it cant just do everything for town. That would makeit townsided. The clean is just as harmful as a janitor clean. Its not like doible wont claim its role.
its already killing one of its own allies to join their side I think thats plenty harmful!
Wills shouldnt even exist. But regardless a will will never provide THAT much info
with jailor transporter and invest their wills provide tons of info... if town had no wills evils win waaaay more town needs them trust me but that's a separate issue
See its not really hurting its faction it's just replacing one person in it. Amne gives town or maf another role, which is bad. This just takes a current role
you may as well just make the game start with 14 people then if that's gonna be your argument,
============================================================
pretend this role kills a town member joins town
in this case mafia doesn't have to waste a night killing that person so one extra person dies
it isnt a net gain of 0 with u killing and replacing the person its a loss of -1
since an extra person dies now sooner since mafia doesn't have waste a night killing a person since you did it for them,
Ye its not, and thats exactly why double is better
its better at not confirming itself but other then that no its very hurtful to the side it joins
btw i think you understand what im saying but dont want to admit it cause ive cleary explained it 3 times in a row mantee, i will not be doing so again,
its simple math town is gonna die one day sooner cause you one them anemsaic takes the place of someone who has already been killed so town will die at the same pace
=========================================================
Flake wrote:The way I see it is that Double is a more balanced but slightly less fun variation of the Amnesiac. That is, more balanced in terms of not reducing/increasing the win chances of other factions when it is outside of said factions' control (like Amnesiac does), and less fun in terms of the person being killed (as they are denied from playing). The latter isn't really a huge issue, since you could argue that all killing roles aren't fun by the same standard.
I see no reason as to why both cannot coexist.
its much worse then anme flake read above why