The NFM Stats Thread (upd: January 2nd, 2018, 50g)

[K1llthestory]

Spoiler: Notes: If a slot is replaced twice, that counts as one replaced slot and two replaced players. Therefore, the player rate cannot be any lower than the slot rate. A slot rate of 100% means that all 9 slots were replaced at least once. A player rate of 100% means that 9 players (from any slots) were replaced (so it can exceed 100%). I don't know which type of rate is better to use, though using both is useful (it tells us whether all the replacements came from one slot or were distributed amongst multiple slots). (Reminder: The Matrix6 setup has 9 players, hence why 9 appears in the previous.) As experienced slots aren't actively used anymore, I've removed them from the statistics completely.

Player | Slot Replacement Rate | Player Replacement Rate
Town Newbies; 0%; 0%
Mafia Newbies; 0%; 0%
Neutral Newbies; 0%; 0%
Total Newbies; 0%; 0%

1/7 town replacements; 14%
1/3 mafia replacements; 33%
2/11 slot replacements 18%

2/3 (3/4 player) mafia replacements; 66% slot, 75% player
2/9 town replacements; 22%
3/13 slot replacements (4/14 players replaced out): 23% slot, 29% player

0/13 replacements; 0%

0/13 replacements; 0%

2/9 town replacements; 22%
1/1 neutral replacement; 100%
3/13 slot replacements; 23%

1/3 mafia replacement; 33%
2/9 slot (3/10 player) town replacements; 22% slot, 30% player
3/13 slot replacements (4/13 player replacement); 23% slot, 29% player

END OF 2015

0/13 replacements; 0%

1/9 town replacements; 11%
1/13 replacements; 8%

3/9 town replacements; 33%
3/13 slot replacements; 23%

1/9 town replacement; 11%
1/3 slot (2/4 player) mafia replacements; 33% slot, 50% player
2/13 slot replacements (3/13 player replacements); 15% slot, 23% player

0/13 replacements; 0%.

HUGE SPIKE NFM12
4/10 slot (5/11 player) town replacement; 40% slot, 45% player
2/3 mafia replacement; 66%
6/14 slot replacements (7/14 player replacements); 43% slot, 50% player

2/10 town replacement; 20%
2/14 slot replacements; 14%

1/10 town replacement; 10%
1/3 mafia replacement; 33%
2/14 slot replacement; 14%

1/3 mafia replacement; 33%
1/13 slot replacements; 8%

1/9 town replacement; 11%
1/3 mafia replacement; 33%
2/13 slot replacements; 15%

2 town replacement
1 mafia replacement
3/13 slot replacements

1 town replacement
1 slot replacement

MAJOR SPIKE IN NFM 19
4 town replacements
3 mafia replacements
7/20 slot replacements

3 town replacements
3/20 replacements

2 town replacements
1 mafia replacements
1 neutral replacements
4/16 slot replacements

4 town replacements
4/16 slot replacements

2 town replacements
1 mafia replacements
3/16 replacements

NFM24 IS THE BEGINNING OF WHEN REPLACEMENTS START GROWING TO AN ALL TIME HIGH
7 slot (9 player) town replacements
2 slot (4 player) mafia replacements
9/16 slot replacements (13/16 player replacements)

NFM25 CANNED DUE TO LACK OF INACTIVITY
4 town replacements
3 mafia replacements
7/16 slot replacements

NFM25 PT. 2 - note: inactivity problem
3 slot (4 player) town replacements
3/16 slot replacements (4/16 player replacements)

NFM26
4 town replacement
2 mafia replacement
1 neutral replacement
7/16 slot replacements

2 town replacements
3 slot (4 player) mafia replacement
1 slot (2 player) neutral replacement
6/17 slot replacements (8/17 player replacements)

3 town replacement
2 mafia replacement
5/17 slot replacements

SPIKE NFM29
7 slot (11 player) town replacement
1 neutral replacement
1 slot (2 player) mafia replacement
9/16 slot replacements (13/16 player replacements)

2 slot (3 player) town replacement
1 mafia replacement
3/17 slot replacements (4/17 player replacements)

7 slot (8 player) town replacements
1 mafia replacement
1 neutral replacement
9/18 slot replacements (10/18 player replacements)

BEGINNING OF LESS REPLACEMENT ERA

NFM 32
4 town (5 player) town replacement
4/17 slot replacements (5/17 player replacements)

2 town replacements
1 slot (2 player) neutral replacement
3/14 slot replacements (4 player replacements)

0/14 slot replacements NFM 34

1 slot (2 player) town replacement
2 slot (3 player) mafia replacement
3/14 slot replacements (5/13 player replacements)

