VFM 49: SK win #rekt

[TheDebil]

also ejji even tho rick might be a friend to you you shouldnt ever shy away from reading him or pushing him. especially him since is a dangerous player
hes not gonna think you are a bad person or anything its just a game and if he does that's a dick move

[GrumpyGoomba]

For me it's chemist and debil.

[Chemist1422]

@chemist and seth, have you played with debil before? Could you give some insight on their meta?

neither their town or scum meta is like this but I’d call them town because other things

1. GG
2. Seth

[Seththeking]

This is what I was going to say before the thread was locked for Rick’s Flip:
@Chemist

See right now you don’t want to take any risks.
Your hoping Ejji doesn’t get to ISO you in time.
Your hoping Ejji doesn’t call you out on shooting you because then you’d Be locked SK
Your hoping if you do get what you want here you can manipulate town into miss Lynching and giving you the win.
Well chemist as long as I’m alive, I’ll make sure you don’t get your SK win.

^

Also not to mention I believe Chemist softed SK.
So In order for Chemist to not manipulate his way to victory I’ll do what Ejji requested me to do and explain why chemist’s arguments are bad.

So let’s go over a few things Chemist has said.
Also keep in mind I’m currently writing this on notepads before Rick has flipped yet.

Anyway, for the first 1 this was his response to the difference between NE and NK.

“Probably, because they have different wincons

The only time I ever played as NK was a meme game though so you probably won't be able to meta me on it”

NE can win with all Scum and NK must kill Town and Mafia.
I mean I’ll give you that 1 is harder then the other but the playstyle is still relatively similar.

Your also playing like your NE game but worse, which makes me believe that this is your NK playstyle.

What Meme game are you even referring to?

Now for the second one.
This is your response for when I caught you softing SK.

“I think you misunderstood my post

If Ejji says they’re shooting someone and that person is the SK, they’ll just flip so they don’t get shot”

Ok so I’m a little lost on this one so I’ll try and brake it down.
Ejji says they Shoot’s Player B the SK
SK will flip SK so they don’t get shot?????!!!??? :/


Here’s some of his comments I’ll also answer.

“1. It's not an SK soft at all, I refuted it and you called me flailing
2. Not puppeting, Dash and I agreed on a lot of reads.
3. If I was SK why would I need to vote Crimson? I wasn't a lynch target and he was almost definitely dying anyway.”

My response to “1.”
Refuted: prove (a statement or theory) to be wrong or false; disprove.
SK Flips SK! . Totally proved me wrong there fam!

My response to “2”
While most of them might be true I want you to see your Reactions with Crimson and Dash.
Not to mention always that much agreeing with Dash could also be signs of being SK. Also I think Sheeping is what I was looking for not Puppeting.

“Oh did you not hear

They got rid of spoilers for non-trusted

Also I don’t know why you’re under the assumption that I sheeping you and not that I had the idea separately but just posted it later”

“/vote Crimson

This has not been here and now it deserves to be

And if nothing else you can look at the spike in activity since he got wagoned”



My response to “3”

You voted Crimson in case they Flipped Mafia so you could appear more Town, However once you realized Crimson was Town is where my suspicion went away from Dash and onto you.


The I Claimed I can easily find more reads later today and instead of casually saying I’ll be waiting he responds with this
“There's three problems with that post

1. You're pandering again
2. You said something that you called me scum for saying
3. You're being rude”

Response for “1”
I’m not entirely sure what Pandering is but I assume it means Ramble on which is false because I wasn’t just deathtunneling you for the same thing but multiple things.

Response for “2”
What was that exactly?

Response for “3”
Oh yeah and that’s problematic how exactly?


Also not to mention these Posts are obviously contradicting recent statements.

“I think Zucker and tfios are both likely town though I'm less solid on Zucker after yesterday's EoD combined with the Crimson flip, tfios I already explained”

“Besides, didn't you think I was scum already? It feels like you're trying to justify it with the slip now.”
(Says that to Dash’s Slip Caught but not mine)

“I was aware of the slip when I typed the post

Not when I posted it”

“I Said: Says the guy that voted Crimson at the wrong time.
Chemist Replied with:
towqipghwqpoieghwqoeginw”


Also right here you didn’t want to be associated with Crimson if she Flipped Mafia.
“You're both trying to paint me as scum with the other

Drop your read on me or your read on Zucker. Same with you, Zucker. Drop your read on me or your read on Crimson.”

“Dash2 wrote:
I motion for a tfios lynch if they refuse to start posting meaningful content

Chemist replied with:
I'm not not okay with this

They play at their own pace but if they don't actually play they can get lynched”

“Crimson is slightly towny by tone but I want to see more from them”


Also this post by Chemist explains why SK killed Phone.

“Phone is genuinely solving and not self-aware at all, which is both townie and an improvement over his recent games”

Not to mention that Tfios called out Rick and we Lynched Rick.
Chemist didn’t call out rick because he was too worried about the chance of himself getting lynched.

However looking at ISO I can say Chemist as been doing the following:
FoS
Leaning on Town’s approval to attempt to stay safe
Accusing anyone he has a chance in Lynching without Lynching himself
Slipping
Not voting Tfios at end of vote count despite them being sure it’s Tfios.
Prob More.

Furthermore this should be clear that Chemist is the Serial Killer.

[Seththeking]

/Vote Chemist

Not sure why Vigilante Shot Tfios Over GG and Chemist.
After Rick was lynched it should have been clear Tfios was Town.

[Seththeking]

@chemist and seth, have you played with debil before? Could you give some insight on their meta?

neither their town or scum meta is like this but I’d call them town because other things

1. GG
2. Seth

I’m surprised you Actually put me on there.

[Seththeking]

@chemist and seth, have you played with debil before? Could you give some insight on their meta?

neither their town or scum meta is like this but I’d call them town because other things

1. GG
2. Seth

Is it because of their catchup wall? If that's TAI then from now on I'm always replacing in late and writing huge posts for freelo.

Look at my Chemist response.
It legit has to be Chemist at this point.

[Chemist1422]

@chemist and seth, have you played with debil before? Could you give some insight on their meta?

neither their town or scum meta is like this but I’d call them town because other things

1. GG
2. Seth

Is it because of their catchup wall? If that's TAI then from now on I'm always replacing in late and writing huge posts for freelo.

It’s town indicative because the solving feels very real

[Chemist1422]

@chemist and seth, have you played with debil before? Could you give some insight on their meta?

neither their town or scum meta is like this but I’d call them town because other things

1. GG
2. Seth

Is it because of their catchup wall? If that's TAI then from now on I'm always replacing in late and writing huge posts for freelo.

Look at my Chemist response.
It legit has to be Chemist at this point.

I’ll respond once I get on a computer

[Seththeking]

Seth in our previous game where you were town you did not put so much effort in to make a post like that. I'm legit paranoid of you right now.

I put in so much effort because unlike last VFM I don’t want to lose.
I truly believe this is SK Chemist play and I want the dead Town and alive Town to warship me after we lynch the SK.
Another reason I put so much in is because you guys don’t want to push Chemist like I’ve been telling you to do.
I also couldn’t get what I was going to say in.

I also just noticed If Vigilante didn’t shoot last night which they shouldn’t have because they didn’t call it out, we wouldn’t be at a MyLo situation RN.

[TheDebil]

Debil you were on the fence about chemist yesterday, and you thought me/goomba were likely SK candidates. Why do you think it could be chemist over me?

I'm kinda paranoid you're trying to use the fact that seth will always vote chemist.

good question. im not fully convinced you are town, but you are really towny and gamesolve alot, and compared to chemist/grumpy you are less likely to flip scum imo.
if you see my posts i have you as a townread and just mention that you could flip scum, because it seems like everyone just kinda locktowned you when that should not happen. same with the other message seth quoted, since he got so into his tunnleing it seemed like he forgot grumpy and you even existed

[Seththeking]

Before anyone replies next read my big post.

[Chemist1422]

Seth in our previous game where you were town you did not put so much effort in to make a post like that. I'm legit paranoid of you right now.

I put in so much effort because unlike last VFM I don’t want to lose.
I truly believe this is SK Chemist play and I want the dead Town and alive Town to warship me after we lynch the SK.
Another reason I put so much in is because you guys don’t want to push Chemist like I’ve been telling you to do.
I also couldn’t get what I was going to say in.

I also just noticed If Vigilante didn’t shoot last night which they shouldn’t have because they didn’t call it out, we wouldn’t be at a MyLo situation RN.

Can I take this as an admission of throwing

We’re also not in MyLo

[Seththeking]

Seth in our previous game where you were town you did not put so much effort in to make a post like that. I'm legit paranoid of you right now.

I put in so much effort because unlike last VFM I don’t want to lose.
I truly believe this is SK Chemist play and I want the dead Town and alive Town to warship me after we lynch the SK.
Another reason I put so much in is because you guys don’t want to push Chemist like I’ve been telling you to do.
I also couldn’t get what I was going to say in.

I also just noticed If Vigilante didn’t shoot last night which they shouldn’t have because they didn’t call it out, we wouldn’t be at a MyLo situation RN.

Can I take this as an admission of throwing

We’re also not in MyLo

Oh wait a sec.
5 - 1 = 4 - 1 = 3.

Ok then I’m so stupid. I apologize.

Well if it’s not Chemist it’s GG.
No matter what it’s Fine.
We lynch Chemist first because I haven’t trusted him all game and made a giant post about it.
Then if some how some way he’s Town we lynch GG for the win!

[Seththeking]

It should be very clear Me, Qva and Debil are Town at this point.
My suggestion is we lynch between Chemist (-) GrumpyGoomba always.
We will always win by this.

[Seththeking]

I want to lynch Chemist now though before he kills me tonight and try’s to manipulate one of you to vote each other giving him the win.

[Seththeking]

People were coming up with ideas that I am the sk at that point xD

I'm sad... do I really look like a psychotic murderer that much? *hides the bloody knife behind me*

This joke was really off place at a point when the game was pretty serious. I can totally see myself making a joke like this as an SK being suspected and having low odds of winning. Also I feel scum joke about being scum much more often than town do, though that's not so telling.

I wonder if I truly would've put this much focus on me being the sk if I actually were sk...

Anyways nope you are wrong. Swap me for ejj and that's a go on the scums.

Yes you would. That's how psychology works, people tend to focus on themselves. Also it fits in with the theory that you chose cop/vig immunity. See these posts where you're trying to exploit this:

Okay I have finally caught up with the thread. Did a cop check on me succeed? If not then don't claim. See people think that I am the sk. If I was the sk then :-
1. I would be immune to mafia kills, that would make it so that cop can find me. Why would I want that to happen to me actively?
2. I would be immune to vig/cop. That would make it so that I am literally announcing to the mafia that I am not immune to them by wanting a cop check on me, making it so that maf can eliminate me anytime they want.

How could what I am doing be even remotely beneficial to me if i were the SK?

As for me being mafia, I don't really know people would come to that conclusion. Who would I even be in a scum team with?

I hope that through some magical luck the cop check is on me and it succeeds and I am hopefully cleared.

And your stance on vig revealing:

Strongly disagree on vig revealing. They get 2 more bloody free shots by not revealing. Also nice one vig.

You wouldn't want them to reveal since they're confirmed town and you're immune to their shot, so revealing only makes it harder for you.

It’s GG or Chemist.
Chemist is Worse but GG is still a possibility.
If we do lynch GG and I die, you lynch Chemist.
However don’t you think it’s best to lynch Chemist now?
Because no matter what GG would be the culprit.
While Chemist can manipulate, GG can’t.

[Chemist1422]

Spoiler:

This is what I was going to say before the thread was locked for Rick’s Flip:
@Chemist

See right now you don’t want to take any risks.
Your hoping Ejji doesn’t get to ISO you in time.
Your hoping Ejji doesn’t call you out on shooting you because then you’d Be locked SK
Your hoping if you do get what you want here you can manipulate town into miss Lynching and giving you the win.
Well chemist as long as I’m alive, I’ll make sure you don’t get your SK win.
admitting to tunneling, shading me off stuff that's unprovable, ignoring my posts
^

Also not to mention I believe Chemist softed SK.
ignoring my counterarguments
So In order for Chemist to not manipulate his way to victory I’ll do what Ejji requested me to do and explain why chemist’s arguments are bad.
zzz
So let’s go over a few things Chemist has said.
Also keep in mind I’m currently writing this on notepads before Rick has flipped yet.
cool
Anyway, for the first 1 this was his response to the difference between NE and NK.

Probably, because they have different wincons

The only time I ever played as NK was a meme game though so you probably won't be able to meta me on it

NE can win with all Scum and NK must kill Town and Mafia.
I mean I’ll give you that 1 is harder then the other but the playstyle is still relatively similar.
no it's not, there's a fundamental difference

NE needs to know who to kill, NK doesn't
Your also playing like your NE game but worse, which makes me believe that this is your NK playstyle.
I take it I won't be getting an explanation on this
What Meme game are you even referring to?
Cow's April Fools mash on MU
Now for the second one.
This is your response for when I caught you softing SK.
not even close

I think you misunderstood my post

If Ejji says they’re shooting someone and that person is the SK, they’ll just flip so they don’t get shot

Ok so I’m a little lost on this one so I’ll try and brake it down.
Ejji says they Shoot’s Player B the SK
SK will flip SK so they don’t get shot?????!!!??? :/
Flip as in switch ejji off so they can't shoot

Here’s some of his comments I’ll also answer.

1. It's not an SK soft at all, I refuted it and you called me flailing
2. Not puppeting, Dash and I agreed on a lot of reads.
3. If I was SK why would I need to vote Crimson? I wasn't a lynch target and he was almost definitely dying anyway.

My response to “1.”
Refuted: prove (a statement or theory) to be wrong or false; disprove.
SK Flips SK! . Totally proved me wrong there fam!
See above
My response to “2”
While most of them might be true I want you to see your Reactions with Crimson and Dash.
Not to mention always that much agreeing with Dash could also be signs of being SK. Also I think Sheeping is what I was looking for not Puppeting.
will respond to the individual reactions separately, but how is agreeing with someone SK indicative at all?

Oh did you not hear

They got rid of spoilers for non-trusted

Also I don’t know why you’re under the assumption that I sheeping you and not that I had the idea separately but just posted it later

Yes, don't see the problem here

/vote Crimson

This has not been here and now it deserves to be

And if nothing else you can look at the spike in activity since he got wagoned

Still don't see the problem here


My response to “3”

You voted Crimson in case they Flipped Mafia so you could appear more Town, However once you realized Crimson was Town is where my suspicion went away from Dash and onto you.
I voted Crimson because I thought they were going to flip scum.

The I Claimed I can easily find more reads later today and instead of casually saying I’ll be waiting he responds with this
That wasn't the post I was responding to, This one was

There's three problems with that post

1. You're pandering again
2. You said something that you called me scum for saying
3. You're being rude

Response for “1”
I’m not entirely sure what Pandering is but I assume it means Ramble on which is false because I wasn’t just deathtunneling you for the same thing but multiple things.
No, that's wrong. Pandering is trying to agree with someone else to make them think you're on their side. Similar to pocketing.
Response for “2”
What was that exactly?
If we mislynch ejji doesn't shoot
Response for “3”
Oh yeah and that’s problematic how exactly?
It's not alignment related, it's just you being a jerk

Also not to mention these Posts are obviously contradicting recent statements.

I think Zucker and tfios are both likely town though I'm less solid on Zucker after yesterday's EoD combined with the Crimson flip, tfios I already explained

Reads change, unless you're tunneling

Besides, didn't you think I was scum already? It feels like you're trying to justify it with the slip now.

(Says that to Dash’s Slip Caught but not mine)
That implies it was a slip in any sense

I was aware of the slip when I typed the post

Not when I posted it

We went over this D2

I Said: Says the guy that voted Crimson at the wrong time.
Chemist Replied with:
towqipghwqpoieghwqoeginw

???

Also right here you didn’t want to be associated with Crimson if she Flipped Mafia.

You're both trying to paint me as scum with the other

Drop your read on me or your read on Zucker. Same with you, Zucker. Drop your read on me or your read on Crimson.

Yeah because the way Crimson acted EoD meant we were never w/w, if you would care to read into it at all

I motion for a tfios lynch if they refuse to start posting meaningful content

I'm not not okay with this

They play at their own pace but if they don't actually play they can get lynched

Metaread, tfios has trouble making solid reads as scum

Crimson is slightly towny by tone but I want to see more from them

Reads change
Also this post by Chemist explains why SK killed Phone.

Phone is genuinely solving and not self-aware at all, which is both townie and an improvement over his recent games

So that doesn't apply to anyone else who had a similar read?
Not to mention that Tfios called out Rick and we Lynched Rick.
Chemist didn’t call out rick because he was too worried about the chance of himself getting lynched.
I was nullscumreading Rick the entire game, but sure
However looking at ISO I can say Chemist as been doing the following:
FoS
the heck does that even mean in this situation
Leaning on Town’s approval to attempt to stay safe
That's probably a better definition of pandering than the one I posted above, so that's actually what you've been doing
Accusing anyone he has a chance in Lynching without Lynching himself
Now you're contradicting yourself. You just said I didn't call out Rick
Slipping
zzz
Not voting Tfios at end of vote count despite them being sure it’s Tfios.
Vote wouldn't have changed anything, I said it was between Rick/tfios/Goomba for me, so I was okay with any of those three getting lynched.
Prob More.
Oh, so you're not done!

Furthermore this should be clear that Chemist is the Serial Killer.

[Chemist1422]

Spoiler:

This is what I was going to say before the thread was locked for Rick’s Flip:
@Chemist

See right now you don’t want to take any risks.
Your hoping Ejji doesn’t get to ISO you in time.
Your hoping Ejji doesn’t call you out on shooting you because then you’d Be locked SK
Your hoping if you do get what you want here you can manipulate town into miss Lynching and giving you the win.
Well chemist as long as I’m alive, I’ll make sure you don’t get your SK win.
admitting to tunneling, shading me off stuff that's unprovable, ignoring my posts
^

Also not to mention I believe Chemist softed SK.
ignoring my counterarguments
So In order for Chemist to not manipulate his way to victory I’ll do what Ejji requested me to do and explain why chemist’s arguments are bad.
zzz
So let’s go over a few things Chemist has said.
Also keep in mind I’m currently writing this on notepads before Rick has flipped yet.
cool
Anyway, for the first 1 this was his response to the difference between NE and NK.

Probably, because they have different wincons

The only time I ever played as NK was a meme game though so you probably won't be able to meta me on it

NE can win with all Scum and NK must kill Town and Mafia.
I mean I’ll give you that 1 is harder then the other but the playstyle is still relatively similar.
no it's not, there's a fundamental difference

NE needs to know who to kill, NK doesn't
Your also playing like your NE game but worse, which makes me believe that this is your NK playstyle.
I take it I won't be getting an explanation on this
What Meme game are you even referring to?
Cow's April Fools mash on MU
Now for the second one.
This is your response for when I caught you softing SK.
not even close

I think you misunderstood my post

If Ejji says they’re shooting someone and that person is the SK, they’ll just flip so they don’t get shot

Ok so I’m a little lost on this one so I’ll try and brake it down.
Ejji says they Shoot’s Player B the SK
SK will flip SK so they don’t get shot?????!!!??? :/
Flip as in switch ejji off so they can't shoot

Here’s some of his comments I’ll also answer.

1. It's not an SK soft at all, I refuted it and you called me flailing
2. Not puppeting, Dash and I agreed on a lot of reads.
3. If I was SK why would I need to vote Crimson? I wasn't a lynch target and he was almost definitely dying anyway.

My response to “1.”
Refuted: prove (a statement or theory) to be wrong or false; disprove.
SK Flips SK! . Totally proved me wrong there fam!
See above
My response to “2”
While most of them might be true I want you to see your Reactions with Crimson and Dash.
Not to mention always that much agreeing with Dash could also be signs of being SK. Also I think Sheeping is what I was looking for not Puppeting.
will respond to the individual reactions separately, but how is agreeing with someone SK indicative at all?

Oh did you not hear

They got rid of spoilers for non-trusted

Also I don’t know why you’re under the assumption that I sheeping you and not that I had the idea separately but just posted it later

Yes, don't see the problem here

/vote Crimson

This has not been here and now it deserves to be

And if nothing else you can look at the spike in activity since he got wagoned

Still don't see the problem here


My response to “3”

You voted Crimson in case they Flipped Mafia so you could appear more Town, However once you realized Crimson was Town is where my suspicion went away from Dash and onto you.
I voted Crimson because I thought they were going to flip scum.

The I Claimed I can easily find more reads later today and instead of casually saying I’ll be waiting he responds with this
That wasn't the post I was responding to, This one was

There's three problems with that post

1. You're pandering again
2. You said something that you called me scum for saying
3. You're being rude

Response for “1”
I’m not entirely sure what Pandering is but I assume it means Ramble on which is false because I wasn’t just deathtunneling you for the same thing but multiple things.
No, that's wrong. Pandering is trying to agree with someone else to make them think you're on their side. Similar to pocketing.
Response for “2”
What was that exactly?
If we mislynch ejji doesn't shoot
Response for “3”
Oh yeah and that’s problematic how exactly?
It's not alignment related, it's just you being a jerk

Also not to mention these Posts are obviously contradicting recent statements.

I think Zucker and tfios are both likely town though I'm less solid on Zucker after yesterday's EoD combined with the Crimson flip, tfios I already explained

Reads change, unless you're tunneling

Besides, didn't you think I was scum already? It feels like you're trying to justify it with the slip now.

(Says that to Dash’s Slip Caught but not mine)
That implies it was a slip in any sense

I was aware of the slip when I typed the post

Not when I posted it

We went over this D2

I Said: Says the guy that voted Crimson at the wrong time.
Chemist Replied with:
towqipghwqpoieghwqoeginw

???

Also right here you didn’t want to be associated with Crimson if she Flipped Mafia.

You're both trying to paint me as scum with the other

Drop your read on me or your read on Zucker. Same with you, Zucker. Drop your read on me or your read on Crimson.

Yeah because the way Crimson acted EoD meant we were never w/w, if you would care to read into it at all

I motion for a tfios lynch if they refuse to start posting meaningful content

I'm not not okay with this

They play at their own pace but if they don't actually play they can get lynched

Metaread, tfios has trouble making solid reads as scum

Crimson is slightly towny by tone but I want to see more from them

Reads change
Also this post by Chemist explains why SK killed Phone.

Phone is genuinely solving and not self-aware at all, which is both townie and an improvement over his recent games

So that doesn't apply to anyone else who had a similar read?
Not to mention that Tfios called out Rick and we Lynched Rick.
Chemist didn’t call out rick because he was too worried about the chance of himself getting lynched.
I was nullscumreading Rick the entire game, but sure
However looking at ISO I can say Chemist as been doing the following:
FoS
the heck does that even mean in this situation
Leaning on Town’s approval to attempt to stay safe
That's probably a better definition of pandering than the one I posted above, so that's actually what you've been doing
Accusing anyone he has a chance in Lynching without Lynching himself
Now you're contradicting yourself. You just said I didn't call out Rick
Slipping
zzz
Not voting Tfios at end of vote count despite them being sure it’s Tfios.
Vote wouldn't have changed anything, I said it was between Rick/tfios/Goomba for me, so I was okay with any of those three getting lynched.
Prob More.
Oh, so you're not done!

Furthermore this should be clear that Chemist is the Serial Killer.

Your honor, the defense rests.

[Chemist1422]

Spoiler:

People were coming up with ideas that I am the sk at that point xD

I'm sad... do I really look like a psychotic murderer that much? *hides the bloody knife behind me*

This joke was really off place at a point when the game was pretty serious. I can totally see myself making a joke like this as an SK being suspected and having low odds of winning. Also I feel scum joke about being scum much more often than town do, though that's not so telling.
I agree on the first quote, but the second isn't AI for goomba.

