CFM6 | The Glorious Evolution | Cowgod Died For Our Sins

[ObiWan]

Just because you replaced him - doesn't mean we can just erase what scummy things he's said from our minds.
I'd be comparing/analyzing both had you not been doused

[BirdyThePhoenix]

And what is Obi's role? Because everyone seems to think that he is for sure scum.

[Arcthurus]

And what is Obi's role? Because everyone seems to think that he is for sure scum.

Well if you at least read the goddamn thread you would know he's a phantom.

[BirdyThePhoenix]

And what is Obi's role? Because everyone seems to think that he is for sure scum.

Well if you at least read the goddamn thread you would know he's a phantom.

Well excuse me I am trying to.

[Arcthurus]

@Akame, Great, Marco and Dizzy: What are your thoughts on the recent developments? Who do you think is scum and who do you think is town?

[ValeforRaine]

arcthurus is whispering to melanora! [1/4]
Akame is whispering to Gobble124! [2/4]
melanora is whispering to ObiWan! [1/4]
melanora is whispering to Neasans! [0/4]

A woodpecker drops from the sky and pecks out melanora's voice box!

[Greatplayer01]

Welcome birdy!
Good luck trying to get off the scum pit that chit put himself into...
Also, hardclaiming cit huh? Hmm. I gotta write that down..

@arc: Define how recent developments.

As for scum, I'd mainly say it's bumble & cow for sure.
As for townies, I'd say mela, vucub, and gobble. You are also starting to get a Town read for me.

[Arcthurus]

Welcome birdy!
Good luck trying to get off the scum pit that chit put himself into...
Also, hardclaiming cit huh? Hmm. I gotta write that down..

@arc: Define how recent developments.

As for scum, I'd mainly say it's bumble & cow for sure.
As for townies, I'd say mela, vucub, and gobble. You are also starting to get a Town read for me.

Pretty much everything that happened Day 3 - or at least in the past 24~ish hours.

I also find it interesting you consider Chit to be in a "scum pit" but doesn't list him/birdy as scum.

[Akame]

@Akame, Great, Marco and Dizzy: What are your thoughts on the recent developments? Who do you think is scum and who do you think is town?

I think bird, Marco, Pretzel and Great are scum. I think Gobble, Vucub, dat, Neasans and Mel are town.

[ValeforRaine]

Vote Count:

ObiWan (3): ObiWan, Gobble124, Akame

16 players alive, 9 needed for majority.

[Greatplayer01]

As I did with you, I want to let a period of time to replacements to reinforce/change the read I have on them.
For me, it is not very right (in FM) to judge someone from the person replaced. They could have been scummy, but the truth could be, they're Town. So I'll give birdy a chance, before I get a town/scum read.

[melanora]

How many times should I bang my head into the wall before this starts making sense?


My suspicions had to do with more than waffle's inactivity, although that was certainly part of it. Any time that he was here, nothing that he was offering was pro-town. When he was here, he basically just said "oh I forgot". ... ... ... what? And then he would give half of a reply, and disappear again. Waffle's behavior was the epitome of scum trying to lay low.

That stated, Arc has stepped into the game and had a real moving presence here. It doesn't ERASE the fact that I found waffle to be scummy, however, I'm not going to condemn Arc for it.


The same cannot be said for birdy. If we were not already lynching Obi, I would have voted long ago to lynch chit. There would have been no need for a replacement. The fact that birdy walked in and KNEW that chit was under suspicion but has no understanding as to what is going on, it seems... I mean why would you just randomly claim the second you walk into a game when you have no idea what's going on? We were not going to lynch you the second you joined. That would just be rude. We would have given you the chance to catch up and lodge a defense.

But instead, birdy just claims Citizen. And THAT to me is scummy.

But, it doesn't matter for today's day phase. That stated... RB should definitely get on that.

[Arcthurus]

Mel did you read my whisper?
Can you just state with either a yes or no if what I said makes sense?

[bumblecow]

... Didn't chit say that he had only just received his role card and Scraf was like no everyone got it at the same time?

That was my night results.

[melanora]

-rolls in to arc-

I 1000% meant to reply to your whisper in thread and then completely forgot about it as I went on a mini rant.

Basically what you listed is why I'm thinking it's Mafia attributed, however, I do not think what you think of the last person you mentioned. I'm thinking Neutral still. I'm thinking Jester, actually. But, we'll see. Tonight will reveal a lot, I think.

[melanora]

Really, before we take any more steps forward, we need to talk about what's going to happen tomorrow. Tonight, we might have the Random Neutral revealed. If not, RN had best be stepping up and out soon, or else I'm going to assume Bomber.

Everyone needs to me doing some serious reads. Like, pay attention to what has happened with each step. Whether or not I die, whether or not you have a power role, everyone should have a read. Nes' list was perfect, but all of like half of us did it, if even that many. And anyone that isn't contributing? If we have any TI left, get on that. We've already lost too many town, and unless Mafia hits Neutral or gets blocked tonight, we are going to lose someone else tonight. If the Arso douses, we could be fucked.

Town is at an impasse here. We lose any more without at least having some idea as to where we are going... I'm going to say that the top of the suspicious list should be Cow, Bumble, and Chit/Birdy. It's tough luck what you walked into Birdy, but that's the way it is. Regardless, those that are doused are not important. DO NOT LET THEM GET YOU OFF TRACK. Ignore them if you must. Pretend like they're Jester. Until we find the Arso, they really don't matter.

Four people total I trust, and that's not a lot. They're listed in my will, but I also think it's pretty obvious who I trust right now. Good luck to all of you, and I hope we don't get fucked.

[melanora]

Now, with that being said... Myself, Downie, and Neasan will not be voting. Or at least, shouldn't be voting. That way scum will not know who has the phantom. If you object to lynching Obi at this point, consider yourself lynchable tomorrow.

Go ahead and get this voting rolling.

[TheCow]

/vote obi

[VucubCaquix]

/vote Obi

[bumblecow]

/vote Obi

[Arcthurus]

I'll hold off from voting for now - we still have slightly over a day left.
There's no need to rush.

[pretzellover33]

/vote obiwan

ok i'm pretty sure if there's a stalker when we lynch obi somebody will commit suicide unless they were killed already
because

starts stalking D1, then four phases

1. N1
2. D2
3. N2
4. D3

[melanora]

That's what I'm thinking, Pretzel, unless we got lucky and one of the dead was being stalked.

[ValeforRaine]

Vote Count:

ObiWan (7): ObiWan, Gobble124, Akame, TheCow, VucubCaquix, bumblecow, pretzellover33

16 players alive, 9 needed for majority.

[Greatplayer01]

That is the best case scenario.
Vale, if someone is stalked D1, do we see their death at the end of D3?

Well, lemme add another wagon to the Obi-Lynch Train..
/vote ObiWan