Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]

[notCalmYT]

/vote notCalmYT
Let's lynch the guy not reading the thread and wanting to lynch the proven Investigator.
I'm fine with this gambit.

Shouldn't be a gambit if you're Invest. Scum slip found. bb

/unvote
/vote Retral

[RetralMega]

/vote notCalmYT
Let's lynch the guy not reading the thread and wanting to lynch the proven Investigator.
I'm fine with this gambit.

Shouldn't be a gambit if you're Invest. Scum slip found. bb

/unvote
/vote Retral

If you're Town, you're never living this moment down.

[notCalmYT]

/vote notCalmYT
Let's lynch the guy not reading the thread and wanting to lynch the proven Investigator.
I'm fine with this gambit.

Shouldn't be a gambit if you're Invest. Scum slip found. bb

/unvote
/vote Retral

If you're Town, you're never living this moment down.

I can be the only one that knows you're not legit Town. Why should I be wrong about you and Nelly? And even if you found Evil, probably you just bussed him. It was the plan and you couldn't go against it.

Hippo could've been framed tonight. What do you say about it?

[RetralMega]

/vote notCalmYT
Let's lynch the guy not reading the thread and wanting to lynch the proven Investigator.
I'm fine with this gambit.

Shouldn't be a gambit if you're Invest. Scum slip found. bb

/unvote
/vote Retral

If you're Town, you're never living this moment down.

I can be the only one that knows you're not legit Town. Why should I be wrong about you and Nelly? And even if you found Evil, probably you just bussed him. It was the plan and you couldn't go against it.

Hippo could've been framed tonight. What do you say about it?

K.

[notCalmYT]

Obv scum reaction found. I finally figured out his plan after all this time and he started pushing the vote on me. Not even answering questions. When I flip Medium he will have his lovely mislynch, but now it's too late because we already know who your GF is.

surrender

[RetralMega]

I'm fucking dying of laughter.
I'm going to continue my anime.

[notCalmYT]

I'm fucking dying of laughter.
I'm going to continue my anime.

run, run away you little scummy scum scum.

[RetralMega]

If I am scum, who takes my slot?
Who takes Nelly's slot if we're buddies?

[notCalmYT]

If I am scum, who takes my slot?
Who takes Nelly's slot if we're buddies?

me
another cit claim

[RetralMega]

If I am scum, who takes my slot?
Who takes Nelly's slot if we're buddies?

me
another cit claim

So lynching me or you 100% proves the other?
What about the other RTs? How is it me rather than one of them?

[notCalmYT]

If I am scum, who takes my slot?
Who takes Nelly's slot if we're buddies?

me
another cit claim

So lynching me or you 100% proves the other?
What about the other RTs? How is it me rather than one of them?

I've been blocked, so it's obv Murat is Escort. Spy has proven himself several times. Chubby is the only TK claim, can't be RT.
It's me or you obv, if they lynch you I'll finally be confirmed Medium. No more meta shibble.

[Nellyfox]

This is so funny!
Buddy if you think you're so smart for thinking Hippo is framed, you clearly missed my giant analysis piece I did earlier. Do check them and then come back.

Also if I'm Godfather then Hippo or cmitc takes my place, but do you really believe either of them are town?

[notCalmYT]

This is so funny!
Buddy if you think you're so smart for thinking Hippo is framed, you clearly missed my giant analysis piece I did earlier. Do check them and then come back.

Also if I'm Godfather then Hippo or cmitc takes my place, but do you really believe either of them are town?

I don't trust Godfather's analisys. Let's lynch Hippo or Cmtic then. Then we can get your head on a fork!

[Nellyfox]

"i know everything"
"retral is scum and jacko isn't the bomber"
"you're the godfather lol"

right?
Anyway, just humour me a bit. Go back and read my analysis, and tell me what's wrong with it. 12 size font, double space, Times New Roman, cite your sources. 3, 2, 1, go!

[notCalmYT]

Now let's talk about the Citizens.

There are six slots. If we use the role list above, Salense has to be Citizen because there is no room (or Chubby is lying about being Veteran).
Those claiming citizen are: Nellyfox, Tilted, Vucub, cmitc, Hippo, Jord, Swords.
To Retral: I came back as Citizen, as well as Jord and Hippo. Supports my theory
To Elusive: Vucub and Swords came back as citizen.
Cmitc came back framed.

Now let's work through these.

Since Salense is Citizen, there are five remaining slots and seven people fighting over them.
Both myself and Vucub came back as Citizen when we were not visited by the mafia. Retral could be lying about, noone else has investigated you.
When Cmitc was framed, he was also roleblocked, and there were no kills.
Jord and Swords are like me and Vucub.
Tilted is unknown.

