Moderators: Varanus, FM Game Moderators
Gambler wrote:RNGsus Take the wheel
TheCow wrote:I'm surprised that twenty four people would vote yes on this pitch and not point out the fact that this 30 player game only has 28 roles on the role list.
As it stands, the game is 18-5-5. Town currently starts with an 8 player majority, with 3 confirmed town powers. At first glance, one might think that this game would be an utter stomping, with Town sweeping Mafia and Neutrals mercilessly, but they would be wrong. No, Neutrals would still get utterly destroyed, but really there is still Mafia to deal with.
Mafia can summon a new player off of the back up queue each night. These newly summoned players are confirmed as Mafia. One might think "oh, no big deal, let's just lynch them". Well, each night a new member of the Mafia is added to the game, and each day the Town is forced to lynch them. Fast forward to day five, and the Mafia Bomber uses their ability, and Mafia wins.
One could argue "the Hero would save the day! They can wipe the mafia just as easily!" That is not really the case, as they summon half as often as the Mafia, and therefore may only sweep the mafia twice as far into the game. In short, this game is impossible for Town to win, unless by some twist of fate, they manage to Vig/Jailor their way through legions of summoned Mafia.
What happens if Vampire bites a TPw?
With their current win condition why would they not become a witch?
Sorceress can confirm themselves very easily.
Lynching-Mob is a weak. It requires three people to visit their target, which means you're wasting several ability uses to use this ability.Gambler wrote:RNGsus Take the wheel
I'm voting no. Even after the issues on the summoning system are fixed I think this game is impossible to run. It would require something like 37 players to run in all, which is more than games on this site can handle.
TheCow wrote:I'm surprised that twenty four people would vote yes on this pitch and not point out the fact that this 30 player game only has 28 roles on the role list.
As it stands, the game is 18-5-5. Town currently starts with an 8 player majority, with 3 confirmed town powers. At first glance, one might think that this game would be an utter stomping, with Town sweeping Mafia and Neutrals mercilessly, but they would be wrong. No, Neutrals would still get utterly destroyed, but really there is still Mafia to deal with.
Mafia can summon a new player off of the back up queue each night. These newly summoned players are confirmed as Mafia. One might think "oh, no big deal, let's just lynch them". Well, each night a new member of the Mafia is added to the game, and each day the Town is forced to lynch them. Fast forward to day five, and the Mafia Bomber uses their ability, and Mafia wins.
One could argue "the Hero would save the day! They can wipe the mafia just as easily!" That is not really the case, as they summon half as often as the Mafia, and therefore may only sweep the mafia twice as far into the game. In short, this game is impossible for Town to win, unless by some twist of fate, they manage to Vig/Jailor their way through legions of summoned Mafia.
What happens if Vampire bites a TPw?
With their current win condition why would they not become a witch?
Sorceress can confirm themselves very easily.
Lynching-Mob is a weak. It requires three people to visit their target, which means you're wasting several ability uses to use this ability.Gambler wrote:RNGsus Take the wheel
I'm voting no. Even after the issues on the summoning system are fixed I think this game is impossible to run. It would require something like 37 players to run in all, which is more than games on this site can handle.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest