Cenvil2 wrote:Blackajack wrote:JazzMusicStops wrote:Seems a little too good in the F2
If it comes to the final two guesses are going to matter more than challenges.
not quite true...
yeah, it can, but this is really OP if it reaches final 2 and has any gift reserve.
It has the same problem as the student had in the past.
Then it should have the same treatment as student, no?
Student was neutered so he built his challenges slower. This was done because he gained too many +2s way too quick. I feel as though a 'late game' role should always exist somewhat, like how MAA is an early game powerhouse as he can kill almost immediately.
If your argument is that ronin/old student is unbeatable in a 1v1 it's time to add to that list Musician, Blacksmith, Knight and a whole bunch of others. They do very similar aspects.
That being said I understand your criticism. Here's a fun modification:
Ronin
You are a Ronin!
Wandering in a land far from your own, you've had to take steps to survive in these strange lands. Now that you finally have the chance to settle down, it's time to put all of your skills to the test.
At the start of the game during the first challenge phase, PM the current moderator and choose either duels or dances. Once you choose, the choice lasts that game.
Your position on the listing you chose is always above the middle of each challenge list, rounded up.
Your position on the listing you didn't choose is always below the middle of each challenge list, rounded down.
These changes takes place after every other position change.
As players die, your position update accordingly based on the remaining pool of players.
This would resolve your problem and also offer a curious level of customisation for your role.