Town of Salem Game Forums

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 12:46 am**

Vannish wrote:
EyeOfTheTiger wrote:
Vannish wrote:Why is everyone voting for people with no gifts and with no profile to be something dangerous like MAA? Don't Goose and Sheep seem like better deals?

No vote for now I think we need more discussing.

Would you like the honest answer, or the one that doesn't make us look like arseholes?

Honest one

Easier to go along with a vote we disagree with, than to put in the effort to fight for one we like.
Plus, it's not us that's getting killed.

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 12:53 am**

EyeOfTheTiger wrote:
Vannish wrote:
EyeOfTheTiger wrote:
Vannish wrote:Why is everyone voting for people with no gifts and with no profile to be something dangerous like MAA? Don't Goose and Sheep seem like better deals?

No vote for now I think we need more discussing.

Would you like the honest answer, or the one that doesn't make us look like arseholes?

Honest one

Easier to go along with a vote we disagree with, than to put in the effort to fight for one we like.
Plus, it's not us that's getting killed.

Vote on someone with potential to be MAA would be much better though no? Just because you aren't being executed doesn't mean you aren't getting killed. I understand it from your point of view though, since you're up to be voted as well.

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 12:57 am**

Personally, I waited for someone else to cast the first vote, and then followed along with it on seeing it wasn't me. Having multiple votes on that target may have then resulted in more people then joining the vote.

I wonder how gameplay dynamics would change if votes were submitted privately and not revealed until end of phase?

Vannish, we don't know if the MAA will shoot again this VP, and if they do, voting them up won't stop them from getting a shot off.

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 1:00 am**

*loses duel*

Vannish wrote:Vote on someone with potential to be MAA

Vannish wrote:Don't Goose and Sheep seem like better deals? .

Mate its very unlikely I'm MAA unless you claim that the sturgeon and the goose are top 2 duelers

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 1:49 am**

transportowiec96 wrote:*loses duel*
Vannish wrote:Vote on someone with potential to be MAA

Vannish wrote:Don't Goose and Sheep seem like better deals? .

Mate its very unlikely I'm MAA unless you claim that the sturgeon and the goose are top 2 duelers

MAA was more regarding the goose, my opinion on you is more regarding gifts, but I guess MAA may just take care of that regardless..

Technetium wrote:Personally, I waited for someone else to cast the first vote, and then followed along with it on seeing it wasn't me. Having multiple votes on that target may have then resulted in more people then joining the vote.

I wonder how gameplay dynamics would change if votes were submitted privately and not revealed until end of phase?

Vannish, we don't know if the MAA will shoot again this VP, and if they do, voting them up won't stop them from getting a shot off.

They would likely change a lot also, it will stop him shooting next time you're up in vote. (although you're the one from the ones up in vote with a higher chance of being MAA so idk.)

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 1:55 am**

Actually nvm, low chance anyone in vote can be MAA, I'm dumb.

I don't like either option, (Vulpine/Gorilla), but I guess if its between one of them I'll go for the most gifts

/vote Gorilla

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 2:16 am**

Votes:
The Vulpine: 5
The Gorilla: 3
The Mocking Bird: 0
The Sheep: 0
The Goose: 0

Gifts wrote:The Fairy: 1 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve
The Outlaw: 0 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 1/1 Reserve
The Vulpine: 0 Deny/ 0 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve
The Husky: 2 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 1/1 Reserve
The Gorilla: 1 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve
The Devil: 1 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve
The Mocking Bird: 1 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve
The Dragon: 0 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve
The Sheep: 2 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 1/1 Reserve
The Sturgeon: 2 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve
The Direwolf: 1 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 1/1 Reserve
~~The Snake: 1 Deny/ 0 Switch/ 1/1 Reserve~~ POISONED
The Goose: 2 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 1/1 Reserve
~~The Eagle: 1 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve~~ MURDERED
The Phoenix: 1 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 2:20 am**

Vannish wrote:Actually nvm, low chance anyone in vote can be MAA, I'm dumb.

I don't like either option, (Vulpine/Gorilla), but I guess if its between one of them I'll go for the most gifts

/vote Gorilla

Didn't I beat you in a dance? Probably says something about your dancing skills if you think I am the Man at Arms.

