Page 1 of 1

Drugger (Mafia Support)

PostPosted: Mon Sep 07, 2020 7:08 am
by Romanelu00
Role Name: Drugger


Role Alignment: Mafia Support


Attack: None
Defense: None


Abilities: Choose 1 target to drug each night.


Attributes: Successfully drugged targets will not be able to read the chat and whispers sent to them the following day, but can still write messages in chat and whisper to other people. If a doctor visits the target during the night the drugging fails. If a target is drugged 3 times in a row they will overdose and die. Only a doctor can save the target from a overdose.


Goal: Kill anyone that will not submit to the Mafia.


Win Conditions: Same as other mafia roles.


Investigator Results:
Sheriff - Your target is suspicious!
Investigator - Spy/Bmer/Jailor/Drugger
Consigliere - Your target secretly drugs people, they must be a drugger!


Achievements:

Street Dealer --- 1 Drugger win
Snowwhite --- 5 Drugger wins
Master Cook --- 10 Drugger wins
Pablo Escobar --- 25 Drugger wins
Good stuff --- Succesfully drug someone
Loyal Customer --- Succesfully overdose someone
Boss, try this! --- Drug the Godfather
Why does my drink taste weird? --- Drug yourself


Would love to hear opinions!

Re: Drugger (Mafia Support)

PostPosted: Mon Sep 07, 2020 8:01 am
by OreCreeper
So just a reverse blackmailer? It might work but the overdose part is really dumb. Mafia Support roles should not be able to kill.

Re: Drugger (Mafia Support)

PostPosted: Mon Sep 07, 2020 8:01 am
by OreCreeper
So just a reverse blackmailer? It might work but the overdose part is really dumb. Mafia Support roles should not be able to kill.

Re: Drugger (Mafia Support)

PostPosted: Mon Sep 07, 2020 8:41 am
by RiceHatMan
I guess this role is different? I don't get the Doctor and overdose part though. The Doctor part as in you cannot drug important townies, and the overdose part as in it's unnecessary and a MS shouldn't be able to kill. This role is kind of underwhelming, and there isn't much else to say about it.

Re: Drugger (Mafia Support)

PostPosted: Mon Sep 07, 2020 9:04 am
by Ezradekezra
I'm not a fan of the overdose mechanic, but I can see this being useful against a Jailor or Mayor.

Re: Drugger (Mafia Support)

PostPosted: Mon Sep 07, 2020 9:06 am
by KAKERMAN23
just saying, the hypnotist was originally called the drug dealer when it was suggested, but was changed, so i dont think the name "drugger" is gonna pass

Re: Drugger (Mafia Support)

PostPosted: Mon Sep 07, 2020 9:16 am
by Romanelu00
Harryyoshi wrote:I guess this role is different? I don't get the Doctor and overdose part though. The Doctor part as in you cannot drug important townies, and the overdose part as in it's unnecessary and a MS shouldn't be able to kill. This role is kind of underwhelming, and there isn't much else to say about it.



The Doctor part is there to block the drugger from actually destroying the jailor. He could just drug the jailor everynight and that would really be op. the overdose part is there to balance the role a bit, imagine a blackmailer without hearing whispers, that would make the blackmailer easily the worst mafia role.

Re: Drugger (Mafia Support)

PostPosted: Mon Sep 07, 2020 10:07 am
by RiceHatMan
Romanelu00 wrote:
Harryyoshi wrote:I guess this role is different? I don't get the Doctor and overdose part though. The Doctor part as in you cannot drug important townies, and the overdose part as in it's unnecessary and a MS shouldn't be able to kill. This role is kind of underwhelming, and there isn't much else to say about it.



The Doctor part is there to block the drugger from actually destroying the jailor. He could just drug the jailor everynight and that would really be op. the overdose part is there to balance the role a bit, imagine a blackmailer without hearing whispers, that would make the blackmailer easily the worst mafia role.

I guess this should be MK then? This role has the potential to kill, and TPs counter this role, so I don't see why this role shouldn't be MK instead of MS. Right now, this role is half MS and half MS. I don't see why drugging the Jailor would be OP, you can Blackmail the Jailor and many of the results would be the same. Even if it is, it would disincentivize the Jailor meta. Right now, this role is underwhelming in the killing and supporting aspect, because how are you going to drug the same person 3 nights in a row, and people can still say "I'm drugged, here's my info". The whole point of Blackmailer to it keep someone quiet and prevent that info from getting out. This role makes it so one specific person won't get info at all. I don't see this working early nor late game, since people can still communicate through votes. E.g. You are drugged and you say, "player 1, vote player 7 if xyz". Why is this mutually exclusive to Drugger and not Blackmailer? It's because other people need to ask you questions as a blackmailed, while as a drugged, you make the communication. You rely on others to help you communicate as a blackmailed, anyway, and that is very unreliable.

Re: Drugger (Mafia Support)

PostPosted: Mon Sep 07, 2020 12:28 pm
by MaikeruSapphire
It's an interesting idea, but it might be better with Coven (if you get the necronomicon, you deal a basic attack on the first dose) and with only 2 "doses" needed for a kill.

Another thing that might be an issue is the political-correctness of this role...

EDIT: Maybe the drugged players could have their messages scrambled, but at that point it's just a blackmailer lol

Re: Drugger (Mafia Support)

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2020 3:25 am
by Brilliand
Coven already has Poisoner, so the overdose mechanic wouldn't be good as a *new* Coven role anyway.

I think the overdose mechanic and the Doctor heal part need to be scrapped. After that... I'm thinking this idea would work best as an additional power for Blackmailer, while the "hear whispers" ability is moved from Blackmailer to Forger.

A reverse blackmailer without the direct blackmailing ability has the problem that it's too easy for the target to directly claim 'drugged' or whatever.

Re: Drugger (Mafia Support)

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2020 8:14 am
by KAKERMAN23
this is a bit of a stretch, but maybe the people who overdose don't die but are maybe roleblocked, but are then immune to drugging? i know that's not how drugs work but i think it's better than killing them outright

Re: Drugger (Mafia Support)

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2020 4:24 pm
by Mystoc
if they can see whispers that entirely defeats the purpose of the role

i like this role cause u can fake being drugged very easy this a a good tool for evils or jestors to use

the overdose part is meh 3 visits for a death is long and balanced but mafia support isnt supposed to kill

Re: Drugger (Mafia Support)

PostPosted: Wed Sep 09, 2020 3:28 am
by Romanelu00
Mystoc wrote:if they can see whispers that entirely defeats the purpose of the role


They can't see whispers but can whisper to other players.
This ofcourse also applies to the open chat, they can't see the chat but can still write messages.