Evil Doctor (Clumsy)

[marlony1]

Evil Doctor


Town Gamethrowing

50/50 chance of healing or killing someone each night.

As the game goes on and half the town dies you have a 75/25 chance of healing

Attributes: Can't be framed








It doesn't count as a joke role submission to BOTBRI if the thread is already dead

[Damafaud]

Well, this role is interesting. It handicap Sheriiff in a way, and buff framer along the way.

Unfortunately, this role success depends on luck, and it can't work.

[marlony1]

Well, this role is interesting. It handicap Sheriiff in a way, and buff framer along the way.

Unfortunately, this role success depends on luck, and it can't work.

The thing is. It would kind of work in a way. You are completely right. Luck isnt the best option but, imagine this. There are 3 people left. No one know's you're clumsy. So you would have to make a breath taking decision on who to pick. Do you want to wing it and heal someone? Or hopefully kill the SK. This way the person has to guess what their luck would be and hope to pick their right person. Or maybe in a 12 person game. You are completely SURE someone is the SK. So you decide to keep on being "clumsy" to him. I know, both of my points just proved your point. But luck is sometimes fun and helps the viewer think. (If there is anyway I could possibly fix the luck chance. Like at the F5 its a 80/20 percent chance of killing or healing. Then tell me. Thanks! This is my first role suggestion and im glad to know you think its at least "interesting" which is what I was going for!). Like the idea?!

[Yoshiking13]

Rng, I cannot support this.

[marlony1]

If you're not going to support it. At least say why. That's probably one of the reasons replies exist. This is of course the first suggestion and in order to make better roles I need constructive criticism to grow on. I'm not Michael bay..
RNG is bad, I get it. But can you please tell me some ways to fix it? Im trying my best to fix it, by not only making so that you're not forced to be clumsy, but you also have a bigger chance of healing. If I removed the RNG all together the point of the role would be lost.

[marlony1]

Thanks for all the feedback. I now know that roles should not be unfairly luck based. I justubmitted the ideas as soon as I came up with them, and now I decided that that's not the best idea in the world. I shall think for at least 10 minutes on each role idea before submitting.

[Spectre0]

I'm really surprised that Damafaud was so passively unsupportive of such a ridiculous role.

"Attributes : Can't be framed"

What the shit? Why?

"Abilities : Has a 50/50 chance of healing or killing someone (Auto kills if he doesnt choose)"

Lolno.exe

"When writing a death note (e.g. Sorry for killing you), a sloppy drawing of a picture with crayon seems to have a weird line in the middle of it (As if he messed up in between drawing)"

What the shit? Why?

"When put into jail, every time you try to say "Clumsy" you stumble up your words and say "Clums-E""

What the shit? WHY?

"Someone told me that "luck" isn't the best option. So I think the more you play the game you get smarter and you eventually increase your percentages to heal. For example when there are 15 people it's a 50/50. When there's 10 its a 60/40. When there's 5 its a 70/30 chance of healing. What do you think about the edit?"

What the shit? Why?

This role is a terrible concept with a bunch of strange and pointless attributes taped on for the sake of lore.

And changing RNG with less people is as ridiculous as the RNG in the first place, especially since TK's have more use end-game.

[deathofrats0808]

This role's ability depends entirely on RNG to do their night action. The game should be based off of skill, not luck. Obviously there are some things that can't be avoided such as random town's but luck of the draw should be avoided as much as possible.

If you want a fix, you could make it so that you're a healer, but if your target isn't attacked, you kill that player. Then it would at least be decent, not sure if optimal but definitely workable. And remove frame immunity, framer is weak as is.

FTFY

[deathofrats0808]

Whoops. Found this through the BOTBRI thread and didn't see when the last post was.

[lemonader666]

>Start out as a real role idea
>Realize mistake
>Make into a BOTBRI role
>Laughter.png

[HereThereEverywhere]

I was honestly scared when I saw this, I didn't realize the date at first.

[Jackparrot]

This role's ability depends entirely on RNG to do their night action. The game should be based off of luck, not skill. why?Obviously there are some things that can't be avoided such as random town's but luck of the draw should be avoided as much as possible.

If you want a fix, you could make it so that you're a healer, but if your target isn't attacked, you kill that player. Then it would at least be decent, not sure if optimal but definitely workable. And remove frame immunity, framer is weak as is.

[lemonader666]

This role's ability depends entirely on RNG to do their night action. The game should be based off of luck, not skill. why?Obviously there are some things that can't be avoided such as random town's but luck of the draw should be avoided as much as possible.

If you want a fix, you could make it so that you're a healer, but if your target isn't attacked, you kill that player. Then it would at least be decent, not sure if optimal but definitely workable. And remove frame immunity, framer is weak as is.

This role is a failed role already OP even said it stop bumping

[lemonader666]

My eyes have been opened

This role is a failed role already OP even said it stop bumping

[marlony1]

oh god why the necrobump, now the mods will see this joke role



well technically they would never notice and i have the freedom to do whatever i want to a dead thread and i cant be punished or banned for other random people necrobumping, but stilll