Sadly I didn't get a screenshot because I didn't realize something was wrong until AFTER the game, and so far I haven't been able to replicate the same thing in other games! It was one of my first VIP games so I thought maybe it was a feature until other people mentioned it wasn't.
We were on about a night... 5? or 6? And our VIP died. The game didn't end but selected a different town member as VIP, and the game continued as usual. That way town won and it kinda felt unfair toward the last coven. There have been plenty of other games where the VIP died but it never acted the same way as it did back then. I have no idea what triggers it.