[Newcomer FM] NFM37 | Game Over | RIP that guy

[BS4125]

I disagree with lynching mafia being our main priority. If we let the arsonist live he has to ignite for him to have a better chance at winning which would leave us in a worse position. It is better to get rid of a scum faction fully(that is the arsonist) so that we do not have to worry about 2 scum teams.

If we take down Mafia first then the Arsonist is easy to deal with. Mafia can kill every night, the Arsonist needs time and time is our strong point

Also, since the Arsonist has likely doused the Mafia, they aren't igniting any time soon

I'm confused - why do you think Cheddar is Mafia?

Because a PR role has to be bad and I actually feel like Frop is Sheriff

Moreover, I feel like Cheddar and Jaegy are plotting something together with the fake-roleblock strategy being used to make Jaegy look less suspicious since the day before he was being held as Mafia

Sure this is speculation so I'll need to do a read on this, I'll send what I find if there's anything

[destinycall]

As I've already pointed out, that only makes sense if the roleblock makes Jaegybomb look LESS suspicious.

But it doesn't.

[BS4125]

As I've already pointed out, that only makes sense if the roleblock makes Jaegybomb look LESS suspicious.

But it doesn't.

Because the Mafia failed in killing someone because they accidentally attacked the Arsonist
That's why Jaegy looks suspicious

[Cyantic]

As I've already pointed out, that only makes sense if the roleblock makes Jaegybomb look LESS suspicious.

But it doesn't.

Because the Mafia failed in killing someone because they accidentally attacked the Arsonist
That's why Jaegy looks suspicious

if cheddar is the consort (why are we even spending time on this? does anyone think that cheddar is really consort?), claiming that jaegy was rbed in mafia is silly because he wouldn't be under any attention anyway until he announced he was rbed

[destinycall]

As I've already pointed out, that only makes sense if the roleblock makes Jaegybomb look LESS suspicious.

But it doesn't.

Because the Mafia failed in killing someone because they accidentally attacked the Arsonist
That's why Jaegy looks suspicious

Exactly. If you are Mafia, why fake that you were roleblocked on a night that Mafia failed to make a kill?

It makes you look more suspicious, because the no-kill could be due to the roleblock. Only Mafia know for sure why they didn't kill last night.

[Dragonfire77111]

Dragon - who do you think is scum among our PR claims? If you think frop418 might not be town, why trust his "sheriff" result?

I honestly don't know who is scum between the PRs, which is why I'm voting Jaegy.

I disagree with lynching mafia being our main priority. If we let the arsonist live he has to ignite for him to have a better chance at winning which would leave us in a worse position. It is better to get rid of a scum faction fully(that is the arsonist) so that we do not have to worry about 2 scum teams.

Yes but what are the chances frop is Arsonist? Fairly equal to the chances of you being Arsonist, I think.

As I've already pointed out, that only makes sense if the roleblock makes Jaegybomb look LESS suspicious.

But it doesn't.

Because the Mafia failed in killing someone because they accidentally attacked the Arsonist
That's why Jaegy looks suspicious

if cheddar is the consort (why are we even spending time on this? does anyone think that cheddar is really consort?), claiming that jaegy was rbed in mafia is silly because he wouldn't be under any attention anyway until he announced he was rbed

Hang on a minute. Cheddar only claimed that Jae was roleblocked AFTER frop revealed his result. It is possible that they decided to bus Jaegy to give Cheddar towncred when he was going down anyway.

[Dragonfire77111]

The thing is though, if we assume that Cheddar is mafia, then mafia's highest priority right now is killing the arsonist, since mafia is doused. If Cheddar is mafia, then they must have attacked the Arsonist last night, so they already know who it is. Which means they'd be pushing for its lynch right now...

[EyesofCurze]

Dragon - who do you think is scum among our PR claims? If you think frop418 might not be town, why trust his "sheriff" result?

I honestly don't know who is scum between the PRs, which is why I'm voting Jaegy.

I disagree with lynching mafia being our main priority. If we let the arsonist live he has to ignite for him to have a better chance at winning which would leave us in a worse position. It is better to get rid of a scum faction fully(that is the arsonist) so that we do not have to worry about 2 scum teams.

Yes but what are the chances frop is Arsonist? Fairly equal to the chances of you being Arsonist, I think.

As I've already pointed out, that only makes sense if the roleblock makes Jaegybomb look LESS suspicious.

But it doesn't.

