Page 1 of 1

Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Fri Oct 25, 2019 5:08 am
by Zabuciddin
When jester didin't choose a target for haunting i want to everyone see the message jester randomly picked someone. Because there is many times i played as jester and i had few couple games like Godfather-Jester-Serial Killer. Casually i promise to them if they lynch me i wont choose game will randomly choose everyone has %50-%50 chance. So i want to let them know i didin't pick anything. It is happend to me a lot like Town-Jester-SK i told them if they wont vote for me i will vote who didin't vote for me so that person gonna lose.

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Fri Oct 25, 2019 7:45 am
by ProtoZigg
/support I like jester

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Fri Oct 25, 2019 9:13 am
by Descender
that takes away from the mystery of the game
/nosupport.

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Fri Oct 25, 2019 5:02 pm
by Yosh1123
Jester haunt shouldnt be told like this, you should be able to lie about your haunt

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Sat Oct 26, 2019 3:15 am
by JacksonVirgo
Any Jester win which has Town think it's a jester is a terrible Jester game. The role shouldn't be changed for a win that isn't having Town think you're evil.

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Sat Oct 26, 2019 7:38 am
by Descender
JacksonVirgo wrote:Any Jester win which has Town think it's a jester is a terrible Jester game. The role shouldn't be changed for a win that isn't having Town think you're evil.

imo a diplomatic jester win is a good jester win because you somehow have to get town to trust you. rng killing message would change nothing as an rng kill by jester wouldnt help town most of the time.

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Sat Oct 26, 2019 8:00 am
by JacksonVirgo
Google wrote:
JacksonVirgo wrote:Any Jester win which has Town think it's a jester is a terrible Jester game. The role shouldn't be changed for a win that isn't having Town think you're evil.

imo a diplomatic jester win is a good jester win because you somehow have to get town to trust you. rng killing message would change nothing as an rng kill by jester wouldnt help town most of the time.

Yeah I guess so, I just hate winning by siding with Town or getting to a 1v1v1 it's gross to me

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Sat Oct 26, 2019 8:01 am
by Descender
JacksonVirgo wrote:
Google wrote:
JacksonVirgo wrote:Any Jester win which has Town think it's a jester is a terrible Jester game. The role shouldn't be changed for a win that isn't having Town think you're evil.

imo a diplomatic jester win is a good jester win because you somehow have to get town to trust you. rng killing message would change nothing as an rng kill by jester wouldnt help town most of the time.

Yeah I guess so, I just hate winning by siding with Town or getting to a 1v1v1 it's gross to me

theres better ways to do it. I'll probably make a stratdiscussion thread later

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Sat Oct 26, 2019 9:16 pm
by James2
Zabuciddin wrote:When jester didin't choose a target for haunting i want to everyone see the message jester randomly picked someone. Because there is many times i played as jester and i had few couple games like Godfather-Jester-Serial Killer. Casually i promise to them if they lynch me i wont choose game will randomly choose everyone has %50-%50 chance. So i want to let them know i didin't pick anything. It is happend to me a lot like Town-Jester-SK i told them if they wont vote for me i will vote who didin't vote for me so that person gonna lose.


The jester isn't "supposed" to be able to randomly kill. That's just necessary to provide for cases where the jester doesn't perform their action. Honestly, if anything, the jester should be denied the win if they fail to submit a kill.

Any mechanism which relies on the town (or any other faction) "trusting" kingmakers is against the spirit of the game. Kingmakers should be totally free agents.

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Sun Oct 27, 2019 12:35 am
by Descender
James2 wrote:
Zabuciddin wrote:When jester didin't choose a target for haunting i want to everyone see the message jester randomly picked someone. Because there is many times i played as jester and i had few couple games like Godfather-Jester-Serial Killer. Casually i promise to them if they lynch me i wont choose game will randomly choose everyone has %50-%50 chance. So i want to let them know i didin't pick anything. It is happend to me a lot like Town-Jester-SK i told them if they wont vote for me i will vote who didin't vote for me so that person gonna lose.


The jester isn't "supposed" to be able to randomly kill. That's just necessary to provide for cases where the jester doesn't perform their action. Honestly, if anything, the jester should be denied the win if they fail to submit a kill.

Any mechanism which relies on the town (or any other faction) "trusting" kingmakers is against the spirit of the game. Kingmakers should be totally free agents.

