Qvapil wrote:Ejji I why don't you think goomba is the SK? I agree that they're probably not mafia due to their D1 vote but during D2 they were following the thread but not really saying anything. Like, they were there but kinda not there? I can't explain it very well, but I think it's something I'd do as SK. Goomba could you give us some quick reads? Not anything as deep as your D1 post, just some thoughts on who you think could be the last mafia or the SK.
Honestly, they were “there” but “not there” for the entirety of D1 as well, lol. I don’t know how they play normally, but I THINK it might be normal for them.
It’s not like they’re afraid to share their own opinion and they obviously weren’t afraid to interact and heavily criticize 2 “obv” townies (D1-dash, d3-seth), so I think they shouldn’t be SRd for their tone.
I mean, if they aren’t afraid to interact naturally, nothing should stop them from giving reads and SRing people as scum.
The reason I TR them is precisely because of their interactions with dash.
viewtopic.php?f=17&t=99445&p=3173694#p3173694This ^ is prob my whole read on them. It might look undependable, but I trust it a lot.
Qvapil wrote: Somewhere during D2 Flake was discussing the night kills and said he found it weird he were still alive, then you answered him that you thought Dash should have been a higher priority target compared to phone and eragon. Though I agree with you on that point, is it too deep in the realms of science fiction to assume that you were scum signalling to the other evil faction? To like, coordinate a Dash kill? Or am I too tired.
you’re too tired, lol.
Scum can’t signal to each other, because they don’t know each others’ identities
And they obviously wouldn’t want the other party to know.
Besides, if they wanted to signal D2, the best choice should have been to use Cupcake, since he was outed anyway. So no, they 100% didn’t coordinate and no, I didn’t coordinate with anyone either.
Qvapil wrote: One last thing, I don't think proto/debil is mafia. I pointed this post out yesterday:
Qvapil wrote:ProtoZigg wrote:/vote cupcake
I disagree
This vote was just after I voted crimson, and I was the first vote there. I think it's unlikely proto is cupcake's buddy here
The timing of the vote is weird for them to be buddies. Proto directly opposed a starting crimson wagon to vote cupcake, and he was townreading me before that point.
I THINK I agree here… the vote means nothing, but the timing and the strength of it was weird
Rn the ones with the most mafia equity are 1. Tfios and 2. ….probably rick :/
But I genuinely believe it should just be tfios
As for SK, actually, idfk…
Qvapil wrote:
Anyway I think chemist is definetely not SK, they could be maf if tfios is town but I haven't read them carefully yet.
Why is chem not SK?
Besides the thing about them not forgetting about Dash’s slip as scum, I think they have quite a bit of SK equity.