Page 1 of 1

1 Mafia And 1 Town Killing Role

PostPosted: Fri May 31, 2019 6:35 pm
by Seththeking
Informer - (Possible Blackmailer Replacement)

-During the night, you can target someone and inform them. (Steal their nighttime feedback)
-During the night, you will know the names of all Town members who visited your target.


Suicide Bomber
Town Killing

-After the first lynch (and after night 1), you may choose to set someone's house on fire.
-You will attack anyone who visits that house with an Unstoppable attack (including yourself).
-If your target doesn't visit or stays home, they will also be dealt an Unstoppable attack.

Re: 1 Mafia And 1 Town Killing Role

PostPosted: Fri May 31, 2019 7:37 pm
by xUltiix
Blackmailer kinda sucks right now, this is actually a good buff imo - would increase blackmailer's power level to that of mafioso and hustler and also add more of the "tactical" aspect to it (night feedback + visitors helps discover PRs)
Only thing is that I think whoever had their results stolen should be notified they had it stolen instead of just receiving no feedback

Suicide bomber in that way kinda sounds too weak imo, generally TKs except ones that would almost fit in another alignment should be able to pick who they want dead and have it done within two nights barring other things happening in practice.

Re: 1 Mafia And 1 Town Killing Role

PostPosted: Fri May 31, 2019 7:39 pm
by Chemist1422
I think Informer doesn't need both powers and Suicide bomber is overall meh in concept due to being really situational.

Re: 1 Mafia And 1 Town Killing Role

PostPosted: Fri May 31, 2019 10:20 pm
by Kmenx
Informer is actually okay as a blackmailler buff (You did it Seth you finally made a good one)

Suicide bomber is kinda useless since it trades 1v1 TK's entire premise is killing scum without losing any townies

Re: 1 Mafia And 1 Town Killing Role

PostPosted: Fri May 31, 2019 10:23 pm
by Seththeking
Kmenx wrote:Informer is actually okay as a blackmailler buff (You did it Seth you finally made a good one)

Suicide bomber is kinda useless since it trades 1v1 TK's entire premise is killing scum without losing any townies


Say that to the current Vigilante in town of Salem.

Re: 1 Mafia And 1 Town Killing Role

PostPosted: Fri May 31, 2019 10:29 pm
by Kmenx
Seththeking wrote:
Kmenx wrote:Informer is actually okay as a blackmailler buff (You did it Seth you finally made a good one)

Suicide bomber is kinda useless since it trades 1v1 TK's entire premise is killing scum without losing any townies


Say that to the current Vigilante in town of Salem.

You ahould never consider ToS balanced while making roles in FM

Re: 1 Mafia And 1 Town Killing Role

PostPosted: Fri May 31, 2019 10:30 pm
by Kmenx
Kmenx wrote:
Seththeking wrote:
Kmenx wrote:Informer is actually okay as a blackmailler buff (You did it Seth you finally made a good one)

Suicide bomber is kinda useless since it trades 1v1 TK's entire premise is killing scum without losing any townies


Say that to the current Vigilante in town of Salem.

You ahould never consider ToS balanced while making roles in FM

Also even then ToS vig doesn't 1v1 trade when it kills scum

Re: 1 Mafia And 1 Town Killing Role

PostPosted: Sat Jun 01, 2019 4:53 am
by Phone0Ix
xUltiix wrote:Blackmailer kinda sucks right now, this is actually a good buff imo - would increase blackmailer's power level to that of mafioso and hustler and also add more of the "tactical" aspect to it (night feedback + visitors helps discover PRs)
Only thing is that I think whoever had their results stolen should be notified they had it stolen instead of just receiving no feedback

Suicide bomber in that way kinda sounds too weak imo, generally TKs except ones that would almost fit in another alignment should be able to pick who they want dead and have it done within two nights barring other things happening in practice.

Basically this

Seth can you review my role idea, Spider?

Re: 1 Mafia And 1 Town Killing Role

PostPosted: Sat Jun 01, 2019 12:36 pm
by Varanus
Game Moderator Message: To avoid clogging FMD with threads about role ideas, please put any suggestions you have in some sort of megathread.