Lovers mode pirate uwu

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Sun Oct 27, 2019 3:57 am
by Zabuciddin
There is a fact called "Jester Roulette" i think devs. able to do that option for us. It has to be done tbh. Don' ignore it pls.

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Sun Oct 27, 2019 4:17 am
by Descender
Zabuciddin wrote:There is a fact called "Jester Roulette" i think devs. able to do that option for us. It has to be done tbh. Don' ignore it pls.

what
what do you mean

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Sun Oct 27, 2019 7:27 am
by James2
Google wrote:
James2 wrote:
Zabuciddin wrote:When jester didin't choose a target for haunting i want to everyone see the message jester randomly picked someone. Because there is many times i played as jester and i had few couple games like Godfather-Jester-Serial Killer. Casually i promise to them if they lynch me i wont choose game will randomly choose everyone has %50-%50 chance. So i want to let them know i didin't pick anything. It is happend to me a lot like Town-Jester-SK i told them if they wont vote for me i will vote who didin't vote for me so that person gonna lose.


The jester isn't "supposed" to be able to randomly kill. That's just necessary to provide for cases where the jester doesn't perform their action. Honestly, if anything, the jester should be denied the win if they fail to submit a kill.

Any mechanism which relies on the town (or any other faction) "trusting" kingmakers is against the spirit of the game. Kingmakers should be totally free agents.

Lovers mode pirate uwu


Once a pirate has won two duels, they can do whatever they want, even in Lovers mode.

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Sun Oct 27, 2019 2:23 pm
by Descender
James2 wrote:
Google wrote:
James2 wrote:
Zabuciddin wrote:When jester didin't choose a target for haunting i want to everyone see the message jester randomly picked someone. Because there is many times i played as jester and i had few couple games like Godfather-Jester-Serial Killer. Casually i promise to them if they lynch me i wont choose game will randomly choose everyone has %50-%50 chance. So i want to let them know i didin't pick anything. It is happend to me a lot like Town-Jester-SK i told them if they wont vote for me i will vote who didin't vote for me so that person gonna lose.


The jester isn't "supposed" to be able to randomly kill. That's just necessary to provide for cases where the jester doesn't perform their action. Honestly, if anything, the jester should be denied the win if they fail to submit a kill.

Any mechanism which relies on the town (or any other faction) "trusting" kingmakers is against the spirit of the game. Kingmakers should be totally free agents.

Lovers mode pirate uwu


Once a pirate has won two duels, they can do whatever they want, even in Lovers mode.

once a jester has been lynched, they can do whatever they want, even if they are a kingmaker

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Sun Oct 27, 2019 5:15 pm
by James2
Google wrote:
James2 wrote:
Google wrote:
James2 wrote:
Zabuciddin wrote:When jester didin't choose a target for haunting i want to everyone see the message jester randomly picked someone. Because there is many times i played as jester and i had few couple games like Godfather-Jester-Serial Killer. Casually i promise to them if they lynch me i wont choose game will randomly choose everyone has %50-%50 chance. So i want to let them know i didin't pick anything. It is happend to me a lot like Town-Jester-SK i told them if they wont vote for me i will vote who didin't vote for me so that person gonna lose.


The jester isn't "supposed" to be able to randomly kill. That's just necessary to provide for cases where the jester doesn't perform their action. Honestly, if anything, the jester should be denied the win if they fail to submit a kill.

Any mechanism which relies on the town (or any other faction) "trusting" kingmakers is against the spirit of the game. Kingmakers should be totally free agents.

Lovers mode pirate uwu


Once a pirate has won two duels, they can do whatever they want, even in Lovers mode.

once a jester has been lynched, they can do whatever they want, even if they are a kingmaker


I agree. My point is that they should have to *choose* their action, like all other kingmakers. They certainly shouldn't be able to prove that they didn't choose, as the OP proposed.

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Sun Oct 27, 2019 7:33 pm
by Kirize12
James2 wrote:
Zabuciddin wrote:When jester didin't choose a target for haunting i want to everyone see the message jester randomly picked someone. Because there is many times i played as jester and i had few couple games like Godfather-Jester-Serial Killer. Casually i promise to them if they lynch me i wont choose game will randomly choose everyone has %50-%50 chance. So i want to let them know i didin't pick anything. It is happend to me a lot like Town-Jester-SK i told them if they wont vote for me i will vote who didin't vote for me so that person gonna lose.


