ThyMason122 wrote:I have a feeling this is just a mafia sided version of the "Politician" role. That was in the testing grounds a few days ago.
Kirize wrote:I didnt know you could contradict yourself in one sentencekookeekwisp wrote:Dont single out Arso cause it kills slower!
PoptartPresident wrote:ThyMason122 wrote:I have a feeling this is just a mafia sided version of the "Politician" role. That was in the testing grounds a few days ago.
wait...there was already someone who came up with this?
kookeekwisp wrote:Please don't ignore the stickies. The role card format is there for a reason.
Name+Alignment, Win condition, Abilities, Attributes, Special attributes, Side-notes & Invest results.
Also, giving a full tutorial on your own role that's not in the game is a bit narrow-minded.
PoptartPresident wrote:kookeekwisp wrote:Please don't ignore the stickies. The role card format is there for a reason.
Name+Alignment, Win condition, Abilities, Attributes, Special attributes, Side-notes & Invest results.
Also, giving a full tutorial on your own role that's not in the game is a bit narrow-minded.
Maybe the whole format thing is just you.
I personally get a better feel for a role when I visually imagine playing it in-game. But I will update for the sake.
Cenas4life wrote:Sounds too much like the neutral politician role which wss executed better than this one. /No Support.
Villagerlover wrote:Cenas4life wrote:Sounds too much like the neutral politician role which wss executed better than this one. /No Support.
*was
Okay first off, the politician role is a neutral evil role. And secondly, the political role should be a Mafia member because a neutral role that has the ability to control other people's votes is stupid. Someone who has the ability to control votes should be a Mafia member because they can keep a townie from voting. That is EXTREMELY USEFUL.
And in this role, you don't "control" the votes. You just block them.
I think the politician role should actually be the name of this idea because even though the Vote Blocker and the Politician roles have similar abilities, this Mafia-sided version is waaaaaaay more concise than the politician who keeps constantly changing the way his role works.
This role idea is clear, to the point, and only helps the Mafia, a side that doesn't win nearly as much as the currently overpowered town.
Cenas4life wrote:Villagerlover wrote:Cenas4life wrote:Sounds too much like the neutral politician role which wss executed better than this one. /No Support.
*was
Okay first off, the politician role is a neutral evil role. And secondly, the political role should be a Mafia member because a neutral role that has the ability to control other people's votes is stupid. Someone who has the ability to control votes should be a Mafia member because they can keep a townie from voting. That is EXTREMELY USEFUL.
And in this role, you don't "control" the votes. You just block them.
I think the politician role should actually be the name of this idea because even though the Vote Blocker and the Politician roles have similar abilities, this Mafia-sided version is waaaaaaay more concise than the politician who keeps constantly changing the way his role works.
This role idea is clear, to the point, and only helps the Mafia, a side that doesn't win nearly as much as the currently overpowered town.
Roles that can block, control, or get extra votes are very powerful, and likewise that is why I think they should be neutral instead of mafia. If mafia got one of these roles, they would become too powerful. Just think about the mafia with a mayorish role. That is what this would become.
BPsycho2 wrote:Mafia doesnt need this.
Spam1985 wrote:The current decription make it sounds like the person is blackmailed, afraid to vote for fear of having their identity revealed.
For variety's sake, how about calling it something like:
Thug
Hooligan
Goon
Ruffian
Mobster
Basically, a bully who will beat you up. You cannot raise your hand to vote because you are crippled? I don't know I'm just toying with ideas.
EternalRage wrote:Make your own message?
"A (name) has threatened to attack you! You are vote-blocked"
Villagerlover wrote:Cenas4life wrote:Villagerlover wrote:Cenas4life wrote:Sounds too much like the neutral politician role which wss executed better than this one. /No Support.
*was
Okay first off, the politician role is a neutral evil role. And secondly, the political role should be a Mafia member because a neutral role that has the ability to control other people's votes is stupid. Someone who has the ability to control votes should be a Mafia member because they can keep a townie from voting. That is EXTREMELY USEFUL.
And in this role, you don't "control" the votes. You just block them.
I think the politician role should actually be the name of this idea because even though the Vote Blocker and the Politician roles have similar abilities, this Mafia-sided version is waaaaaaay more concise than the politician who keeps constantly changing the way his role works.
This role idea is clear, to the point, and only helps the Mafia, a side that doesn't win nearly as much as the currently overpowered town.
Roles that can block, control, or get extra votes are very powerful, and likewise that is why I think they should be neutral instead of mafia. If mafia got one of these roles, they would become too powerful. Just think about the mafia with a mayorish role. That is what this would become.
"Just become too powerful" okay. So you're saying the mafia, the ones that's supposed to be the more powerful team, are too OP with this role idea?? If anything the TOWN is the one that needs nerfs. Especially in ranked mode.
"Just think about the mafia with a mayorish role" okay, the Godfather? Cause you know the moment the godfather gets investigated, you're dead son.
Same goes for just about any of the mafia roles really.
I don't even think you read this idea because it clearly summarizes near the end that "this role would be too OP if there was too many of them, so they should be unique."
And you're saying the Politician, a 4th neutral evil role (Cause that's TOTALLY what's on demand), with an author who keeps changing the goal currently, would be better than one extra mafia role that the mafia reallllllllly needs?? Especially with the fact that the disguiser will leave soon??
I don't think you've ever even played mafia at that point.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests