HereThereEverywhere wrote:What are the reasons it needs to heal people, and why? You said you can heal the person your target attacks to get them killed, but that's a very inefficient way to kill them, because you have no guarantee they'll actually attack that person. There's also healing the person the enthralled says they will kill at daytime, but you assume they'll tell the truth instead of lying or just whispering it. You said it has multiple reasons, which is true, but they're both reasons that wont come up all that often. It's ability is it's greatest weakness, the ability I'm talking about is the killing ability, since you have so little control over who dies.
it doesn't NEED to be used it an optional reactionary ability that fixes its horrible weakness of its own ability being used against it, it can also be used to kill enthralled if you predict who they attack sure it's not an easy thing to do but it same principle of TP predicting who evils attacks, it can be used heal witch to save an ally or jester to make them look the siren and susp helping them win at same time keeping a mafia alive a bit longer so they distract town for you into late is a reason as well
those are multiple reasons,
btw potion master is an evil role who can heal and yea it has a team but this role has has witch and jester and NEEDS this ability otherwise its own ability will out itself
theres no reason an enthralled would randomly lie who it attack in day time chat that serves no purpose if it cant kill the person it dies and has no will so lying during the day accomplishes nothing
i admit i did not consider whispering a friend you trust who you will kill and that is a counter. but it has many stipulations to it, first you need someone you trust and then the person they actually attack has to be the siren, theres multiple reasons a person could have a basic defense including TP healing them
if all these factors happen or don't happen it's still that person's word vs yours since it was a whisper and not a public announcement same thing happens with sheriff and finding mafia claims who is the liar?