FM Ep. III "Short Days, Unlucky Mafia and GIFs" - Arso Wins

[Metrion]

Hiphoplog claims Survivor
This is a mistake. You should never claim a role early unless forced to reveal - even if you are a neutral. If he was an actual survivor, he would want to stay quiet and not reveal as killing roles do not count on Survivors to help with votes as Survivors typically side with the Town. Therefore, best not to reveal, especially as he was an Amnesiac, not a Survivor. Therefore, once he reveals, it becomes obvious that he was lying, thus becoming a target for investigative roles. He becomes a target as Survivor becomes an impossibility once the Serial Killer and Arsonist roles are established - he was either the Amnesiac or a liar - either way, a suspicious player that evil roles could capitalize upon to place an accusation on and if not get lynched, at least remove suspicion from themselves. Therefore, best to not say anything and have the evil roles have to deal with an extra townie once he becomes one - or just wait it out to become an evil role himself and try to win by himself, or join the mafia, unless they all die on the same night.

I'd argue that this is a good stratigy or atleast neutral. The execution in this game was sub par, no offence Hip, but it worked amazingly in Game B. Fooled even the SK into attacking the real survivor. Also in all games prior the survivor revealed early.

[Salense]

Claiming Survivor is fine if you are actually the survivor. If you are any other role you cause the town to focus on the neutrals instead of the actual evil roles. This causes a SailorNeptune situation where town had no clue who any of the evil roles were on Day 3.

[Alicitzen]

Claiming Survivor is fine if you are actually the survivor. If you are any other role you cause the town to focus on the neutrals instead of the actual evil roles. This causes a SailorNeptune situation where town had no clue who any of the evil roles were on Day 3.

Dont dis the strategy until you try it.

[LordofFail]

I say it was an error looking at the big picture: He was not the Survivor.

When he claims a role, if it is anything other than a town role, he will have a hard time shaking the suspicion off himself. If he claims a town role, the is suspicion on himself as he may have been lying about Survivor.

[Salense]

The main thing that killed the mafia this game was inactivity. Yak chose the worst time to not be online. For if you read mafia chat we changed our mind on who to attack but Yak wasn't online to change his target.

[Yak]

The main thing that killed the mafia this game was inactivity. Yak chose the worst time to not be online. For if you read mafia chat we changed our mind on who to attack but Yak wasn't online to change his target.

Sorry about that, but it's not that often that you party all night for graduating high school

[SailorNeptune]

Claiming Survivor is fine if you are actually the survivor. If you are any other role you cause the town to focus on the neutrals instead of the actual evil roles. This causes a SailorNeptune situation where town had no clue who any of the evil roles were on Day 3.

You named a situation about me, I feel special. ^ - ^

[Guzame]

Congratulations Duck, you get a nice blue name. The only one on the forum until an episode 4 happens.

[Duck]

Congratulations Duck, you get a nice blue name. The only one on the forum until an episode 4 happens.

im special!!!

[RoyTheHero]

wat is this and how do i join in?

[Veeena]

wat is this and how do i join in?

Go to the 'Signup' board and choose what game you want to join in by posting /join

NOTE: all games are active now and you can only join BACKUPS (AKA: you can't play unless someone decided to quit or is prodded out of the game). I'd suggest Game D as the other one has a long line of backups.

[RoyTheHero]

wat is this and how do i join in?

Go to the 'Signup' board and choose what game you want to join in by posting /join

NOTE: all games are active now and you can only join BACKUPS (AKA: you can't play unless someone decided to quit or is prodded out of the game). I'd suggest Game D as the other one has a long line of backups.

k thx maxwell....hmmmm milla maxwell
also i think its full already

[Veeena]

wat is this and how do i join in?

Go to the 'Signup' board and choose what game you want to join in by posting /join

NOTE: all games are active now and you can only join BACKUPS (AKA: you can't play unless someone decided to quit or is prodded out of the game). I'd suggest Game D as the other one has a long line of backups.

k thx m4xwell....hmmmm milla m4xwell

Second note: Since Game D Replacements thread is locked, you must contact PoisonMaid that you will be a potential Joiner in her game if one decides to quit or prod out (PM)

[RoyTheHero]

Second note: Since Game D Replacements thread is locked, you must contact PoisonMaid that you will be a potential Joiner in her game if one decides to quit or prod out (PM)

k thx agian,and can i call you milla maxwell?

[Veeena]

Second note: Since Game D Replacements thread is locked, you must contact PoisonMaid that you will be a potential Joiner in her game if one decides to quit or prod out (PM)

k thx agian,and can i call you milla m4xwell?

Yes. So much yes.

[LeScraf]

I read through this all, and it took an hour.
By comparison, Murphy's Law took three
Very well played, Duck.

[LordofFail]

[Rickdaily12]

Good game, everyone.

Excuse me while I put these games in order, though.