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 2:27 am**

Technetium wrote:
Vannish wrote:Actually nvm, low chance anyone in vote can be MAA, I'm dumb.

I don't like either option, (Vulpine/Gorilla), but I guess if its between one of them I'll go for the most gifts

/vote Gorilla

Didn't I beat you in a dance? Probably says something about your dancing skills if you think I am the Man at Arms.

Nah this is just what happens when you write down everyone's duels and dances for analysis and forget to add your own lmao

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 2:50 am**

Vannish wrote:Why is everyone voting for people with no gifts and with no profile to be something dangerous like MAA? Don't Goose and Sheep seem like better deals?

No vote for now I think we need more discussing.

There is no "not dangerous" role.

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 3:03 am**

more concerned about the student tbh

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 3:37 am**

transportowiec96 wrote:more concerned about the student tbh

Because they get more powerful the further the game progresses or...?

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 3:40 am**

Cenvil2 wrote:
Vannish wrote:Why is everyone voting for people with no gifts and with no profile to be something dangerous like MAA? Don't Goose and Sheep seem like better deals?

No vote for now I think we need more discussing.

There is no "not dangerous" role.

Augur

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 3:41 am**

destawaits wrote:
transportowiec96 wrote:more concerned about the student tbh

Because they get more powerful the further the game progresses or...?

because it's OP

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 3:53 am**

JazzMusicStops wrote:
Cenvil2 wrote:
Vannish wrote:Why is everyone voting for people with no gifts and with no profile to be something dangerous like MAA? Don't Goose and Sheep seem like better deals?

No vote for now I think we need more discussing.

There is no "not dangerous" role.

Augur

Actually he can guess you, and then die, or is it the other way around?

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 4:22 am**

I guess I'll go with who has more gifts too...

/vote Gorilla

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 4:23 am**

JazzMusicStops wrote:
Cenvil2 wrote:
Vannish wrote:Why is everyone voting for people with no gifts and with no profile to be something dangerous like MAA? Don't Goose and Sheep seem like better deals?

No vote for now I think we need more discussing.

There is no "not dangerous" role.

Augur

Knowledge is power.
One dead player's role can be enough for a good Augur.

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 5:03 am**

people lie

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 5:10 am**

Votes:
The Vulpine: 5
The Gorilla: 4
The Mocking Bird: 0
The Sheep: 0
The Goose: 0

Gifts wrote:The Fairy: 1 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve
The Outlaw: 0 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 1/1 Reserve
The Vulpine: 0 Deny/ 0 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve
The Husky: 2 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 1/1 Reserve
The Gorilla: 1 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve
The Devil: 1 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve
The Mocking Bird: 1 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve
The Dragon: 0 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve
The Sheep: 2 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 1/1 Reserve
The Sturgeon: 2 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve
The Direwolf: 1 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 1/1 Reserve
~~The Snake: 1 Deny/ 0 Switch/ 1/1 Reserve~~ POISONED
The Goose: 2 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 1/1 Reserve
~~The Eagle: 1 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve~~ MURDERED
The Phoenix: 1 Deny/ 1 Switch/ 0/1 Reserve

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 5:37 am**

JazzMusicStops wrote:people lie

Augur gets a modconfirmed role from a dead player.

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 10:01 am**

Cenvil2 wrote:
JazzMusicStops wrote:people lie

Augur gets a modconfirmed role from a dead player.

Three modconfirmed roles, possibly, since they can ask moderator question three times
Also, if any of the dead players have reason to actually be helpful to Augur, they might provide true information

though Augur's ability to actually "attack" other players is limited to the methods available to all roles (voting and guessing), they just get a slight boost to guessing.

The role really ought to have stronger challenge ranks.

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 11:11 am**

/vote Gorilla

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 11:56 am**

/vote Gorilla

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 12:21 pm**

Technetium wrote:Also, if any of the dead players have reason to actually be helpful to Augur, they might provide true information

they don't though

Posted: **Thu Oct 10, 2019 12:28 pm**

/vote Gorilla

Town of Salem Game Forums

Behind the Masks: Episode 12 - GAME OVER! Blackmailer Wins!

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)

Re: Behind the Mask: Episode 12 - Voting Phase 2 (13/15)