To be honest ranked is kinda braindead lately as is.
Had a Godfather claim medium D4, barely 1 sentence will, no copy and paste from dead chat.
Ironically enough the only 2 people that voted guilty were also mafia.
Sheep. But that's just how the game goes I guess.
Back on topic though since I don't know how this discussion went from "Witch is boring as hell" to "punishment for killing a townie"
Witch is most definitely boring to play, correct. If mafia has less than 4 brain cells, you are screwed. Correct.
However if we throw NK in there, we throw things a bit off balance in the eyes of some players (Honestly you will probably win as Witch easier than winning as SK or WW. Let's be honest, that hardly happened)
So I agree, replace Surv with Witch, or have it Jester + Exe (So there can be 2 Jesters at a time if target dies)
Or witch needs some kind of re-work, such as in the Card Game version where the witch silently poisons everyone and once everyone is poisoned, they all die and witch wins. (That would be really shitty for TOS itself but that's a suggestion)