Re: Cult (Faction)
Posted: Sun Dec 03, 2017 12:33 am
It’s very hard to kill all TKs when you have 0.5 kpn, let alone survive to the late game. It’s the town’s fault for not catching you at that point. I feel it is self explanatory that the average day length would be longer with the cult
only guaranteed tk who can kill you is jailor vet can be tk and then cant kill you.
there can end up being no vig so jailor will be your only counter late game it will be very likely jailor is dead
and keep in mind if you know who jailor the last killer alive is you can just vote them to stand night after you reveal and hang your last counter this role is still OP
False. Domming somebody isn’t killing them. You need to get them lynched or hope that the nk of tk catche them
so what about the cutthroat doesnt he kill every night cant he just kill doomed targets for you?
if he cant then two doomed every night on average you get this done by n4 or n5 then it might be balanced accept remove powerful attacks
Ritualist only works for lynching
your role says
- Chooses 2 players per night, preparing his target's body to be switched upon the death of a certain cult member
you have this worded absolutely horribly then this heavily implies they can die in anyway it doesn't say upon hanging
I mean the guy that attacked the trickster, so jailor and vig counter, but I forgot to put (Basic attack) so not nk counter
this role is interesting then i would rather it have 3 charges and only last a night but not die if it runs out charges
Exactly, remember the whole 0.5 kpn means that the roles are naturally more powerful to account for it
ok you're implying that cutthroat isn't a role in the faction but its listed as role im so confused, WHY DO YOU HAVE CUTTHROAT AS A ROLE IF IT ISN'T IN THE FACTION
this completely changes how rate the faction if it only has .5 kills you need make it clear that this faction only has .5 kills a night and that cutthroat doesn't appear as a role in the faction
i might go through again grade each role based on this new info but not right now
You do know that spiritualisr can only do things when killed right? That’s a big negative
you're missing my point they are both roles where a thing only happens if someone dies from hanging
all it takes is just having only one town vote to kill you and this role is trash my point was you should merge two roles somehow or just remove cause this is to weak
------------------------------------------------
keep in mind i thought this faction had 1.5 kills a night the whole letting this faction kill NK more of a worse idea
then the nk has too much control over killing since the game is moving slower and less efficiently for the town, meaning that before the cult would be able to stop the nk he could easily clean them out
keep in mind i thought this faction had 1.5 kills a night the whole time i previously reviewed this
letting this faction kill NK more of a worse idea now that i know it only has .5 kills
kill NK when you only have .5 kills is A HORRIBLE idea you need them alive till there very end
games will easily last to night 9 or 10 if nk dies early you will lose by then
if you can accidently kill NK early on guarantee your faction looses becuase town will die to slowly and be able to gather enough info to hang you
infact if try tries to hang or kill NK early you should do everything in your power to keep nk alive that how important is it to your faction winning since it only has .5 kill a night
not only is it fair a team of 4 people can kill a player who is solo vrs the rest the game its also basically a guaranteed loss for you faction if you Kill NK early on
how would you like it you were nk and just got kill accidently N2 no strategy no chance can win nothing you could've done you had no chance to counter this and have no allies in your win condition so you just straight up loose
why do you think that's fair tell
evil actions are meant to use voting to kill NK they should never be able to directly kill NK during the night
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
now that this cut throat not being in the faction even though its a role in your list thing is cleared
i think this faction is a lot fairer now expect you basically shitting on NK this faction has has huge potential