Suggest balanced ideas to end jailor meta

[syjfwbaobfwl]

Ban the word "Jailor" for jailor and make them reveal like mayor. 10/10

So jailor is obligated to reveal and cant play hidden

[Robbytherobot]

Nah that confirms another townie, jailor can be faked.

[syjfwbaobfwl]

so? It should be useless. It still has the ability to confirm 3 town slots, thats 1/3 of the role list.... you asked how to balance that, and I told you the only way it can be done mathematically....

So you want a way to make the role that can confirm 1/3 of the role list day 2, to be ''balanced'' but not ''useless''? The role is totally unbalanced to start with....there is no way of balancing the role, without making it ''useless'' (If you consider confirming 1 player per night, useless)

As it is now, LO can still confirm 5/9ths of the town day 2...all the nerf did was drop the rate (that jailor could exe an evil night 2, by choosing at random) from 66% chance to 55% chance. Seeing 2 roles visit would drop it to 45% chance, seeing 1 visit would drop it to a 33% chance.

Idk....I think a 33% chance is more balanced, than useless... much more balanced than a 50%+

Not really, I have seen some good reworks to make it more balanced without making it useless, without to mention that seeing 1 visit increases RNG by a lot

[cob709]

remove jailor role from town of salem

[kyuss420]

remove jailor role from town of salem

Noobs cant ToS without a jailor in game tho.....

[Lachek]

Another game I didn't claim jailor and was reported by others after I died n1.

[Lachek]

I think since doctor is stronger tp than bg in this meta since he is better claim and won't die after protecting target, I think doctor can be nerfed by not leting him nurse same target twice in a row.

[StlnSP]

Another game I didn't claim jailor and was reported by others after I died n1.

Personally : git gud scrub why would you not abuse broken shit

But seriously: you probably won't get banned for not claiming jailor. That is a bad strategy, but it's not gamethrowing.

[Cookazoo2]

Jailor can't jail the night after they execute someone because they're "cleaning the cell."

Think about your jails before you exe.

[OreCreeper]

so? It should be useless. It still has the ability to confirm 3 town slots, thats 1/3 of the role list.... you asked how to balance that, and I told you the only way it can be done mathematically....

So you want a way to make the role that can confirm 1/3 of the role list day 2, to be ''balanced'' but not ''useless''? The role is totally unbalanced to start with....there is no way of balancing the role, without making it ''useless'' (If you consider confirming 1 player per night, useless)

As it is now, LO can still confirm 5/9ths of the town day 2...all the nerf did was drop the rate (that jailor could exe an evil night 2, by choosing at random) from 66% chance to 55% chance. Seeing 2 roles visit would drop it to 45% chance, seeing 1 visit would drop it to a 33% chance.

Idk....I think a 33% chance is more balanced, than useless... much more balanced than a 50%+

Jailor should always execute N2, especially if no evils have died. It's fair to have a "50%+ chance" since if they dont exe N2 that's effectively throwing the game.

[Descender]

Another game I didn't claim jailor and was reported by others after I died n1.

Personally : git gud scrub why would you not abuse broken shit

But seriously: you probably won't get banned for not claiming jailor. That is a bad strategy, but it's not gamethrowing.

not a bad strat if you play your cards right

remove jailor role from town of salem

jailkeeper pog