Town of Salem Game Forums

Jesters should only win when they haunt, not when they are lynched.
And the random haunt feature should be removed, so if a jester doesn't haunt then no one dies and the jester loses.
The reason why this should be implemented is because many jesters use the random haunt which heavily relies on luck.

I don't see the problem with how it works right now

JacksonVirgo wrote:I don't see the problem with how it works right now

I explained the problem in my post, how a lot of jesters use the random haunt feature. It's luck based, and luck based abilities aren't good.

Rivelle wrote:

JacksonVirgo wrote:I don't see the problem with how it works right now

I explained the problem in my post, how a lot of jesters use the random haunt feature. It's luck based, and luck based abilities aren't good.

No jester kill is even worse

JacksonVirgo wrote:

Rivelle wrote:

JacksonVirgo wrote:I don't see the problem with how it works right now

I explained the problem in my post, how a lot of jesters use the random haunt feature. It's luck based, and luck based abilities aren't good.

No jester kill is even worse

But most jesters aren't going to do that, because they won't be able to win.

The game is highly luck-based anyway. I do understand why you would want jester to be forced to play kingmaker, but I don't think it will really matter that much in the end. It is still going to be a roll of the die to determine who the jester feels like siding with today. Also unknown roles and stuff.

Kirize12 wrote:Replace Jester's haunt in general honestly. Strahm is right, since the jester won it has no stake in the game and all of its decisions are luck based.

Agreed.

I think Throne of Lies got it right: "When a Jester is lynched, no one can be voted to the stand the following day." It accurately penalizes the people who want to win by lynching (usually the town, but also the mafia if they get majority).