Here is my take on it:
Essentially, the mafia killing system currently works, but only works well with 4 members with two being mafia killings (GF and Mafioso). Without both roles being in the same game, the mafia can be essentially brought to a halt by 2 roles. Jailor and Escort. All it takes is a lucky n1 choice and then one member of the Mafia is caught out, and mafia is then at a disadvantage. Well, what can be done to fix this? Rework mafia kills so any member can do it. I mean, they all have the mental capacity to perform the kill, apart from maybe framer. But then what would happen to GF, Mafioso and how would the player and game determine who would perform kills. Well here is my doings of TMK. (With the addition of reworked Mafioso, Framer buff and a New Role)
The New Mafia
Mafia(Killing)
Godfather
Ambusher
Stalker
Mafia(Deception)
Disguiser
Forger
Framer
Hypnotist
Mafia(Support)
Consort
Consigliere
Janitor
Mafioso
Role Changes:
Mafia:
All mafia members can vote for themselves to perform the kill, and who to kill. All mafia members also have a base value of basic attack. No members of the Mafia turn into Mafioso or Godfather anymore. In the case of 1 or more people volunteering for the kill, let your fate rest in the RNG gods.
Summary for the voting:
Godfather has first say on who will be killing and who to kill.
If Godfather selects nothing, a member of the Mafia that has volunteered will do the kill. If a tie occurs then RNG. If no one votes, no one attacks.
Mafia(Killing)
Godfather:
Spoiler:
Stalker:
Spoiler:
Mafia(Deception)
Framer:
Spoiler:
Mafia(Support)
Mafioso:
Spoiler:
Summary/TL;DR:
Godfather becomes the boss of more then just the Mafioso.
Stalker is a new role that shakes things up with visits.
Mafia members can now vote to kill and can volunteer for themselves to do the kills.
Framer now has a reason to do something with their lives, affecting all TI
Mafioso now becomes Mafia LO.
Examples:
Mafia:
Godfather
Janitor
Consort
Consigliere
For simplicity sake, let the names of the players be there roles.
Mafia
Godfather: Should I kill or someone else?
Consigliere: you do the kill
Game: Godfather has ordered Consigliere to kill tonight.
Game: Godfather has voted to attack Player1 tonight.
Consigliere: screw you, I could've checked PLAYER to see if they actually are survivor
Game: Janitor has decided to clean Player1 tonight.
Game: Janitor has voted to kill Player1 tonight.
Game: Consort has decided to roleblock Player3
Game: Consort has nominated themselves to kill tonight.
Consort: I'll do the kill, they are on to me anyways
Game: Day 4
What happened:
Player1 was killed as they had 2 votes on them with no ties on votes. Player1 also was cleaned by Janitor. So Player1 was killed by Consigliere and cleaned by Janitor. Consort roleblocked Player3 as the Godfather ordered Consigliere to kill Player1.
Feedback is appreciated.