Mace8937 wrote:This transition makes the jester even more evil, not benign.
Benign roles, in my point of view with the survivor, are supposed to not hinder the game any which way. They are supposed to lay low and help whichever faction they think will lead them to victory.
In this case with this new Jester idea, this severely changes the games and kind one sided towards making the town unable to do anything.
Bodyguards on a mayor won't save them, if mafia is unable to kill and jailor jails a town member then they will think the jailed in a mafia.
However, the killers, mafia and NK are only stopped from killing for one night. One! Its a role block with no dead escorts or actual escort to begin with!
And as for jester-afraid people not lynching, they're just not skilled. Any good player would be able to make reads and know if its a jester or a mafia or NK
HereThereEverywhere wrote:The problem with your view on NBs is that it doesn't allow for much variation. Not to mention, if it doesn't make an impact on the game, why even have it?
HereThereEverywhere wrote:The problem with your view on NBs is that it doesn't allow for much variation. Not to mention, if it doesn't make an impact on the game, why even have it?
Shilster wrote:HereThereEverywhere wrote:The problem with your view on NBs is that it doesn't allow for much variation. Not to mention, if it doesn't make an impact on the game, why even have it?
*cough* Amnesiac remembers Mafia *cough*
Parallax7 wrote:Shilster wrote:HereThereEverywhere wrote:The problem with your view on NBs is that it doesn't allow for much variation. Not to mention, if it doesn't make an impact on the game, why even have it?
*cough* Amnesiac remembers Mafia *cough*
What's your point? Amnesiac could also very well remember Jailor, or Mayor.
Villagerlover wrote:Parallax7 wrote:Shilster wrote:HereThereEverywhere wrote:The problem with your view on NBs is that it doesn't allow for much variation. Not to mention, if it doesn't make an impact on the game, why even have it?
*cough* Amnesiac remembers Mafia *cough*
What's your point? Amnesiac could also very well remember Jailor, or Mayor.
Uuuuh no. They can't.
The Amnesiac can only remember Unique roles that aren't Town. It even says it right on the role card...
Parallax7 wrote:Villagerlover wrote:Parallax7 wrote:Shilster wrote:HereThereEverywhere wrote:The problem with your view on NBs is that it doesn't allow for much variation. Not to mention, if it doesn't make an impact on the game, why even have it?
*cough* Amnesiac remembers Mafia *cough*
What's your point? Amnesiac could also very well remember Jailor, or Mayor.
Uuuuh no. They can't.
The Amnesiac can only remember Unique roles that aren't Town. It even says it right on the role card...
They can't....?
Parallax7 wrote:Villagerlover wrote:Parallax7 wrote:Shilster wrote:HereThereEverywhere wrote:The problem with your view on NBs is that it doesn't allow for much variation. Not to mention, if it doesn't make an impact on the game, why even have it?
*cough* Amnesiac remembers Mafia *cough*
What's your point? Amnesiac could also very well remember Jailor, or Mayor.
Uuuuh no. They can't.
The Amnesiac can only remember Unique roles that aren't Town. It even says it right on the role card...
They can't....?
HereThereEverywhere wrote:Amnesiac, during the PTR when it was originally updated to remember uniques, could remember roles like Jailor and Mayor. Community feedback led the Devs to change this so it can only remember non-unique Town roles.
Parallax7 wrote:Bumping my thread up because I wanna get some more support/thought - concerns.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Joacgroso wrote:Parallax7 wrote:Bumping my thread up because I wanna get some more support/thought - concerns.
Wait... is that allowed
Ralozey wrote:Joacgroso wrote:Parallax7 wrote:Bumping my thread up because I wanna get some more support/thought - concerns.
Wait... is that allowed
The OP is allowed to bump their thread whenever they want. If the OP is using this priviledge too excessively though we will intervene.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Joacgroso wrote:Ralozey wrote:Joacgroso wrote:Parallax7 wrote:Bumping my thread up because I wanna get some more support/thought - concerns.
Wait... is that allowed
The OP is allowed to bump their thread whenever they want. If the OP is using this priviledge too excessively though we will intervene.
Is that allowed in every forum, or only in role ideas?
Ralozey wrote:Joacgroso wrote:Ralozey wrote:Joacgroso wrote:Parallax7 wrote:Bumping my thread up because I wanna get some more support/thought - concerns.
Wait... is that allowed
The OP is allowed to bump their thread whenever they want. If the OP is using this priviledge too excessively though we will intervene.
Is that allowed in every forum, or only in role ideas?
Every Forum except those who have special rules (DR, FM etc.)
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Soulshade55r wrote:My suggestion would be if jester gets hung no one can vote the next day, helps scum and doesn't help town.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests