Page 63 of 96

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:10 pm
by ryanyb
Also we need to be skeptical of whoever has the role 'milkmaid' since they can never win as long as the role is in their possession. So if they say like 'hey I was scum and now im milkmaid lets lynch the milkmaid last phase' then that's stupid because it could straight up be a lie to prolong the game a phase longer so they can switch out of milkmaid.

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:11 pm
by ryanyb
wait does milkmaid even trade alignments?

Like is it confirmed that if you milkmaid swap with a scum that you get a red rolecard and not the same abilities but flavored green

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:13 pm
by Nopingout
ryanyb wrote:wait does milkmaid even trade alignments?

Like is it confirmed that if you milkmaid swap with a scum that you get a red rolecard and not the same abilities but flavored green

if thats a thing then my role is F

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:14 pm
by ryanyb
Because if we dont actually have confirmation that alignment transfers then the entire milkmaid cohort isn't proven.

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:21 pm
by ryanyb
Angleshoot by definition but really it's just logic given rolecards that have been presented in this thread and the OP, which means it's allowed since im using no out of game information:

Argument: It can't transfer alignments, just card text. If it could transfer alignments, then a contradiction exists as follows:

In the OP, evan wrote "All external chats are open 24/7"
We know there is a mafia. Its is very likely that mafia have a mafia chat. Therefore, the mafia chat is open 24/7.

Therefore, if someone get's swapped OUT of the mafia because they get milkmaid and then pick a town role, then they literally out all of the mafia and win the game with town.
That would be broken and wrong.

Therefore milkmaid cannot transfer alignment unless mafia do not have a chat. Which would be stupid and evan would not do that I think.

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:21 pm
by ryanyb
holy shit what if evan just randed the alignments of each rolecard.

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:22 pm
by Nopingout
ryanyb wrote:holy shit what if evan just randed the alignments of each rolecard.

Probably

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:30 pm
by ryanyb
Lol i totally forgot kmenx existed when I did my brushover

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:41 pm
by taylork2
ryanyb wrote:holy shit what if evan just randed the alignments of each rolecard.

Actually given what roles I know of this is plausible for most roles.

Personally I think the most likely scum atm are RedDragon and Tarpley's slot. Kmenx/Non afterwards and then Juck.
You and FML are whatever due to me stumping you both, so IDC about whether your town or scum.

tbf, non nay be what he claims and attempted to ITA but has been nerfed/disabled from losing the Hog contest.

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:44 pm
by taylork2
ryanyb wrote:Angleshoot by definition but really it's just logic given rolecards that have been presented in this thread and the OP, which means it's allowed since im using no out of game information:

Argument: It can't transfer alignments, just card text. If it could transfer alignments, then a contradiction exists as follows:

In the OP, evan wrote "All external chats are open 24/7"
We know there is a mafia. Its is very likely that mafia have a mafia chat. Therefore, the mafia chat is open 24/7.

Therefore, if someone get's swapped OUT of the mafia because they get milkmaid and then pick a town role, then they literally out all of the mafia and win the game with town.
That would be broken and wrong.

Therefore milkmaid cannot transfer alignment unless mafia do not have a chat. Which would be stupid and evan would not do that I think.

Hmm, if Milkmaid can't transfer alignments then Noping has likely been pacified due to maid role given what his role was.

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:45 pm
by ryanyb
Like I’m not crazy right this shit would be broken

And if the game went to like 5 days the odds of milkmaid not having been passed to scum once is not all that high

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:47 pm
by taylork2
ryanyb wrote:Like I’m not crazy right this shit would be broken

And if the game went to like 5 days the odds of milkmaid not having been passed to scum once is not all that high

Yes, but alot is broken so I can't say he wouldn't do it.

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:48 pm
by ryanyb
I don’t think the games integrity has been broken.

That would break game integrity.

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:48 pm
by ryanyb
It would instantly end the game

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:49 pm
by Nopingout
bastard makes integrity questionable but idfk

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:53 pm
by ryanyb
No, bastard doesn’t break integrity.

Bastard means the game state can rapidly change due to mechanics which you cannot play around. It doesn’t mean someone learns the entire mafia team and then gets converted to town and says them all. Like, I wanted to have a town conversion role in blaming so I literally had to modkill the player when they went from scum to town as a hidden mechanic in their rolecard, and I had a sub lined up already to take the slot. You have to go to lengths like that to make mafia->town conversion work.

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:53 pm
by ryanyb
*in blfm

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:55 pm
by taylork2
ryanyb wrote:I don’t think the games integrity has been broken.

That would break game integrity.

Wish granter and Sorcerer. >.>
It's just lucky they haven't yet. Simeone could have wished for someone they knew were scum to be converted to town and then integrity is it's that way.
I say this game has very little integrity.

In fac, THIS GAME WAS NOT THOUGHT OUT, it's a miracle it haisn't been bent in half and broken apart yet.

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:59 pm
by ryanyb
But Evan was the one who ultimately decided how to integrate the wish. In the ita example, he capped it at one hour one shot per person. He made it bastard, not integrity breaking. Evan wouldn’t do something presumably that would break the game with the wish caster and I’d wager there was a clause in the rolecard about that.

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Fri Jan 11, 2019 12:01 am
by taylork2
ryanyb wrote:But Evan was the one who ultimately decided how to integrate the wish. In the ita example, he capped it at one hour one shot per person. He made it bastard, not integrity breaking. Evan wouldn’t do something presumably that would break the game with the wish caster and I’d wager there was a clause in the rolecard about that.

No, I know for a fact this game has little integrity in terms of more complex mechanics.

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Fri Jan 11, 2019 2:17 am
by RedDragonHeart
why isn't kmenx dead yet?

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Fri Jan 11, 2019 3:38 am
by JamesD28
RedDragonHeart wrote:why isn't kmenx dead yet?

Why do you think he should be?

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Fri Jan 11, 2019 3:39 am
by JamesD28
RedDragonHeart wrote:i have mind reading powers but kmenx's presence is clouding it so i need to get rid of them

vote: kmenx

Is it something to do with this
it sounds role related rather than a meme but idk

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Fri Jan 11, 2019 6:48 am
by taylork2
/vote RedDragon

I'm going to
I'm going to stump him if we don't lynch him today.
Lynch him.

Re: SFM52: Bastard Mess (Day two)

PostPosted: Fri Jan 11, 2019 7:02 am
by jucktropy
/RedDragon

BTW i thought dead people can't join Events