Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]

[Invenio]

Day 9 Begins!

Retralmega's dead.
He was an investigator.

Now the real show begins.


The thread is now open for discussion. The day will end when a majority vote is made, be it a NoLynch or on a player. Otherwise, it will end when 5 days pass.
Dawn of the 9th day. 120 hours remain.
Day 9 will end on 7/5, 10:30pm (CST), or when a majority vote is reached.

Plans may be made if you wish. Just be detailed and account for kills and anything else.

[Tiltedcomedian]

I was doused. /s

[Swordsworth]

Slept peacefully.

I just read everybody's ISO all the way through. It's not Hippophant.

It's Tilted, Vucub, or Nelly.

[Swordsworth]

It may also have to do with the fact that Hippo hasn't been online since last night, hidden mode or not, and the Godfather has both submitted a kill as well as nightskipped.

[Swordsworth]

Yes it's angleshooting, no I'm not proud of it, yes its necessary, because literally everyone was on board with her lynch.

[Tiltedcomedian]

Yes it's angleshooting, no I'm not proud of it, yes its necessary, because literally everyone was on board with her lynch.

By that standard I don't think it's Vucub, either.

Therefore it's me or Nelly. Therefore we're far ahead.

[Invenio]

I've been sent actions on skype and discord before, if you're going to meta.

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

Slept peacefully.

@Swords how can you tell if someone has not been online in hidden mode?

[Swordsworth]

Players who last logged in as or are currently online with Hidden Mode are marked with a "-" for Last Seen.

Let's not proceed down this path much longer, I feel awful for just this much meta. But however we proceed, and given what Invenio has told us, I don't think it's possible that Hippophant is the Godfather.

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

Players who last logged in as or are currently online with Hidden Mode are marked with a "-" for Last Seen.

Let's not proceed down this path much longer, I feel awful for just this much meta. But however we proceed, and given what Invenio has told us, I don't think it's possible that Hippophant is the Godfather.

The latter is wrong. It just updates the time but ill trust you on the former.

However, given what Invenio's said,nit is entirely possiblemfor hippo to be GF.

[Swordsworth]

TiltedComedian
Jordarrian
ChubbyMooshroom9
Hippophant
Nellyfox
VucubCaquix
Swordsworth

Optimal scumplay here is to kill me, then one of the non-suspects. With that said, take today to deeply analyze Nelly, Vucub, Hippophant, and TiltedComedian. Revise all the facts. Turn this case on its head. Tell everyone who you think is the Godfather, and why. Cite evidence. [b]We have three lynches and four suspects. There is little to no margin for error.

[Swordsworth]

TiltedComedian
Jordarrian
ChubbyMooshroom9
Hippophant
Nellyfox
VucubCaquix
Swordsworth

Optimal scumplay here is to kill me, then one of the non-suspects. With that said, take today to deeply analyze Nelly, Vucub, Hippophant, and TiltedComedian. Revise all the facts. Turn this case on its head. Tell everyone who you think is the Godfather, and why. Cite evidence. We have three lynches and four suspects. There is little to no margin for error.

aaaaaa

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

Alright captain swords, ill do thatbp after my 10 hour car ride.

[Tiltedcomedian]

As a heads-up, I'll be away Saturday if we haven't finished discussing by then.

[Nellyfox]

I WOKE UP BECAUSE MY BODY WAS LIKE TILTED IS SCUM BUT I DON'T KNOW WHY AND I'M SCARED

Someone hold me
I feel uncomfortable with this logic but if it's true then I say lynch Vucub first??

Do not lynch me at all thanks
I've scum hunted a lot and helped bust like half the mafia and after NK dying D2 why would I do that especially so strongly
If I recall correctly Vucub defended notCalm very oddly and I need to get on my laptop ugh

[Nellyfox]

1. We aren't lynching NCYT, because NC can still be town. End of story. That should be cleared up tonight, so we don't have to worry. No taking risks.
2. Where was our roleblock last night? Should've been on NC again. If it wasn't we have a problem.
3. No broadcasting who Murat blocks. As I recall, any mafia can make the kill, so telling Murat what to do is counterproductive. Unless its to block the framer, which is pointless now.
4. Nelly's night plan is.... :/

Murat roleblock:

25% cmit
25% NC
50% Between Hippo, TC, and Chubby. Use judgement.

We have a small chance of blocking it.

There's this

Jfc nelly what are you even doing. If he's town your practically confirmed scum.

and this

neither really make a whole lot of sense

hippo:

We lynched the witch day 3. Try again.

forgot days came before nights, not the other way around.,

Honestly probably Jacko. It would explain how the mafia knew he was the bomber. I'm just saying.

also im grasping at straws now

i don't really feel like pulling out much but the last line is what gets me

the whole inner tilted is scum thing comes from his roleblock i think

anyway
i want everyone to list in order what happened to them every single night. this is an order; i need to dissect the spy visits more and i don't want to dig through the thread because OP not updated :c

[Tiltedcomedian]

I WOKE UP BECAUSE MY BODY WAS LIKE TILTED IS SCUM BUT I DON'T KNOW WHY AND I'M SCARED

Someone hold me
I feel uncomfortable with this logic but if it's true then I say lynch Vucub first??

Do not lynch me at all thanks
I've scum hunted a lot and helped bust like half the mafia and after NK dying D2 why would I do that especially so strongly
If I recall correctly Vucub defended notCalm very oddly and I need to get on my laptop ugh

OK, not at all comfortable with this. Or Nelly's sudden uptick in activity or her "I trust Tilted" suddenly turning to this, see also my point about mafia being in gambit territory.

Jord is a dead horse.

Vucub...well, remembering what Arc said when the stereotypically scummy are the main suspects, something is wrong. It isn't quite the PbPA you asked for, Swords, but it's a starting point.

[Nellyfox]

This game could be over if we knew one thing, but we don't. And I realized it this morning when I woke up. We could clear someone right now if everyone just tells me what happened to them every night.

I'm not sure where everyone is, but they need to get back here.

[Nellyfox]

Jord what happened to you every night

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

Tilted what do you mean dead horse..


sorry its my stupid hour

Useless.

[Swordsworth]

I slept peacefully all but N2

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

I've only slept peacefully.

[Nellyfox]

Vucub, I see you. Answer ASAP.

[VucubCaquix]

Neato.

Pretty sure your all wrong and Chubby is the last mafia. Here's why.

1. On night 6, Alzar was killed. A strange choice, considering an investigator was still alive, as well as an escort. Why would they do this? The spy was practically useless.
2. Chubby was chosen as investigation target the night before Chubby was investigated by Retral. The mafia knew this was going to happen.
3. Known framer NC was not roleblocked during night 6, as TC was roleblocked that night. Meaning a framer was free to do whatever he wanted that night.
4. The framer must have visited Chubby that night. There just isn't any way they wouldn't send the framer towards Chubby. Why wouldn't they take advantage of this and frame Chubby as Cit/GF? The only reason I can think of is that Chubby was actually the godfather.

This explains the weird kill order as well as NC's medium claims. I want to look into his ISO but I think this is correct.

[Nellyfox]

Hey Vucub, want to answer my question?