ProfessorArceus wrote:I have a few problems with this role. Mainly the fact that it will most likely be a Medium claim (I'm assuming those will be invest results).
Also, this role can kill roles very easily, I'm afraid that is is very overpowered. If you see a scum who will be lynched the next day, you take the Town with it. I would also like to know how and when the bound people dies. Is it the day they are hung, the next night? Consider roleblocking the bound target who will be dying, and killing them the next day? What will be the death message?
Overall, it's a nice idea. I've only made a short post here because it's late and I want this to be in the View my Posts section so I can comment later.
ProfessorArceus wrote: Spoiler:
So it's a protective Neutral evil? I like the idea, but it seems a bit too powerful like that. See if it was an aggressive Neutral Evil, it wouldn't take the Town's main way of killing. The trial system gives Town an unstoppable daily weapon, and this defeats the point of waiting until day. The protective neutral like this, from what I can see, prevents deaths from the trial.
I suggest a more aggressive neutral, which allows Town to still use their trials, but with a constant possibility that another Town might die too?
Also, wouldn't Jester get fucked if it rolled as the any?
I've probably misunderstood this role again, sorry.
Also, I trust that this doesn't work like the old Disguiser when you say "lives on in the second target's body"?
ProfessorArceus wrote:Also didn't you make a role with a similar name? Would it be a problem if they both got into tg or the game?
BS4125 wrote:ProfessorArceus wrote:Also didn't you make a role with a similar name? Would it be a problem if they both got into tg or the game?
I'm abandoning the old one because however much I try to make it not confirmable it destroys core mechanics
roz1roz wrote:Actualy it's simlar to Nercomorph, cause it allows dead scum to still perform theirs role.
It still is slightly weaker then it cause Spiritualist does not adapt the defense of it's target.
On the other side lookouts/trackers can't really see it, cause he does not perform action instead of the scum. Scum does it, cause they still "live" bound to someone.
Generaly very interesting concept.
roz1roz wrote:I'm thinking of actualy increasing number of max. revenants (?)
BS4125 wrote:roz1roz wrote:I'm thinking of actualy increasing number of max. revenants (?)
Hmm... I'm not sure. I'll have to think about it
Shilster wrote:Question.
What if the second target is Esc/Cons/Trans, and the first is Spy/BM/Jailor,
and when the first target dies, they live on as the second?
Do the second's invest results change?
Also, if Mafioso attacks the first target (ex. Jester), and your target second target is a Mafia (ex. Consort), then will they know that their Consort has disappeared from their window?
Shilster wrote:If the first "dies", will the body die?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 12 guests