Auditor (Neutral Evil)

[BPsycho2]

You say no to everything I suggest. So negative to think of the possibilities.

Can somebody give a reason besides "Oh no"

Preferably someone older than me.

[Mace8937]

Vet- one shot

Do you mean one alert?
Vet doesn't shoot

[BPsycho2]

No, I meant one Vig bullet.

Giving him an alert might be OP since he could (very low chance, but) kill a whole lobby,

[Megalomancer]

No, that's not going to happen. No role thievery.

Also, I'm making it Roleblock Immune

[BPsycho2]

Alright then.

Actually, that makes sense since all neutral roles have some sort of problem.

Survivor- Paranoia
Amnesiac- Amnesia
Jester- Depression
Executioner- Obsession
Witch: Vengeance at all costs other than her life
Auditor: hoarding
Serial Killer: everything has to die
Arsonist: everything has to burn
Werewolf: Paranoia, Lycanthropy

(If the audit fails, does the role block still go through?)

[Megalomancer]

(If the audit fails, does the role block still go through?)

Yes

[BPsycho2]

Do you approve of my other idea?

(Box 1 blocks, box 2 audits which also blocks, can only pick one box?)

[BPsycho2]

A lot of times.

Say there's a vig and the mafioso says to shut him down

Just audit the vigilante.

Then the mayor asks you to confirm that you're an escort, so you role block him, and the mafioso lies that he was blocked too.

Then day after that, You audit the mayor and you're a "confirmed " escort AND the janitor cleans a role

Town assumes he was disguised, and hang.

[Megalomancer]

In order to get around the roleblocking thing, I'm considering the following changes:

• Is now Unique
• Has Night Immunity
• RBs NKs as Normal

[Megalomancer]

In order to get around the roleblocking thing, I'm considering the following changes:

• Is now Unique
• Has Night Immunity
• RBs NKs as Normal

Swap night immunity for a scum autovest and then we're golden.

That doesn't justify being unique

[Lisq]

I like the idea but it's too OP.

[Megalomancer]

I like the idea but it's too OP.

An explanation on why you think that would be appreciated.

[Lisq]

Just because it shuts down everything the target can do - reduces 3 mayor votes to 1, reduces all 3 vigilange's bullets, all 4 survivor vests, all 3 vete alerts, etc... And you roleblock your target. And you can use it THREE times which means you can "castrate" three characters. And after you use your ability three times you become an escort/consi... It's way too OP.

[BPsycho2]

In order to get around the roleblocking thing, I'm considering the following changes:

• Is now Unique
• Has Night Immunity
• RBs NKs as Normal

I've been suggesting this whole list for a while now. I support this because having more than one would destroy up to six roles with charges (and that's for just two)

You're going to need some good form of protection and especially since it's unique now, throw in some night immunity.

Still should be able to choose whether to role block or audit



Also, Lisq. All of the points you made are balanced by the fact that it's unique, and due to its high power, it will be a huge target.

[Megalomancer]

I've modified the role again, it now is unique, has an auto-vest and full roleblocking

[BPsycho2]

Should be fully immune, due to the fact that it is unique, and can only use it's powerful ability three times.

[BPsycho2]

Um, what?

You can't have something that is immune to attacks,but only if it's not a vigilante.

It's like Bane of Corpus on Warframe. Nobody uses it on every mission, because it's a racist mod, that is useless against other factions.

Should be fully immune since he's unique and has no team.



Scum autovest. Pfft, I'd much rather see the vigilante pierce night immunity. Only has three bullets anyways

[oliy]

Scum autovest is a completely realistic idea so the scum doesn't accidentally kill their ally but they're still up to the threat of Vigilantes Veterans and Jailors.

[Jerme]

@Oliy: Jailor is always a threat, since that roles does nto care if the target is nightimmune of not... What is the intereaction of a scum autovest with Arsonists douse/ignite and Werewolf maul?

[BPsycho2]

No role HAS a "scum autovest" and every unique Neutral should have full fledged night immunity.

Nowhere has that been approved, and I doubt that will ever be approved. The idea simply isn't good.

Besides, the Veteran and Jailor can already kill it.

There have been no recorded instances in TOS, or in real life, of a bulletproof vest that purposely doesn't protect if the bullet is straight and true and honorable, and all of that.

It's honestly a trash idea, especially for a unique role with no team. He doesn't mind other people winning, but he still has no team.

Honestly, the Witch should have a one use shield (but not one that's scum only)

[BPsycho2]

I meant I'd rather that.

No roles should be immune to WW, just give full immunity anyways.

[JazzMusicStops]

Just because it shuts down everything the target can do - reduces 3 mayor votes to 1, reduces all 3 vigilange's bullets, all 4 survivor vests, all 3 vete alerts, etc... And you roleblock your target. And you can use it THREE times which means you can "castrate" three characters. And after you use your ability three times you become an escort/consi... It's way too OP.

No, it's fine

[Megalomancer]

Just because it shuts down everything the target can do - reduces 3 mayor votes to 1, reduces all 3 vigilange's bullets, all 4 survivor vests, all 3 vete alerts, etc... And you roleblock your target. And you can use it THREE times which means you can "castrate" three characters. And after you use your ability three times you become an escort/consi... It's way too OP.

No, it's fine

Don't shut him down like that.
That said, this is based on a role that has existed for years on the game this one was based off of, but wasn't copied over because of the lack of Citizen and the Mafioso modification. Its impacts on the meta game, as well as some of the other abondoned roles, nerf the otherwise OP Town. Its previous use shows that it is not as OP as it is looks.

[Megalomancer]

Bumping this for more feedback

[DancingKitten10]

I think this is good, but it might need a nerf.