randomguyhavingfun wrote:Ok so I can nfortnatelay can't quote because I'm on mobile but I wrote what I think is the best place for roles. Of course don't take it wholesale but I hope you like some of my ideas and add them
Trusted
Jailor
Idk why but I like Jailor in the cannot be Trusted result. Gives the role a twist and makes town think before they go to lynch someone from this role
Doctor
Meh, it can go here or Kind of Trusted doesn't really matter
Transporter
Transporter is very OP rn so I think placing it in lower results can nerf it a bit
Interviewer
Agreed
Sheriff
Agreed
Investigator
Agreed
Godfather
Agreed
(Serial killer)
If Serial Killer was in here then it makes the top result a result to look out for. It needs to go lower
Executioner
Agreed
Janitor
Meh, I guess this role can with a buff and is better than Blackmailor currently
Kind of trusted
Lookout
Agreed
Bodygaurd
Bodyguard is under too much pressure as it is with the Investigator result, needs to be higher
Amnesiac
Agreed
Survivor
Agreed
Medium
Agreed
Werewolf
Borderline fine but I still feel Werewolf needs a buff atm
Arsonist
Agreed
Consigliere
I feel this role can go here or lower but I still think lower is better as it is a powerful role
Forger
Agreed
Witch
Can go here but I feel Witch is weak atm and hard to survive as
(Serial killer )
Can go here or lower
Cannot be trusted
Spy
Agreed
Escort
I guess
Vampire hunter
Agreed
Mayor
Why can't Mayor be trusted, should be in the first result
retributonist
Agreed or it can go in Kind of Trusted
Vigilante
Agreed
Consort
I guess, should be in he same result as Escort
Blackmailer
Agreed, this role is too OP atm
Framer
Agreed
Jester
Agreed
Vampire
Agreed
Disguiser
Agreed
Mafioso
Agreed
BS4125 wrote:randomguyhavingfun wrote:Ok so I can nfortnatelay can't quote because I'm on mobile but I wrote what I think is the best place for roles. Of course don't take it wholesale but I hope you like some of my ideas and add them
Trusted
Jailor
Idk why but I like Jailor in the cannot be Trusted result. Gives the role a twist and makes town think before they go to lynch someone from this rolenot like jailor is gonna get claimed any time soon. So I thought I might as well put him here because of lore
Doctor
Meh, it can go here or Kind of Trusted doesn't really mattertrue but lorewise he should be here. Also he is a nice claimspace so I thought h could go in the most innocent category
Transporter
Transporter is very OP rn so I think placing it in lower results can nerf it a biti think having him where godfather is is quite a nerf because mafia is the only one who may try to fake him
Interviewer
Agreed
Sheriff
Agreed
Investigator
Agreed
Godfather
Agreed
(Serial killer)
If Serial Killer was in here then it makes the top result a result to look out for. It needs to go lowerwell it should be something you should look out for. And tahts one of the main reasons I put a lot townies in here. Town investigatives and Doctor are really nice claims and important roles
Executioner
Agreed
Janitor
Meh, I guess this role can with a buff and is better than Blackmailor currentlyyeah but o thought allowing the interviewer to tell janitor apart from the medium could buff him
Kind of trusted
Lookout
Agreed
Bodygaurd
Bodyguard is under too much pressure as it is with the Investigator result, needs to be higherif he is higher he is in the same one as gf and that turns out to be more pressure. This again allows the interviewer to tell them apart but it keeps him in the same as arsonist
Amnesiac
Agreed
Survivor
Agreed
Medium
Agreed
Werewolf
Borderline fine but I still feel Werewolf needs a buff atmthpughtvof putting him in trusted but that would be a lot of scum. Also buffing the werewolf will take more than giving him claims, he needs more power
Arsonist
Agreed
Consigliere
I feel this role can go here or lower but I still think lower is better as it is a powerful role yeah guess I can do with putting him in cannot be trusted
Forger
Agreed
Witch
Can go here but I feel Witch is weak atm and hard to survive astrue but putting her more up is bad for lore and doesn't offer much
(Serial killer )
Can go here or lowerserial killer is kinda weak so putting him lower wouldn't be a nice idea
Cannot be trusted
Spy
Agreed
Escort
I guesswould YOU trust a prostitute?
