Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
James2 wrote:Boredfan1 wrote:James2 wrote:Executioner is trivially easy to win as if you can lie halfway well.
And even if you can't, in the current meta town will often give you the win if you cooperate with them.
In theory but in practice, I've seen them lose about 90-99% of the time.
Then you've either interacted with exceptionally bad Executioners or exceptionally perceptive towns. It really isn't hard to set up a convincing fake claim, especially if you pay attention to the current meta regarding how town responds to potential executioners.
Joacgroso wrote:Joacgroso wrote:If you want to change them, maybe you could take inspiration from the fearmonger, a role from blood on the clocktower? That game is kinda different from ToS, but maybe the role can work with some tweaks.
I'm not a balance expert, but maybe we could have them pick a target and 2 red herrings each night, which will be revealed the next day to the town. If the true target is town and is lynched the next day (optionally: this ability only works if the exe is among the first half of people who voted that person up), evils win. The reworked exe could still win like a witch. If you don't want to be so punishing, maybe make the exe rb all townies if he executes his target.
Although as I said, I like current exes.
People said they don't know how to rework exes, so I'll repost this because most people didn't give feedback. I like the concept of a fearmonger because it actually deters town from lynching people just by existing. Even if what I said is bad, there may be some way around it.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Boredfan1 wrote:I've interacted with people who HAVE won as executioner, I have won as executioner myself and we are still saying it's not a good role.
Joacgroso wrote:How is it very bad for mafia?
Brilliand wrote:Boredfan1 wrote:I've interacted with people who HAVE won as executioner, I have won as executioner myself and we are still saying it's not a good role.
Did you get them to specify what was wrong with it? Because Executioner does have a lot of problems; it's just that "too hard to win as" isn't one of them.
Boredfan1 wrote:Because there's a good chance that they will choose a mafia member and the mafia really doesn't need an additional enemy that can screw them over and win for doing so.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 26 guests