I will probably update the OP with additional puzzles, but let's start with 4 which are extreme.
Information and rules
- In all scenarios you are playing ranked game as the Godfather.
- Jailor's meta is in the play and whole Town is following Jailor's meta.
- NE are siding with the Mafia. You can control their actions as long as they are not against they win conditions.
- You can control NK's actions as long as they are not against they win conditions.
- Town is playing logically and don't take unnecessary risk.
- You know roles in play. But you don't know who has which role.
- All TIs claim D2 except for Lookout.
- Lookout informs the Jailor about visits D2, D3 etc.
Example
Setup:
Jailor
Sheriff
Spy
Doctor
Medium
Veteran
Medium
Sheriff
Sheriff
Godfather
Mafioso
Consort
Forger
Executioner
Arsonist
Spoiler:
Scenario 1
Setup:
Jailor
Investigator
Lookout
Doctor
Mayor
Veteran
Investigator
Spy
Sheriff
Godfather
Mafioso
Framer
Janitor
Executioner
Arsonist
Scenario 2
Setup:
Jailor
Sheriff
Spy
Bodyguard
Medium
Vigilante
Bodyguard
Doctor
Doctor
Godfather
Mafioso
Framer
Forger
Witch
Arsonist
Scenario 3
Setup:
Jailor
Investigator
Spy
Bodyguard
Transporter
Vigilante
Vigilante
Vigilante
Vigilante
Godfather
Mafioso
Disguiser
Janitor
Executioner
Arsonist
Scenario 4
Setup:
Jailor
Investigator
Lookout
Bodyguard
Retributionist
Vigilante
Transporter
Mayor
Transporter
Godfather
Mafioso
Consort
Framer
Jester
Werewolf
What you should do in each puzzle.
1. What roles your Mafia should claim in certain situations jailed/busted/vfr/free?
2. What is the strategy? (e.g. gf will try to deepwolf; we play passive; we accuse someone; etc.)
3. What is the tactic? (e.g. gf will accuse Mafia member for being mafia with a Sheriff claim; Forger will accuse Sheriff for being Mafia with a Sheriff claim; etc.)
4. Additional comments.
Try to be as detailed as you can!
The best solution would be the one with highest probability to win which I will calculate later. Calculations will be revealed.