Now let's work out the spy visits.

N1: leyva x2 (attacked/cleaned), retral (?)
N2: salense x2 (attacked/cleaned), arckas (?), jord (?)
N3: cmitc (framed?), retral (blackmailer)
N4: santa (killed), tilt (?)
N5: elusive (killed), hip (?), tilt (?)

So we have a lot of unknowns because we don't know what the Framer or Blackmailer have done. But we know one thing: the janitor has been making the kills since night 4.
I think it is safe to say, based on inactivity and the roleblock, cmitc is Godfather. Now we have six people fighting over five citizen slots. This part makes absolutely no sense. How you know Janitor makes the kill? Maybe it's someone else. Scumslip.

Now that we believe cmitc is Godfather, this clears everyone else. Except for Hippo.

Why isn't Hippo clear? Simple: she was visited the night she came up as Citizen/Godfather. Framer can change what role players come up to Investigator.
Now, if Hippo was citizen, the mafia would try and make it look like she is scum. She would not have come up as citizen/godfather, because they'd want us to mislynch her. Instead, she came back as what she claimed, to try and protect her. Since Elusive was assigned to check Tilted, they wouldn't waste a frame on him since they killed Elusive the same night.

Which now makes the role list this:

Spoiler: Town Invest - Investigator, Elusive
Town Protective - BodyGuard, Santa
Town Support - Escort, Murat
Town Killing - Veteran, Chubby
Random Town - Doctor, Downie
Random Town - Investigator - Retral (swap this to Framer)
Random Town - Spy, Alzar
Citizen - Salense
Citizen - Nellyfox (swap this to GF)
Citizen - VucubCaquix
Citizen - Swordsworth
Citizen - Jordarrian
Citizen - Tiltedcomedian

Godfather - cmitc1 (swap this to Janitor/Cit)
Mafia Tactical - Blackmailer, Evil
Random Mafia - Framer, notCalm (swap this to Medium)
Random Mafia - Janitor - Hippophant (swap this to Janitor/Cit)

Witch - ronit
Bomber - Jacko
Arsonist - Leyva
Which means night 1, Retral was visited by the blackmailer.
Now the spy visits are like this:

N1: leyva x2 (attacked/cleaned), retral (blackmailer) why not framed? scumslip
N2: salense x2 (attacked/cleaned), arckas (?), jord (?)
N3: cmitc (framed), retral (blackmailer)
N4: santa (killed), tilt (?)
N5: elusive (killed), hip (framed), tilt (blackmailer)

Am I missing anything?

You missed the night I was framed and found as Framer. Nelly, there are a few thing you assumed as true but they are absolutely NOT confirmed. Care to explain? You're being overconfident with the information we have, which is usually something Mafia does due to the fact they actually know everything in this game.

[notCalmYT]

"i know everything" this is true. I also know that you're scum
"retral is scum and jacko isn't the bomber" I thought the bomber was in the Cit claims. My mistake. But Mafia did know about the Bomber all along. So, explain why you knew it was Jacko all along?
"you're the godfather lol" This isn't a direct quote. Making it seem like a childish statement you're understimating my accusations. I do believe you and Retral are scum buddies.

right?
Anyway, just humour me a bit. Go back and read my analysis, and tell me what's wrong with it. 12 size font, double space, Times New Roman, cite your sources. 3, 2, 1, go!

Now answer to this if you care:

1) Have you ever seen an Investigator that reveals himself after finding a Cit/GF day 2, even if he wasn't ever accused?
2) Why do you make such bold and clear statements about who Mafia visited on a certain night? And why you forgot that I was framed once? Was it because I'm one of the 2 mislynches Mafia needs to catch up in this game? Is the other the one you know isn't Mafia between Hippo and Cmtic? Who do you suspect the most between the two?
3) How do you explain the message datdownie sent to me?
4) Why is a non confirmed Citizen carrying the game and bossing around, pretending to know everything? Citizen doesn't know shit of what is happening. Look at Jord, he's posting just to avoid being prodded. GF knows.

@Jord read Nelly's statement. There's no visit from Framer to me, or Arckas, even if it's confirmed by the fact that I was found as Framer. Are you that blind?

[Nellyfox]

Mafia can use their role on themselves. :o

All right, so, your points, in order:

- What theory?
- No one has been checked twice, your point?
- How do I know? Because Cmitc isn't killing because he's been a roleblock target and no one has been cleaned. Tell me what the Spy visits are, if you will.
- Role list stuff: Cmitc and Hippo can't both be town, so who is it?
- Why not framed? Because you were roleblocked. You're using outdated Spy results too because I forgot information - Tilted was tracked by the blackmailer night 4.

