[Newcomer FM] NFM46 | Game Over (Mafia Win!)

[BS4125]

TheWabbit will be replacing HATSAT.

Oh god

Am I bad omen? I don't think so.

I'll go catch up. I have a few questions though:

- Are we hypoclaiming?
- Do we claim Witched?

1. We didn't D2 so no, and a TI has already claimed
2. No, only hardclaimed PR roles claim Witched because it gives to much power to the Witch finding scum

[xxSet]

We are lynching DumbStorm though.

Set could be Invest/Consig.

Basically he claimed cit day 1 and I investigated him, he showed up as bodyguard/vig/disguiser/SK.

[Shilster]

We are lynching DumbStorm though.

Set could be Invest/Consig.

Basically he claimed cit day 1 and I investigated him, he showed up as bodyguard/vig/disguiser/SK.

If he was actually Cit, was it worth checking him for a night?

[xxSet]

We are lynching DumbStorm though.

Set could be Invest/Consig.

Basically he claimed cit day 1 and I investigated him, he showed up as bodyguard/vig/disguiser/SK.

If he was actually Cit, was it worth checking him for a night?

Why wouldn't it be?

[xxSet]

I mean yes it wouldn't be the best to just get a cit/gf result on him but you can use that logic for any type of investgative result.

[BS4125]

We are lynching DumbStorm though.

Set could be Invest/Consig.

Basically he claimed cit day 1 and I investigated him, he showed up as bodyguard/vig/disguiser/SK.

If he was actually Cit, was it worth checking him for a night?

Why wouldn't it be?

Because it could have been wasteful, but that's why I'm thinking Set is Invest because Mafia would convince him not to

[xxSet]

I mean you can use that logic to say a sheriff report is wasteful if it could end up being "not suspicious"

[Shilster]

Sheriff is a completely different subject

[BS4125]

I mean you can use that logic to say a sheriff report is wasteful if it could end up being "not suspicious"

No it's the fact that it's wasteful to investigate someone who you already have information on

[xxSet]

I mean you can use that logic to say a sheriff report is wasteful if it could end up being "not suspicious"

No it's the fact that it's wasteful to investigate someone who you already have information on

Eh, I guess I see your point. I still think it makes sense to investigate someone who's claimed.

Also shilster:

There's a big chance on them being Consig who found the SK.

Okay, do you think it's more likely than me being invest on Dumb? If so why?

Just the way you presented it.

Why is the way I presented it not town? And how would you expect town to present it?
Because the way I presented it is how I would do it as town or scum.

[xxSet]

I may or may not leave soon but guyz I'm almost done with my read list
which I should have been done with a long time ago

[Shilster]

There's a big chance on them being Consig who found the SK.

Okay, do you think it's more likely than me being invest on Dumb? If so why?

Just the way you presented it.

Why is the way I presented it not town? And how would you expect town to present it?
Because the way I presented it is how I would do it as town or scum.

[/quote]
Just a hunch

[DumbStorm]

Atleast when i'm lynched, as it'd inevitable, please lynch Shilster.

Check his ISO. The second I scumread him, he voted me, qouting my read as the reason.

He's probably Mafia.

[Varanus]

Expect inactivity from me for a while here. Traveling for the Solar Eclipse.

[andilin1]

Expect inactivity from me for a while here. Traveling for the Solar Eclipse.

kewl

THe one in 28 yrs is closer to meh

[TheWabbit]

We are lynching DumbStorm though.

Set could be Invest/Consig.

Basically he claimed cit day 1 and I investigated him, he showed up as bodyguard/vig/disguiser/SK.

Cool. Why did you immediately chose him as a N1 pick? Unless you scumread/null-scum read DumbStorm, there's legit no reason for you to check him.

[melanora]

Current Vote Count

Player	Votes	Voters
	#	Votes Until Majority

[mdb1023]

Atleast when i'm lynched, as it'd inevitable, please lynch Shilster.

Check his ISO. The second I scumread him, he voted me, qouting my read as the reason.

He's probably Mafia.

That's a discussion for another day, TBH. It's possible that he is but I'm not sure of my read on him yet.

[Shilster]

I'm actually not Mafia. You just seemed generally scummy to me, that's why I voted you.

/unvote

it's 4/8 now, right?

[DumbStorm]

I'm actually not Mafia. You just seemed generally scummy to me, that's why I voted you.

/unvote

it's 4/8 now, right?

This just made me even more pinged by this guy.

Why would you unvote on likely scum from your perspective? Because I called you out?

[Shilster]

There's like 3 more days, mate.

[DumbStorm]

There's like 3 more days, mate.

But there's nothing to discuss, and it isn't as if I was close to hammer.

[Shilster]

we're just waiting... and waiting... and waiting

[xxSet]

We are lynching DumbStorm though.

Set could be Invest/Consig.

Basically he claimed cit day 1 and I investigated him, he showed up as bodyguard/vig/disguiser/SK.

Cool. Why did you immediately chose him as a N1 pick? Unless you scumread/null-scum read DumbStorm, there's legit no reason for you to check him.

I had him as null-scum.

[xxSet]

I still think it's better to lynch andillin over a possible TP.

I've got a feeling that he is gamethrowing or 100% scumlock.

Look at it this way:

If we lynch Dumb we get a chance at killing disg/sk, but also a chance to kill our TP.

If we lynch Andillin we get a chance to kill a gamethrower and getting them banned, or lynching a scum.

If Dumb lives, he will kill someone (SK), disguise as someone (disg) or protect someone/vest (BG)

If andillin lives, he will witch someone (witch), kill someone (SK) or help the mafia out (maf) AND on top of that keep on being useless.

I'm keen on both lynches but getting andillin is a win/win.

What? No, if andilin lives and is town killing he can help us. I don't get what you're talking about.