Bodhrak wrote:It doesn't work because of simple math.
In ranked town has Jailor, 5 "Fixed" slots and 3 RT slots.
This means that there would be more CCs than you'd have possibilities to get rid of.
Example
You get the following claims
Jailor
6 claims for TI (1 RT, 2 Maf, 1 NE)
3 claims for TP (1 RT, 1 NK)
2 claims for TS (1 Maf)
3 claims for TK (1RT, 1 Maf)
Now who do you execute, shoot and lynch?
kyuss420 wrote:I could go on with hypotheticals to counter your hypotheticals all day but point being, your simple math changes every day, with every maf/NK kill and every lynch thinning out the claim space. Better to force role disputes when town has majority or its mafias advantage
fable979 wrote:If NE is witch, town is fucked.
FrankLeeAwful wrote:Why reveal everyone when you can vote for roles and catch scummy behavior instead?
BasicFourLife wrote:congrats, youre one of the first people in this forum who ive seen suggesting this strategy
everyone against it is retarded and shouldnt play Ranked
everyone in the comments who is against it because of RTs is dumb, its much better to have everyone's roles known than to just lynch people. also the mafia cant change their claims anymore, escorts cannot fuck up on rbing conf townies, tis will only target potential Evil candidates, vig will shoot conf evils and vet will just save all of their alerts or randomlt use them since no Town has the need of visiting a Vet claim while the Mafia needs to get rid of him sooner or later anyways, etc etc
the benefits are enormous compared to the negatives, also not to mention the fact of how 2 tos strongest MAfia roles (although consig is not that strong, but in tos he is because the community is brain dead) are completely useless, Janitor can only erase wills now and Consig can only be used to find NEs
TheDebil wrote:BasicFourLife wrote:congrats, youre one of the first people in this forum who ive seen suggesting this strategy
everyone against it is retarded and shouldnt play Ranked
everyone in the comments who is against it because of RTs is dumb, its much better to have everyone's roles known than to just lynch people. also the mafia cant change their claims anymore, escorts cannot fuck up on rbing conf townies, tis will only target potential Evil candidates, vig will shoot conf evils and vet will just save all of their alerts or randomlt use them since no Town has the need of visiting a Vet claim while the Mafia needs to get rid of him sooner or later anyways, etc etc
the benefits are enormous compared to the negatives, also not to mention the fact of how 2 tos strongest MAfia roles (although consig is not that strong, but in tos he is because the community is brain dead) are completely useless, Janitor can only erase wills now and Consig can only be used to find NEs
just learn how to play properly dude
if this shit actually came to be it would ruin the game completely
BasicFourLife wrote:congrats, youre one of the first people in this forum who ive seen suggesting this strategy
everyone against it is retarded and shouldnt play Ranked
everyone in the comments who is against it because of RTs is dumb, its much better to have everyone's roles known than to just lynch people. also the mafia cant change their claims anymore, escorts cannot fuck up on rbing conf townies, tis will only target potential Evil candidates, vig will shoot conf evils and vet will just save all of their alerts or randomlt use them since no Town has the need of visiting a Vet claim while the Mafia needs to get rid of him sooner or later anyways, etc etc
the benefits are enormous compared to the negatives, also not to mention the fact of how 2 tos strongest MAfia roles (although consig is not that strong, but in tos he is because the community is brain dead) are completely useless, Janitor can only erase wills now and Consig can only be used to find NEs
Return to Strategic Discussion
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 27 guests