Town of Salem Game Forums

IF WE BELIEVE STELLA

One Anti Town:
TheCow
Leyva
Stella
Melanora
SirCakez

Three Anti Town:
Nellyfox
TheNinja475
Knockoff
tfiosforevah
RockFire - Confirmed Town by Mel
nighthawk101

Now that we have ALL of the information, this is my thought:

Group One : TheCow or Leyva
Group Two: Nelly, Ninja, Nighthawk, Tfios

Those are the possible scum/sk imo.

Town In My Eyes:
Stella [bc if not town we're fucked tbh]
Deleter/Cakez
Knockoff
Rockfire [confirmed]

So, we have Six possible scum there. we lynch the one we think is SK, then have Rock and the other five vote to lynch. We use Stella's ability to see how many of them are anti-town, and pray we did get the SK. We'll def get those results in her death note in case they try to kill her.

The only question left is who is the SK and I still say it's either Nelly or Ninja.

Lynching from Group One is not a good idea at all tbh. So, don't recommend we lynch from them unless you are 99% sure they are sk.

It's safe to say that tfios is lying now that we have the results, so that's an easy lynch.

And Leyva did visit K1ll to give them a syringe. The SK kills being undetectable clears Leyva of suspicion of being the SK at least. Now, I need to know something. Mel, you gave Sircakez the syringe, so tonight Deleter can do two actions, right? Okay, I think that we can still salvage this, but everyone needs to help me make a night plan to the letter. I'll draft one right away.

melanora wrote:Were you transported or targets traded or anything like that? This is super fucking important.

Because it legit looks like OH WAIT A MINuTE LEYVA

wait. hold up.

holy shit holy shit holy shit.

Okay so no switching, and leyva visited the guy that dies?!

If my targets were switched, Metrion didn't tell me about it. I wasn't informed that I have a syringe either.

So K1ll must have not been able to swap if it was on person.....
The action. Is compulsory so it would have to have happened unless they were RB'ed....

Well, I figured it out. Cow had to have RB'ed K1ll, which means Nelly is lying about being RB'ed.

That means the Mafia is TheCow, Nelly, and tfios since no one else was redirected. That should be double checked today though with Stella.

RockFire wrote:It's safe to say that tfios is lying now that we have the results, so that's an easy lynch.

And Leyva did visit K1ll to give them a syringe. The SK kills being undetectable clears Leyva of suspicion of being the SK at least. Now, I need to know something. Mel, you gave Sircakez the syringe, so tonight Deleter can do two actions, right? Okay, I think that we can still salvage this, but everyone needs to help me make a night plan to the letter. I'll draft one right away.

How does that clear Levya? Just because we can't see the SK kill doesn't mean we can't see the SK's other actions.

Deleter wrote:

melanora wrote:Were you transported or targets traded or anything like that? This is super fucking important.

Because it legit looks like OH WAIT A MINuTE LEYVA

wait. hold up.

holy shit holy shit holy shit.

Okay so no switching, and leyva visited the guy that dies?!

If my targets were switched, Metrion didn't tell me about it. I wasn't informed that I have a syringe either.

Wait, what? No, I definitely passed you a syringe.

@Met. Umm??? Did my syringe not pass?

RockFire wrote:So K1ll must have not been able to swap if it was on person.....
The action. Is compulsory so it would have to have happened unless they were RB'ed....

Well, I figured it out. Cow had to have RB'ed K1ll, which means Nelly is lying about being RB'ed.

That means the Mafia is TheCow, Nelly, and tfios since no one else was redirected. That should be double checked today though with Stella.

Just... hold up a few here Rockfire. I'm really confused because I DEFINITELY sent a message saying to give my Syringe to Cakez, and Deleter apparently doesn't have the syringe. Just... give it a few.

And why would tfios claim to be redirected? To get knockoff lynched? That sounds terrible. One of the scum should have claimed with him. That would be the worst plan imaginable.

And what do you suppose happened? if I was the original target than why did it get switched around the day I happen to be attacked? Who else could K1ll have possibly redirected their action on? We had very few people with night actions to be redirected in the first place unless TheCow was redirected and doesn't want to tell us. Night gave stella a letter. That confirms that action. Who would be a logical switch?

Rock, I don't know, but while I don't want to assume here that Metrion made a mistake... I definitely have a message in my sent folder that says pass the Syringe to SirCakez... and Deleter claims to not have it. That means either Deleter is lying or Metrion forgot to tell him. Maybe Met didn't mention the redirect either. Idk. I'm just saying hold on a second because I KNOW THAT I SAID PASS THE SYRINGE and Deleter doesn't have it.