I wonder if I truly would've put this much focus on me being the sk if I actually were sk...

Anyways nope you are wrong. Swap me for ejj and that's a go on the scums.

Agree on this being bad because self-meta
Yes you would. That's how psychology works, people tend to focus on themselves. Also it fits in with the theory that you chose cop/vig immunity. See these posts where you're trying to exploit this:

Okay I have finally caught up with the thread. Did a cop check on me succeed? If not then don't claim. See people think that I am the sk. If I was the sk then :-
1. I would be immune to mafia kills, that would make it so that cop can find me. Why would I want that to happen to me actively?
2. I would be immune to vig/cop. That would make it so that I am literally announcing to the mafia that I am not immune to them by wanting a cop check on me, making it so that maf can eliminate me anytime they want.

How could what I am doing be even remotely beneficial to me if i were the SK?

As for me being mafia, I don't really know people would come to that conclusion. Who would I even be in a scum team with?

I hope that through some magical luck the cop check is on me and it succeeds and I am hopefully cleared.

More self-meta, baiting cop which would make sense if cop immune

And your stance on vig revealing:

Strongly disagree on vig revealing. They get 2 more bloody free shots by not revealing. Also nice one vig.

You wouldn't want them to reveal since they're confirmed town and you're immune to their shot, so revealing only makes it harder for you.

This seems a bit reachy though.

This+D1 AtE being wolfy is why I think GG is the SK

Not voting yet, because we still have time to discuss

[TheDebil]

Debil you were on the fence about chemist yesterday, and you thought me/goomba were likely SK candidates. Why do you think it could be chemist over me?

I'm kinda paranoid you're trying to use the fact that seth will always vote chemist.

good question. im not fully convinced you are town, but you are really towny and gamesolve alot, and compared to chemist/grumpy you are less likely to flip scum imo.
if you see my posts i have you as a townread and just mention that you could flip scum, because it seems like everyone just kinda locktowned you when that should not happen. same with the other message seth quoted, since he got so into his tunnleing it seemed like he forgot grumpy and you even existed

Reading your iso I don't see much about chemist. Do you think he's possibly SK just because me and seth are less likely from your pov? Do you think he's worse than goomba? I'd like you to go into a bit more depth when you have time.

goomba is scummy on his own, chemist gets 2nd place for me due to POE. he's more of a town-lean/null for me
with my thought progress i think the SK would be a bit reluctant to gamesolve much yesterday, due to the fact that a mislynch there would have increased SK's win chances drastically. a mislynch and a misshoot would most lilely result in a 2v1v1 situation, and sk would probably be sided with there.
chemist's D1 was rather weak, and his D2 was not great either, but the fake-slip play felt a bit too risky for an SK play,but not for mafia so if rick flipped SK back then i would probably have pushed on chemist to be mafia. D3 he did an alright ammount of gamesolving, but he seemed to want a change of the wagon from rick, which seemed slightly suspicious to me. it seems like he was expecting rick to flip town and wanted some towncred.
grumpy didnt do much at all D3, and overall hasnt been the most active or contributive throughout the game. AtE is not helpful either. i also liked your case on him, so that bumps him further for me.

[Chemist1422]

How does going against a mislynch yesterday give anyone any towncred when both of the scum are solo

[Chemist1422]

Do I have to read seth vs chemist

If you think we're both town you're not obligated to

Anyone who has me or seth in their lynch order is

[TheDebil]

How does going against a mislynch yesterday give anyone any towncred when both of the scum are solo

actually yeah that makes no sense

only way you would have had scum intentions there if you knew rick was mafia wand wanted to save him

[TheDebil]

How does going against a mislynch yesterday give anyone any towncred when both of the scum are solo

Technically if tfios were lynched, ejji shot rick and rick killed a townie, we'd be in 3/0/1 MyLo where SK has chances.

yeah but its not towncred
i was depring there