theelfoflorien wrote:Overpowered, A Neutral Killing role, with unlimited Roleblocks, Who also can join Mafia as a Mafioso, with an Auto-vest. That is way too many good things on one role.
TheBlitzBarker wrote:Hmm, it seems like its a bit too similar to datdownie's electrician suggestion...But I still like it.
Aetios wrote:Any role that is neutral AND can kill is Neutral Killing
I like it in a sorta way, but it's time wasting like an Arsonist. And the chances of getting the disease twice would be quite troublesome.
EyeOfTheTiger wrote:There is no alignment called Neutral Chaos.
Your role would fit under Neutral Killing.
And this: (I swear, how many people forget this... these are ideas though)
Investigator: Your target is a loner
Sherrif: Your target is a Virus Creator
Consigliere: Your target works with viruses and spreads them. They are a Virus Creator.
theelfoflorien wrote:This just feels like a nerfed Mafioso. A Mafioso can kill anyone But Mafia, like this, but doesn't have the penalty of accidentally Killing a Mafia member. Along with a Mafioso Knows who the Mafia is and can talk with them. Also Mafioso has unlimited attacks.
With no bonuses to this role vs any other, still a thumbs down for now.
Try adding something unique to them that gives them a reason to have to kill to live maybe? or something without such a harsh penalty?
Otherwise it is as you said yourself. "Vigilant with 3 shots, that commits suicide when killing a Mafia member"
theelfoflorien wrote:I think I get the idea of this latest version, I just simply tried to state that they are a Very much weaker form of a Mafioso. If you want me to take another stab at it, I also believe it to be a Very weak version of a Vigilante.
This is a Neutral that we are talking about so he already has a disadvantage of not being part of a team, (I say this even though he wins with mafia because he is not part of Mafia Chat) So in that regard is is like a witch.
He only has 3 shots like a Vigilante, even though an SK (Also Neutral Killing) has unlimited, and SK does not commit suicide when they attack Mafia, And SK has Night Immunity.
The only thing Unique about him is that if for some reason all the Mafia dies, he turns into a Jester, which is in a way Very Bad.
Example: 1 Stunter, 3 Mafia, 1 Survivor, 10 Town
After 5 days the Stunter has 1 bullet left, There is 4 Town left, The Survivor, and The last Mafia gets Lynched.
The Stunter then Turns into a Jester and the game ends there, Right after the Mafia gets Lynched, because there is no more Evil, or Neutral Killing roles left. Even though the Stunter still has a bullet.
I personally liked your previous idea better.
theelfoflorien wrote:Here's a Question, Where did the Name Stunter come from?
theelfoflorien wrote:Ok now what is the most important/favorite ability from this role that you want to keep?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests