Beasts...? What are you talking about?! Someone was murdered here!! We must find the culprit, not talk about things that don't exist!!
Arckas wrote:Are you positive there, Caroline?
We both had to put our thumbprint in order to vote.
I don't think that's the case. I believe that if you put your handprint at whatever point, a screen comes up just for you. So if your partner put his handprint first, voted, and then you showed up, you would be able to put your handprint and vote for yourself in the screen too.
Either way, I don't like the initial inconsistencies in your alibis, so there is a reason to believe you two planned to murder a lone player beforehand but one of you messed up their alibi.
As for other possibilities, what if Otto himself never entered his booth? Perhaps the person we saw was Charlotte who disguised as him and later threw the body into his booth (or he was killed in the booth itself beforehand)?
Or maybe he was killed as he entered and we didn't notice?
The ones who entered before Otto, Caroline and Theta, are also suspects. They could have entered his booth instead of theirs and murdered him. Their partners are simply lying for them now.