Alright, the waiting shall commence. Hopefully Met won't take too long to give us the answer.

However, I still think that those three are Mafia now. Something about Nelly and Cow's fighting seems fabricated to me. Also, I'm just paranoid that the Mafia has 4 votes and not 3.

... Oh god I didn't even think about that.

Shit. Shit okay.

IF IT TURNS OUT HE WAS RBd...

We have those three plus you plus me? plus one of the other possible lynch targets vote to lynch the one we think is SK. It's Ninja at this point, I think.

Metrion has confirmed to me in PM that I have a syringe and he forgot to say. Problem solved, move along and let me scan the thread.

Well then, looks like we have our scum team.

Rockfire Town MVP.

Well, that solves that.

Having said that, here's the night plan regardless if Ninja is the SK or not:
Mel- Interrogate Nellyfox
Leyva- Give a syringe to Deleter
Deleter- Use your syringe to watch both Cow and tfios tonight
Night- Contract TheCow

If Ninja is not the SK than I hope the SK realizes they have to start killing Mafia to win, so they should kill tfios.

If we're correct and Nelly comes up as not Town, we should lynch straight away. That's a problem that we don't want. And with this, we should have everyone bring looked at, so seeing a visit will definitely tell us what we need to know.

Everyone keep a last will, no exceptions. This is down to the wire, but we can still salvage it.

And mel, hopefully that's the case, but the checks will make sure.

If I am right on everything, than everyone should be lynched in this order:
Nellyfox
TheCow
Tfios

Also, because I need to cover all my bases:
tfios: Watch Mel
TheCow: RB Knockoff

Just in case you thought that I'd forgotten. Remember, a lack of compliance equals a noose around your neck.

Sounds good to me. In the off chance that Ninja is not SK, we'll go from there with Night or Levya, but I'm pretty sure it's Ninja.

I am not lying about being role blocked.
If I'm being interrogated tonight expect a town result. I would rather you interrogate someone else we suspect to be mafia, though.

Hypothetically, if I were town and wrongly killed at some point here, can we still win? Will my death reveal important information that will help us find scum?

Nelly, 3 out of the group of the 5 of you are scum. If we check you and you are Town, we lower that group to 3 out of 4. We know tfios is mafia anyway. Meaning we have a high chance of catching scum. This is in all our benefit and Cow, if you're innocent than I haven't seen it at all. Nothing you've done has convinced me and tomorrow will be 5v3. If you truly are Town Cow then speak up because this is down to the wire. I don't think I'd believe you though. From the way your acting, the only other suspect would be Leyva because I believe everyone else is strong Town.

Just follow my night plan and if you're innocent than we will prove it because you'll RB the other person who could have killed. While I trust knock, I'm trying to account for all variables.

Seeing as I'm not expendable, I'll make a defense when I get into my pc, which will be after breakfast.

Cow... sweetheart... you're not even being lynched until like Day 5.

And here's the thing, Stella is still going to be watching today's lynch as well. If you vote and so does the rest of who we think are scum, and only 1-2 come back anti town... let's say that 2 come back anti town, and Nelly comes back mafia tonight, that means you're in the clear and we were wrong.

But we're not. Follow the plan. Or else get lynched. If you're not scum, that will be revealed before we go to lynch you.

Have fun getting the town result on me then, Mel.

Also...has anyone ever thought that the SK or a mafia member were redirected (not tfios, of course) and just kept quiet about it ?

Or we could have other people vote that we're unsure of while Mel checks Nelly. That would probably help us out in the long run. What we could do is have Night, Cow, tfios, I, Mel, and Deleter vote and have Mel check Nelly. If one of the three is missing than we know it's Leyva or Knock. If more than one is missing we know it's both.

I think that would be a better plan to cover all our bases just in case. It'll give us the most information to work with anyway.

Nellyfox wrote:Have fun getting the town result on me then, Mel.

Also...has anyone ever thought that the SK or a mafia member were redirected (not tfios, of course) and just kept quiet about it ?

This has occurred to me 100%. I'm really pissed, tbh, that k1ll didn't leave a damn last will. This is why you always leave one. Which is why we're checking you - you're our double voter. IF YOU FLIP TOWN then you are our most valuable asset. If you flip scum, you're our biggest take down target. It also shows us one step closer to possible scum regardless.