Vampire hunter
Agreed
Mayor
Why can't Mayor be trusted, should be in the first result it fits with the reveal mechanic
retributonist
Agreed or it can go in Kind of Trusted
Vigilante
Agreed
Consort
I guess, should be in he same result as Escortsee escort
Blackmailer
Agreed, this role is too OP atm
Framer
Agreed
Jester
Agreed
Vampire
Agreed
Disguiser
Agreed
Mafioso
Agreed
Thanks for the feedback, I do like your adaption however some roles don't really fit. Thanks tho
randomguyhavingfun wrote:BS4125 wrote:randomguyhavingfun wrote:Ok so I can nfortnatelay can't quote because I'm on mobile but I wrote what I think is the best place for roles. Of course don't take it wholesale but I hope you like some of my ideas and add them
Trusted
Jailor
Idk why but I like Jailor in the cannot be Trusted result. Gives the role a twist and makes town think before they go to lynch someone from this rolenot like jailor is gonna get claimed any time soon. So I thought I might as well put him here because of lore
Doctor
Meh, it can go here or Kind of Trusted doesn't really mattertrue but lorewise he should be here. Also he is a nice claimspace so I thought h could go in the most innocent category
Transporter
Transporter is very OP rn so I think placing it in lower results can nerf it a biti think having him where godfather is is quite a nerf because mafia is the only one who may try to fake him
Interviewer
Agreed
Sheriff
Agreed
Investigator
Agreed
Godfather
Agreed
(Serial killer)
If Serial Killer was in here then it makes the top result a result to look out for. It needs to go lowerwell it should be something you should look out for. And tahts one of the main reasons I put a lot townies in here. Town investigatives and Doctor are really nice claims and important roles
Executioner
Agreed
Janitor
Meh, I guess this role can with a buff and is better than Blackmailor currentlyyeah but o thought allowing the interviewer to tell janitor apart from the medium could buff him
Kind of trusted
Lookout
Agreed
Bodygaurd
Bodyguard is under too much pressure as it is with the Investigator result, needs to be higherif he is higher he is in the same one as gf and that turns out to be more pressure. This again allows the interviewer to tell them apart but it keeps him in the same as arsonist
Amnesiac
Agreed
Survivor
Agreed
Medium
Agreed
Werewolf
Borderline fine but I still feel Werewolf needs a buff atmthpughtvof putting him in trusted but that would be a lot of scum. Also buffing the werewolf will take more than giving him claims, he needs more power
Arsonist
Agreed
Consigliere
I feel this role can go here or lower but I still think lower is better as it is a powerful role yeah guess I can do with putting him in cannot be trusted
Forger
Agreed
Witch
Can go here but I feel Witch is weak atm and hard to survive astrue but putting her more up is bad for lore and doesn't offer much
(Serial killer )
Can go here or lowerserial killer is kinda weak so putting him lower wouldn't be a nice idea
Cannot be trusted
Spy
Agreed
Escort
I guesswould YOU trust a prostitute?
Vampire hunter
Agreed
Mayor
Why can't Mayor be trusted, should be in the first result it fits with the reveal mechanic
retributonist
Agreed or it can go in Kind of Trusted
Vigilante
Agreed
Consort
I guess, should be in he same result as Escortsee escort
Blackmailer
Agreed, this role is too OP atm
Framer
Agreed
Jester
Agreed
Vampire
Agreed
Disguiser
Agreed
Mafioso
Agreed
Thanks for the feedback, I do like your adaption however some roles don't really fit. Thanks tho
Just answering some questions I can take criticism. I am happy you liked my suggestions
Kirize wrote:I didnt know you could contradict yourself in one sentencekookeekwisp wrote:Dont single out Arso cause it kills slower!
kookeekwisp wrote:Can you PLEASE put those in Spoilers? It's 4 posts, and it's already half as long as a page full of posts.
Tigerleap wrote:Broken role idea. All the scum roles in Not Trusted apart from Mafioso are SCREWED. But this role is useless against everything else.