The jester isn't "supposed" to be able to randomly kill. That's just necessary to provide for cases where the jester doesn't perform their action. Honestly, if anything, the jester should be denied the win if they fail to submit a kill.

Any mechanism which relies on the town (or any other faction) "trusting" kingmakers is against the spirit of the game. Kingmakers should be removed.

Fixed that for you, otherwise agreed.

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Mon Oct 28, 2019 2:52 am
by kyuss420
James2 wrote:
Zabuciddin wrote:When jester didin't choose a target for haunting i want to everyone see the message jester randomly picked someone. Because there is many times i played as jester and i had few couple games like Godfather-Jester-Serial Killer. Casually i promise to them if they lynch me i wont choose game will randomly choose everyone has %50-%50 chance. So i want to let them know i didin't pick anything. It is happend to me a lot like Town-Jester-SK i told them if they wont vote for me i will vote who didin't vote for me so that person gonna lose.


The jester isn't "supposed" to be able to randomly kill. That's just necessary to provide for cases where the jester doesn't perform their action. Honestly, if anything, the jester should be denied the win if they fail to submit a kill.

Any mechanism which relies on the town (or any other faction) "trusting" kingmakers is against the spirit of the game. Kingmakers should be totally free agents.


Idk what spirit of the game youre talking about, but getting opposing factions to trust you before you stab them in the back is very much in the spirit of the game

So OP wants it to be known he let it rando because he doesnt want anyone thinking hes an ass.... really? what an ass.... scared of paybacks in later games or what?

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Mon Oct 28, 2019 11:37 pm
by James2
Kirize12 wrote:
James2 wrote:
Zabuciddin wrote:When jester didin't choose a target for haunting i want to everyone see the message jester randomly picked someone. Because there is many times i played as jester and i had few couple games like Godfather-Jester-Serial Killer. Casually i promise to them if they lynch me i wont choose game will randomly choose everyone has %50-%50 chance. So i want to let them know i didin't pick anything. It is happend to me a lot like Town-Jester-SK i told them if they wont vote for me i will vote who didin't vote for me so that person gonna lose.


The jester isn't "supposed" to be able to randomly kill. That's just necessary to provide for cases where the jester doesn't perform their action. Honestly, if anything, the jester should be denied the win if they fail to submit a kill.

Any mechanism which relies on the town (or any other faction) "trusting" kingmakers is against the spirit of the game. Kingmakers should be removed.

Fixed that for you, otherwise agreed.


Kingmakers are an inherent part of third-party mafia. The only way to get rid of them is to eliminate the neutral roles entirely.

kyuss420 wrote:
James2 wrote:
Zabuciddin wrote:When jester didin't choose a target for haunting i want to everyone see the message jester randomly picked someone. Because there is many times i played as jester and i had few couple games like Godfather-Jester-Serial Killer. Casually i promise to them if they lynch me i wont choose game will randomly choose everyone has %50-%50 chance. So i want to let them know i didin't pick anything. It is happend to me a lot like Town-Jester-SK i told them if they wont vote for me i will vote who didin't vote for me so that person gonna lose.


The jester isn't "supposed" to be able to randomly kill. That's just necessary to provide for cases where the jester doesn't perform their action. Honestly, if anything, the jester should be denied the win if they fail to submit a kill.

Any mechanism which relies on the town (or any other faction) "trusting" kingmakers is against the spirit of the game. Kingmakers should be totally free agents.


Idk what spirit of the game youre talking about, but getting opposing factions to trust you before you stab them in the back is very much in the spirit of the game


Trust, in the general sense, refers to the reliance of people on the presumed honesty of other people. Players in this game "trust" each other based on (perceived) alignment. Authentic trust has no place in the game.

So OP wants it to be known he let it rando because he doesnt want anyone thinking hes an ass.... really? what an ass.... scared of paybacks in later games or what?


Basically. Which is why what he proposes is unfair. He wants to create a reputation for honesty and use it for his future advantage.

Re: Jester automatic haunt message should seen by everyone

PostPosted: Tue Oct 29, 2019 12:02 pm
by ProtoZigg
wtf men jester needs to be heard by all cus jester has no eyes.