"i know everything" this is true. I also know that you're scum
"retral is scum and jacko isn't the bomber" I thought the bomber was in the Cit claims. My mistake. But Mafia did know about the Bomber all along. So, explain why you knew it was Jacko all along?
"you're the godfather lol" This isn't a direct quote. Making it seem like a childish statement you're understimating my accusations. I do believe you and Retral are scum buddies.

right?
Anyway, just humour me a bit. Go back and read my analysis, and tell me what's wrong with it. 12 size font, double space, Times New Roman, cite your sources. 3, 2, 1, go!

Now answer to this if you care:

1) Have you ever seen an Investigator that reveals himself after finding a Cit/GF day 2, even if he wasn't ever accused?
2) Why do you make such bold and clear statements about who Mafia visited on a certain night? And why you forgot that I was framed once? Was it because I'm one of the 2 mislynches Mafia needs to catch up in this game? Is the other the one you know isn't Mafia between Hippo and Cmtic? Who do you suspect the most between the two?
3) How do you explain the message datdownie sent to me?
4) Why is a non confirmed Citizen carrying the game and bossing around, pretending to know everything? Citizen doesn't know shit of what is happening. Look at Jord, he's posting just to avoid being prodded. GF knows.

@Jord read Nelly's statement. There's no visit from Framer to me, or Arckas, even if it's confirmed by the fact that I was found as Framer. Are you that blind?

1)

You're being overconfident with the information we have, which is usually something Mafia does due to the fact they actually know everything in this game.

So why doesn't this apply to you?
2) When did I think it was Jacko? I thought it was you or Downie (you more though). I trusted Jacko because of Evil.
3) You keep boasting how you know everything, which too is really childish.

1) I revealed day 2 in episode 5 after finding Metrion as a Lookout/Stalker when he requested a Lookout...listen, people play roles differently, smart or not.
2) Because that's what I believe? Why do you make such bold statements about me and Retral being Mafia? Cmitc was also framed (Hippo too, by my analysis), is he town too?
3) A bunch of lies desperately trying to prove you, I guess.
4) Maybe because all of the confirmed town is lazing around doing nothing....I've been complaining about that for a while. I have town's best interest in mind so I'm making sure the thread doesn't die because it's been so slow lately. But hey, if you think I'm wrong, you do the analysis and PoE for the role list. I'll be waiting.

[notCalmYT]

I'm not being overconfident. I'm reading into the list.

There's a difference between finding Lookout/Stalker and Cit/GF.

Town has been lazy. I've been lazy aswell. But I can't let GF carry Town. Not in my Town.

Prove you're not the GF and tell me who is GF between Hippo and Cmtic. Let's vote for it, and if it flips not-GF then you go down tomorrow.

[Alzar]

this isn't your fucking town, it's mine. get out

[Nellyfox]

Haven't I proven that already? By analyzing the claims, actions, and other investigative information we have?
With my analysis I showed how Cmitc is Godfather, you are Framer, and Hippo is janitor. Why don't you prove how you aren't Framer?

Oh, and I'm only confident because of all the stuff I did.

[Swordsworth]

NotCalm, I thought you were a Medium.

[Swordsworth]

I'm not being overconfident. I'm reading into the list.

There's a difference between finding Lookout/Stalker and Cit/GF.

Town has been lazy. I've been lazy aswell. But I can't let GF carry Town. Not in my Town.

Prove you're not the GF and tell me who is GF between Hippo and Cmtic. Let's vote for it, and if it flips not-GF then you go down tomorrow.

Burden of proof lies with the accuser. You PROVE that Nelly is the Godfather. The rest of us have already PROVED you are a member of the mafia, being mechanically locked as scum with an impossible claim, with all neutrals dead.

[Swordsworth]

If I am scum, who takes my slot?
Who takes Nelly's slot if we're buddies?

me
another cit claim

So lynching me or you 100% proves the other?
What about the other RTs? How is it me rather than one of them?

I've been blocked, so it's obv Murat is Escort. Spy has proven himself several times. Chubby is the only TK claim, can't be RT.
It's me or you obv, if they lynch you I'll finally be confirmed Medium. No more meta shibble.

This doesn't come from town.

Sorry for the triple post.

[murat1996]

I'm not being overconfident. I'm reading into the list.

There's a difference between finding Lookout/Stalker and Cit/GF.

Town has been lazy. I've been lazy aswell. But I can't let GF carry Town. Not in my Town.

Prove you're not the GF and tell me who is GF between Hippo and Cmtic. Let's vote for it, and if it flips not-GF then you go down tomorrow.

This way of thinking pretty much confirms you to be scum even more.

And this isn't your town as YOU are not confirmed town. So stop double casting already.

[VucubCaquix]

Just end the day. We win either way, so there's no point arguing over it.