Tigerleap wrote:Broken role idea. All the scum roles in Not Trusted apart from Mafioso are SCREWED. But this role is useless against everything else.
randomguyhavingfun wrote:Tigerleap wrote:Broken role idea. All the scum roles in Not Trusted apart from Mafioso are SCREWED. But this role is useless against everything else.
Framer is framer so he is kinda protected and othe roles can fake Vigi too. Also jester. Vampires could fake vh.
But I think you should swap sk and disguiser
BS4125 wrote:randomguyhavingfun wrote:Tigerleap wrote:Broken role idea. All the scum roles in Not Trusted apart from Mafioso are SCREWED. But this role is useless against everything else.
Framer is framer so he is kinda protected and othe roles can fake Vigi too. Also jester. Vampires could fake vh.
But I think you should swap sk and disguiser
If I swap Disguiser with SK then all the NK's are in all one result which means that that result can confirm who is NK
randomguyhavingfun wrote:BS4125 wrote:randomguyhavingfun wrote:Tigerleap wrote:Broken role idea. All the scum roles in Not Trusted apart from Mafioso are SCREWED. But this role is useless against everything else.
Framer is framer so he is kinda protected and othe roles can fake Vigi too. Also jester. Vampires could fake vh.
But I think you should swap sk and disguiser
If I swap Disguiser with SK then all the NK's are in all one result which means that that result can confirm who is NK
Yes but nks are not the only roles in there
BS4125 wrote:Can people say why they don't like the role please in the comments instead of voting then just leaving. I'm doing the best I can from everyone's perspective
BlazinIce wrote:BS4125 wrote:Can people say why they don't like the role please in the comments instead of voting then just leaving. I'm doing the best I can from everyone's perspective
Sorry. Move WW into trusted, and spy into not trusted.
I wasn't one of those voters, though
BS4125 wrote:BlazinIce wrote:BS4125 wrote:Can people say why they don't like the role please in the comments instead of voting then just leaving. I'm doing the best I can from everyone's perspective
Sorry. Move WW into trusted, and spy into not trusted.
I wasn't one of those voters, though
Ok,.. thanks for helping though!
I have swapped Werewolf and Lookout, I agree that Werewolf needs a buff however I didn't move Spy just because Blackmailor is already in the lowest result so if those are both together then it makes this role more UP as Blackmailor can just keep claiming Spy and gets away with it everytime
randomguyhavingfun wrote:BS4125 wrote:BlazinIce wrote:BS4125 wrote:Can people say why they don't like the role please in the comments instead of voting then just leaving. I'm doing the best I can from everyone's perspective
Sorry. Move WW into trusted, and spy into not trusted.
I wasn't one of those voters, though
Ok,.. thanks for helping though!
I have swapped Werewolf and Lookout, I agree that Werewolf needs a buff however I didn't move Spy just because Blackmailor is already in the lowest result so if those are both together then it makes this role more UP as Blackmailor can just keep claiming Spy and gets away with it everytime
With that change however kind of trusted is now a more favorable result that trusted. Move sk up please.
WindBlqde wrote:This is a good idea, but it needs to be buffed. Maybe add another category or two?
WindBlqde wrote:This is a good idea, but it needs to be buffed. Maybe add another category or two?
randomguyhavingfun wrote:WindBlqde wrote:This is a good idea, but it needs to be buffed. Maybe add another category or two?
well it can seperate roles from each other so it kinda works well against claimers or with an invest. having 5 categories means its too investigator like and tehre is barely ahy roles in each
Kirize wrote:I didnt know you could contradict yourself in one sentencekookeekwisp wrote:Dont single out Arso cause it kills slower!
kookeekwisp wrote:How about just general abilities, instead of multiple role groups, so it's less confusing?
Like, Investigative are the most trustworthy, killing's the least, etc.
randomguyhavingfun wrote:kookeekwisp wrote:How about just general abilities, instead of multiple role groups, so it's less confusing?
Like, Investigative are the most trustworthy, killing's the least, etc.
That is gonna turn out mixed. I can't tell.See what others think
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests