Salamandos35 wrote:I'm not the guy who made this, but:
Oracle just gets a pile of visitor names I'm pretty sure. No indication of who visited who.
The "medium copy" and "janitor copy"... medium is something that doesn't have a strong evil CC and janitor is just a good role which is essential/useful enough to justify recycling.
Scholar is less OP than you think because it only gets half as many roles/night as consig does. Sure, it gets alignments, but those are worth a lot less.
Mortician - Since the Mortician can't do anything with his puppet, the reasonable option probably means not counting it for vote purposes. It'll be noticed, but then you have to figure out who the puppet is...
No, the Oracle will first get, Player A cultist was visited by an invesigator and transporter, Player B....
But if somebody visits again to another it will be;
Player A cultist was visited by a lookout and the doctor, Player B...
"You recognize a face. It belongs to [Visitors name here]!"
Yea the medium copy thing is a lot different than the normal medium and it converted to an evil role, which CC's the medium. As the Janitor there is a good argument that it is copied but I feel like it was alreasy a super good role and it is hard to change that without ruining the balance of it.
I do feel the scholar is balanced, sure he can get pure answers every other day and 1 alignment, but hat is actually worse than the consigliere. The way I would do it is that you would only revisit somebody if yoy need to know something to help with the Deformer mutations going on, and instead get information on 3 people every 2 days. Also, I would use the double visit when I would find a neutral player.
Yea Salamando's got it. It won't affect the number of votes, which sure hardcore players will notice(Personally I never even notice the "this many votes for voting up" thing until we are at a standstill and almost voting somebody up), but they cant find the puppet througg this. Discovering the puppet is really just a waste of your night though, unless you are lookout and find out it was a puppet...
I definitely enjoy the feedback though, I will take note of it, from both of you
EDIT: I also noticed how it would require both the Defotmer and the Cleric to be alive to night 6 in order to hit max deformities/mutations, which is highly unlikely and should be rewarded well. But i dont think more are needed because of this.