel 2: ?
Human 1: ?

anyways
/vote PKR


Please remember Debil was a Goblin! ^_^

Good point. PKR's still weird though

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Fri May 17, 2019 7:17 pm
by Hawkwing425
Seththeking wrote:
Hawkwing425 wrote:Okay, so I did some calculations, and I determined... it's not possible for me, BRVR, and PKR to all be Goblin. Chemist died to a Goblin killing role. I can't kill anyone. BRVR and PKR don't claim to be able to kill anyone... so there's someone who isn't speaking up. There's 3 Goblins remaining.

So, a list of claims:
Goblin 1: me (Goblin Shaman)
Goblin 2: BRVR
Goblin 3: PKR
Shade 1: watchme1 (confirmed via Soulshooter, but actual role ability is unknown)
Naga 1: ?
Naga 2: ?
Naga 3: ?
Jackel 1: ?
Jackel 2: ?
Human 1: ?

anyways
/vote PKR


Please remember Debil was a Goblin! ^_^

I know Debil was a Goblin- he was the Rogue. That's why I said 3 Goblins are left, not 4. 2 other Goblins died, the Flagbearer and the Monk.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Sat May 18, 2019 1:17 am
by Crimson97
I'd say BR's power is the least powerful of the two as it relies on others to tell the truth about what they got.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Sat May 18, 2019 1:18 am
by Crimson97
PKR is a straight Goblin Cop

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Sat May 18, 2019 6:13 am
by WindBlqde
Hawkwing425 wrote:
Seththeking wrote:
Hawkwing425 wrote:Okay, so I did some calculations, and I determined... it's not possible for me, BRVR, and PKR to all be Goblin. Chemist died to a Goblin killing role. I can't kill anyone. BRVR and PKR don't claim to be able to kill anyone... so there's someone who isn't speaking up. There's 3 Goblins remaining.

So, a list of claims:
Goblin 1: me (Goblin Shaman)
Goblin 2: BRVR
Goblin 3: PKR
Shade 1: watchme1 (confirmed via Soulshooter, but actual role ability is unknown)
Naga 1: ?
Naga 2: ?
Naga 3: ?
Jackel 1: ?
Jackel 2: ?
Human 1: ?
anyways
/vote PKR


Please remember Debil was a Goblin! ^_^

I know Debil was a Goblin- he was the Rogue. That's why I said 3 Goblins are left, not 4. 2 other Goblins died, the Flagbearer and the Monk.

Yeah, but TheDebil could've been the goblin killing role.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Sat May 18, 2019 6:18 am
by Seththeking
The moment I realized there were 5 Goblins and 5 Shades. X.X

2 Humans, 3 Naga, 3 Jackel, 5 Shade, 5 Goblin = 18 Players.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Sat May 18, 2019 6:31 am
by WindBlqde
Seththeking wrote:The moment I realized there were 5 Goblins and 5 Shades. X.X

2 Humans, 3 Naga, 3 Jackel, 5 Shade, 5 Goblin = 18 Players.

pls update OP with dead players list

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Sat May 18, 2019 8:44 am
by PokemonKidRyan
Please can y'all vote Timur before me.
As if I'm eliminated, there's a high chance it's game over for the goblins and shade.
I can currently advise the shade (by checking others) and it can be a check on anyone we agree on as a group.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Sat May 18, 2019 9:32 am
by WindBlqde
PokemonKidRyan wrote:Please can y'all vote Timur before me.
As if I'm eliminated, there's a high chance it's game over for the goblins and shade.
I can currently advise the shade (by checking others) and it can be a check on anyone we agree on as a group.

Shade doesn't even win with goblin
Why are you acting like you're on the shade's side?

Also tbh Naga has the best chance of winning right now

AND there are only 2 Goblins left - that means that you, BRVR, & Hawkwing can't all be Goblin.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Sat May 18, 2019 9:52 am
by PokemonKidRyan
I said before, while being a shade that I received no info from BRVR.
Someone else also confirmed that.

I'm more likely to be Goblin as a result than BRVR.
Y'all need Naga numbers to go down a bit. Considering Timur is non-Goblin and non-Shade it's more likely they're Naga than anything else.

Re: Forum Fantasy Episode 1 (Main Thread - Day 3)

PostPosted: Sat May 18, 2019 9:59 am
by WindBlqde
PokemonKidRyan wrote:I said before, while being a shade that I received no info from BRVR.
Someone else also confirmed that.

I'm more likely to be Goblin as a result than BRVR.
Y'all need Naga numbers to go down a bit. Considering Timur is non-Goblin and non-Shade it's more likely they're Naga than anything else.

Ok, so you and BRVR aren't both Jackals, which I suspected earlier.

You bring up a convincing point. I kinda feel like your some sort of executioner variant, but /vote timurtheking
Also, timur hasn't said anything in their defense.