Because the Mafia failed in killing someone because they accidentally attacked the Arsonist
That's why Jaegy looks suspicious

if cheddar is the consort (why are we even spending time on this? does anyone think that cheddar is really consort?), claiming that jaegy was rbed in mafia is silly because he wouldn't be under any attention anyway until he announced he was rbed

Hang on a minute. Cheddar only claimed that Jae was roleblocked AFTER frop revealed his result. It is possible that they decided to bus Jaegy to give Cheddar towncred when he was going down anyway.

If that were the case, that would mean that the Consort didn't use their blocking ability last night, as no one else has come forward with that information, and that seems kinda dumb. The only way I could see this working is if the last mafia member is blackmailer, and they as a pair decided to let the blackmailer try and find the the arson by looking at the easy target (Cheddar). It just seems needlessly complicated.
P-edit: given that the two Lynch Targets are frop and jaggy, which do you think is arson?

[Cyantic]

wait what i think i've missed something entirely here

why don't we want to lynch arso ???

[EyesofCurze]

wait what i think i've missed something entirely here

why don't we want to lynch arso ???

People are getting paranoid about how is who, and so second guessing everything.

[destinycall]

I would like to lynch Arso.

Dragon and BS425 are thinking Cheddar might be Consort, in which case the Arso is not a threat to Town yet.

But I find that argument implausible for a number of reasons.

[TheCheddarCheese]

Hang on a minute. Cheddar only claimed that Jae was roleblocked AFTER frop revealed his result. It is possible that they decided to bus Jaegy to give Cheddar towncred when he was going down anyway.

Hang on, I would of claimed I roleblocks Jaegy anytime I got online. Which I didn't have the opportunity to do early.

Discussing me as consort is insane, a waste of time. I'm just simply now.
I kinda wanna just roleblock Jaegy again tonight, assuming we lynch the arsonist instead.

[TheCheddarCheese]

simply not*

[frop418]

Cheddar, roleblocking Jaegy serves no purpose cuz he will get his partner to do the kill. Lynch Jaegy and roleblock me so I can prove that I am sheriff

[TheCheddarCheese]

Ok damn, I forgot about the partner thing

[Cyantic]

Cheddar, roleblocking Jaegy serves no purpose cuz he will get his partner to do the kill. Lynch Jaegy and roleblock me so I can prove that I am sheriff

?

[Vanquisher101]

I believe he meant that roleblock me so that I can prove I am not arsonist.

[Vanquisher101]

Well I suppose lynching jaegi is a fair bet too... If frop is so readily agreeing to be roleblocked his chances of being the arsonist seem slim. Also if jaegi flips mafia and if no mafia kills tomorrow yet again(assuming cheddar rbd frop) then we would know who the mafia is.
/Vote Jaegi

[Jaegybomb]

/vote jaegy

[destinycall]

You better not be Town, Jaegybomb.

[Jaegybomb]

That was a hammer.

[BS4125]

/vote jaegy

Lmao you voted for yourself

[Ralozey]

Current Vote Count

Player	Votes	Voters
	#	Votes Until Majority

[Ralozey]

When I came back from the locomotive
I saw something hanging under the dining car
Further investigation revealed:
It was a passenger

Jaegybomb has been Lynched!
Jaegybomb was a Blackmailer.

We have finally arrived at
Auntown

The Train will continue in 48 Hours.
Night Two will end on Feb 7th 2017 4 PM UTC

Reminders:
Please submit your night action via PM to melanora and myself.
Make sure to title your PM "NFM37 Night Action".
The Mafia may perfom their night actions in their according thread.
There is no Last Wills, Whispers, or Death Notes.
When night ends, you will receive a message from me with your night results.
As always, you can normally find a game mod in the discord chat.

If you have any questions feel free to send us a PM.

[Ralozey]

As the sun rises
And the flowers bloomed
I smelt fresh air, mixed with locomotive oil.
It was wonderful
You should try it yourself!
Well, someone did
But what they smelt was not oil...

EyesofCurze was killed by a Member of the Mafia!
EyesofCurze was a Citizen!

Next Stop:
Nexgen

The Train will arrive in 120 Hours (Or 5 Days)
This will be on Feb 12th 2017 7 PM UTC


Reminders:
Mafia does have Day Chat.
There is no Last Wills, Whispers, or Death Notes.
Votes have to be bolded. Example: /vote melanora.
You do not have to unvote before voting someone else.
As always, you can normally find a game mod in the discord chat.

If you have any questions please include @Ralozey or @melanora or @Moderator in your question in bold and one of us will get to it asap.

Have fun, and good luck!