END OF 2016

2 town replacements
2/14 slot replacements

SPIKE 37
4 slot (5 player) town replacement
1 slot (2 player) mafia replacement
1 neutral replacement
6/14 slot replacements (8/14 player replacements)

2 town replacements
2/14 slot replacements

MAJOR SPIKE NFM39
9 slot (12 player) town replacements
9/18 slot replacements (12/16 player replacements)

1 town replacement
1/18 slot replacements

0/18 slot replacements

REPLACEMENT HELL ERA BEGINS

4 mafia replacement
2 mafia replacement
6/18 slot replacements

NFM43
8 slot (12 player) town replacement
2 mafia replacement
2 slot (3 playerr) neutral replacement
12/17 slot replacements(17/17 replacements)

NFM44
15) leyva45 UNDERSTOOD12345 Vanquisher101 NotAnInspiration lucky333123 - Consort - Lynched Day 5
6 slot (10 player) town replacement
3 slot (7 player) mafia replacement
9/17 slot replacements (17/17 player replacements)

4 slot (5 player) town replaced
4/17 slots replaced (5/17 players replaced)

5 slot (8 player) town replaced
2 mafia replaced
7/17 slots replaced (10/17 players replaced)

NFM 47
8 slot (11 player) town replacements
1 neutral replacement
9/17 slot replacements (12/17 player replacements)

ERA OF ACTIVITY BEGINS

1 mafia replaced
1/10 slots replaced

3 town replaced
3/9 slots replaced

1 town replaced
1 mafia replaced
2/13 slots replaced

replacement statistics so far without the percentages.
player retention rate soon to come.
mafia, town, and neutral winrate soon to come.

i'm going out to eat and i've been doing this for about 2 and a half hours, so i'm just gonna leave it here for now.

[mdb1023]

Oh god I just got NFM44 nam flashbacks.

[chitownmvp01]

Keep in mind that not all replacements are due to inactivity or request. Some are due to rules violations.

Oh god I just got NFM44 nam flashbacks.

lol

[Shilster]

Oh god I just got NFM44 nam flashbacks.

ahahahah

[melanora]

What's interesting about this is that replacements were highest when more experienced members were involved...

[chitownmvp01]

What's interesting about this is that replacements were highest when more experienced members were involved...

Agreed. Maybe having too many experienced players is too intimidating.

[melanora]

What's interesting about this is that replacements were highest when more experienced members were involved...

Agreed. Maybe having too many experienced players is too intimidating.

More like many of the newer members came to me and explained they were not coming back because the experienced players were assholes...

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

No graph smh

[K1llthestory]

soon.tm

[chitownmvp01]

What's interesting about this is that replacements were highest when more experienced members were involved...

Agreed. Maybe having too many experienced players is too intimidating.

More like many of the newer members came to me and explained they were not coming back because the experienced players were assholes...

I didn’t know that happened. Wow. If you ever allow experienced players into NFM again (beyond the current rule), only allow ones who you know would be nice to newbies. Don’t allow experienced players who have a history of getting warned or blacklisted to play NFM.

[K1llthestory]

what are you implying

[chitownmvp01]

what are you implying

Don’t allow experienced players who are assholes to play NFM.

[TrueGent]

JUSTR MAKE IT READBLE
DICKWEED

[melanora]

JUSTR MAKE IT READBLE
DICKWEED

This.

[melanora]

What's interesting about this is that replacements were highest when more experienced members were involved...

Agreed. Maybe having too many experienced players is too intimidating.

More like many of the newer members came to me and explained they were not coming back because the experienced players were assholes...

I didn’t know that happened. Wow. If you ever allow experienced players into NFM again (beyond the current rule), only allow ones who you know would be nice to newbies. Don’t allow experienced players who have a history of getting warned or blacklisted to play NFM.

Yeah, it was bad. So then I stopped letting problem people join, and they threw fits. Absolute train wreck.

[K1llthestory]

JUSTR MAKE IT READBLE
DICKWEED

This.

how about i actually get statistics done before i worry about your stupid bullshit LOL

fucking idiots

[Alzar]

be nice and gentle that's a drunk truegent

[ICECLIMBERS]

The problem players are probably James and Mroz. They’re not around anymore, but it does show that those who would be better for the job don’t want to do it. Also: those games (late 2016 early 2017) were larger and longer. It makes sense that people would go inactive over a longer period of time. NFMs shouldn’t last a month. I have more that I could say but I’d like to do so in the other thread.

[EvanManManMan]

That is how you play scum gg wow